GAO Says We Need More Than a Vision for High Speed Rail

Excited about the prospect of high speed rail in America? Lots of people have been. But as Yonah Freemark reports on The Transport Politic,
yesterday the General Accountability Office threw a bit of a wet
blanket on the growing enthusiasm. The GAO is saying the Obama
administration has so far failed to provide clear goals and a
comprehensive plan for a high speed rail system:

254090836_5e5e644124_m.jpgWant trains like Spain’s? We need a plan. Photo by dewet via Flickr.

[A]t a [June 23] hearing in the U.S. Senate, General Accounting Office Director of Physical Infrastructure Susan Fleming described her concerns
about the government’s distribution of high-speed rail funds. She
focused on the Federal Railroad Administration’s unwillingness thus far
to lay out specific goals for American fast train strategy and argued
that the Department of Transportation must establish a coordinated,
long-term plan for providing funds. Meanwhile, Amtrak CEO Joseph
Boardman and Federal Railroad Administrator Joseph Szabo continued to
mistakenly argue that U.S. plans match those of European countries.

Ms. Fleming’s statement comes three months after the release of GAO’s major report
on high-speed rail, which advocated a major federal investment in the
transportation mode. Emphasizing that that report pushed the DOT to
pinpoint specific goals for rail improvement, Ms. Fleming argued that
the Obama Administration’s actions so far were little more than a “vision,” rather than “a strategic plan.”

The U.S. must “define goals for investing in high speed rail,” she said, and describe “how these investments will achieve them, how the federal government will determine which corridors it could invest in, [and] how high speed rail investments could be evaluated against possible alternative modes in those corridors.”
Ms. Fleming said that the FRA largely agreed with her opinions. In
fact, DOT has been planning to release a draft national rail plan by
mid-October; however, that is a month after the FRA will release initial stimulus bill grants to applicant projects for rail investment.

Meanwhile, Greater Greater Washington looks at Metro’s safety systems in the wake of Monday’s crash. Complete Streets Blog reports they’re rallying for complete streets in Topeka, KS.  And Hard Drive writes about a study that shows that for the first time, more people in Amsterdam are making trips by bicycle than by car.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Oversight Gap in Team Obama’s High-Speed Rail Plan

|
The White House’s economic stimulus law included several large new spending programs, from $4 billion for broadband to $2.4 billion for electric car batteries. But nothing has aroused so much interest — and criticism — as the $8 billion for American high-speed rail. (Photo: Streetsblog LA) Under the circumstances, one might think that lawmakers would […]
STREETSBLOG LA

Senate Committee Grills CA High-Speed Rail Authority on Its Funding Plan

|
Doubts about the High Speed Rail Authority’s ability to fund its estimated $68 billion program dominated last week’s Senate Transportation and Housing Committee hearing (see the background report in this PDF). Committee Chair Senator Mark DeSaulnier (D-Concord) said he was “somewhat skeptical” about the Authority’s 2014 Draft Business Plan and questioned CAHSRA CEO Jeff Morales on […]
STREETSBLOG USA

LaHood Defends High-Speed Rail Program At House Hearing

|
It’s Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood’s birthday, and he’s spending it testifying before the House Transportation Committee. The hearing is on “Mistakes & Lessons Learned” from the high-speed rail program, but — no surprise here — LaHood and House Republicans have differing ideas about what “mistakes” have been made. Here are some highlights. Chair John Mica […]

Bay Area Won’t Likely Get First High Speed Rail Segment

|
The California High-Speed Rail Authority (CAHSRA) Board of Directors won’t make a decision on where to start building California’s first high-speed rail segment until December, but nearly everyone can see the writing on the wall. Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) Adminstrator Joe Szabo wrote [pdf] CAHSRA CEO Roelof van Ark on Wednesday to inform him that […]