Should I Wear a Helmet Today?

bakfiets_naparstek.jpgThe Naparstek boys riding last year’s Summer Streets event… wearing helmets.

Sarah’s "Too Much Emphasis on Safety" post yesterday brings up the question in the headline above.

A
Canadian Broadcasting TV crew doing a documentary on biking is filming
me as I take my two sons to school on our Dutch cargo bike today. While
the kids always wear helmets, and I do too when I’m commuting or riding
longer distances, I often don’t bother to wear one when I’m taking the
kids to school in the bakfiets (also known around our house as the Cadillac Bikescalade). 

There
are a few reasons why I tend to go helmetless. First, I’m a pretty
careful, slow-riding cyclist in general, and even more so when I’m
carrying kids. The ride to school is a short trip on residential
streets marked almost entirely with bike lanes in a neighborhood where
motorists are relatively respectful and aware of bikes. Walking across
a street at an intersection with two young kids in tow often feels more dangerous.

Second,
getting the kids out the door in the morning involves quite a bit of
schlepping and hassle as it is. My own helmet sometimes just gets lost
in the shuffle (as does my four-year-old’s lunch). If the two-year-old
is whiny or we’re running late I’m not turning back to get the helmet.
It’s all about momentum.

Finally, I just don’t like the way the helmet looks
when I’m riding the bakfiets. This is less and issue of fashion
(because lord knows I have no fashion sense) and more, I think, an
issue of public perception.

The first time I ever saw a cargo bike in action was on my U.S.-German Marshall fellowship trip to Copenhagen in 2006.
In Copenhagen I saw people using cargo bikes to cart their kids all
over the place. I rarely saw an adult wearing a helmet. It made an
impression on me. This lack of protective headgear — or any special
bike gear, for that matter — is one of the things that, to my eye,
made biking in Copenhagen seem so remarkably convenient, casual, safe
and part of regular daily life. It didn’t matter what you’re wearing.
In Copenhagen you just hop on a bike and go.

The
sheer sense of normalcy conveyed by streets filled with helmetless,
kid-toting Danish cyclists seemed to me to do more to encourage
bicycling and promote safety than any personal equipment or piece of
infrastructure I’d ever seen back home. And the numbers back that up.
Somehow, despite the lack of headgear, Danish, German and Dutch cyclist injury and fatality rates are a fraction of our own.

We know from the work of Peter Jacobsen
that one of the most surefire ways to make urban bike transportation
safer is to increase the number of cyclists on city streets. There are
a lot of proven and effective ways to encourage more people to get on
bikes. Compelling everyone to strap a styrofoam shell to their head is
not one of them — at least not in the world cities with the safest streets for cyclists.

Yes,
I’m still going to continue to wear a helmet on the vast majority of my
bike rides and I’d encourage every New York City cyclist to do the
same. While cyclists have achieved a real safety-in-numbers effect in
Copenhagen and are beginning to do so here, many New York City streets
are still dominated by aggressive nincompoops in overly large motor
vehicles.

Still, I’m leaning toward wearing a dignified hat on this morning’s bike ride rather than a helmet.

  • 1. In the picture, you straps are not clipped. That’s the same as not wearing helmet.

    2. You should just set a good example to your children. If you wear it sometimes and not wear it other times, they may get confused about the need of a helmet.

    3. Since you wearing it most of the time anyway, why waste time to make individual decision in each situation? Just put it on and snap the clips. How hard can that be?

    Motorist can make the same argument. I’m driving in the neighorhood street and under 25mph. Seat belt isn’t essential in those driving condition. This is a reasonable argument, granted. But can you trust people to be so alert that as soon as they go above 25mph they will behave and buckle up? If you make this exception people will just get confused and make mistake all the time. It will also make the law much harder to enforce. That why we have one simple law. Buckle up, period.

  • Plus helmet is never mean to be the only safety measure. If increase the number of cyclists on city streets make them safer we should certain promote that, as is blinky lights, riding in a straight line in a predictable manner, be alert to the traffic around you, etc, etc. These are all complementary to wearing helmet. There is no reason we should not do them all. If helmet is only useful in 1 in 10 accident, I still think it is $20 well spend.

  • No helmet is going to protect you when car runs you over.

  • So? Nobody say it would protect you in all circumstances. Nothing would. But there are plenty of scenarios it could help. If a car cut you off when making a right turn, causing you to fall; if you try to dodge a car and lose your balance, if you are doored, if another cyclists hit you, etc. Don’t base your evaluation on worst case scenario.

  • John

    I like to tell people with your attitude what the guy who sold me my first motorcycle said when I was 18: “It isn’t a question of IF you ever drop it, it is a question of WHEN you WILL drop it”.

    I bicycle on a daily basis and my brain bucket has saved my life at least twice, and I for one will deal with bad “public perception” over my brain splattered on the pavement. Trust me that a “dignified hat” will not stop the concrete and you are welcome to see what is left of the hat or the 3 inch scar on my head as proof.

    Think about the example you are setting for your kids who will hopefully become lifelong cyclists, and safe cyclists.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Orlando Kids Take Back the Streets — By Bike

|
"They want to ride to school. So they do." That’s the message at the end of this terrific video about a student-initiated bike bus in Orlando, Florida — a city with some of the meanest streets in the nation. Shot by Robert Seidler and edited by CommuteOrlando Blog‘s Keri Caffrey, it comes to us courtesy […]

First Bike to School Day in San Francisco a Success

|
A very happy bike-riding student at Monroe Elementary School in the Excelsior. Flickr photo: Marc Caswell All morning I’ve been asking myself (and some others) why kids riding bicycles to school is a pressworthy event. Don’t kids always ride bikes to school or have we become so car-dependent that even this sancrosanct part of being […]