SamTrans Considers Raising Fares, Cutting Service and Eliminating Lines

488599115_1acfd28e3a.jpgFlickr photo: kuronakko

SamTrans – the buses and paratransit vehicles that run the length of El Camino Real between Palo Alto and Daly City, traverse the Santa Cruz mountains, and service San Francisco’s financial district – is preparing to raise fares and reduce service on some bus lines and eliminate other lines in order to close a $28.4 million budget gap.

SamTrans serves more than 15 million riders annually through its 339 regular buses and its Redi-Wheels and RediCoast (Paratransit) vehicles. Its fixed-route bus system currently consists of 54 routes.

The financial crisis forced SamTrans Deputy CEO Chuck Harvey to present several options to close the gap at a San Mateo County Transit District Board of Directors meeting August 12 and arrive at a preliminary operating budget of $136.5 million for the 2010 fiscal year.

Harvey presented options for achieving 7.5 percent, 10 percent, and 15 percent savings.
"To get to 15 percent savings, it’s wholesale amputation," he said.

To achieve 15 percent savings Harvey proposed: reducing service on up to 22 lines and eliminating 17 lines; increasing adult, youth, and discounted fares by 25 cents or more; and eliminating the 15 percent discount on the SamTrans pass with the purchase of a Muni sticker.

"It is indeed a cruel twist of fate that brings us here today," said Board of Directors Chairwoman Zoe Kersteen-Tucker. "More than ever, we need to reduce our dependence on cars, yet we are facing a significant crushing deficit, and we cannot look to the state to help us out at least for the next four years."


Citizens argued for the retention of affordable fares and the routes they depend on.
Laura Loringer, a disabled bus rider, testified on behalf of herself and other disabled riders, urging SamTrans not to raise fares for the disabled. "Some of us are on fixed incomes," she said.

"What is Schwarzenegger doing to us?" asked William Farrell, another disabled rider. "We need these buses. For the love of God, make the right choices."

The current cost of a discounted monthly pass is $22. The proposed cost is $32.

The transit agency’s budget problem has also been compounded by the loss of
$39.2 million from the State Transit Assistance fund, which was gutted
by Governor Schwarzenegger and the Legislature.

Other members of the public testified on behalf of public school students and community college students who depend on the buses to get their schools or out of concern for the environment.

"The express bus service is one of the most effective methods for improving air quality," testified Amir Fanai, a San Mateo County resident. For four years, Fanai has been taking the NX express bus from Redwood Shores to his job with the Bay Area Air Quality Management District in San Francisco, but the NX is now on the chopping block. "By eliminating the NX, many fellow passengers would have to drive," he said.

Fanai has also written to President Barack Obama asking that stimulus money be released for the operational costs of transit agencies.

According to Randy Rentschler, spokesperson for the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, the Bay Area has received a total of about $500 million in transportation stimulus dollars, $340 million of which has gone to transit. According to SamTrans Public Information Officer Christine Dunn, SamTrans received $7.8 million. Three million of that has been set aside for new buses, $4 million for maintenance, and $788,000 for paratransit buses – and none of those monies have been directly put into operations.

Michael Dolder, interim city manager for Half Moon Bay, questioned whether or not the agency had complied with the California Environmental Quality Act and the MTC Regional Transportation Plan 2035. Dolder was particularly concerned about proposals to eliminate the 17 line which runs between Montara State Beach and Santa Cruz, and is one of only two lines to serve the coast side of San Mateo County south of Pacifica.

"After a thorough review," he wrote in a letter to the Board of Directors, "staff has concluded that the document does not provide sufficient factual and scientific data to support the decision to adopt a negative declaration for this project."

However, BART Board Director and Livably City Executive Director Tom Radulovich said CEQA "is a strange document" and "not a very good planning tool if you’re trying to plan for sustainability."

CEQA, he noted, is weak in terms of the evaluation of carbon dioxide emissions, and performance for transit riders, and it permits exemptions for transit agencies that declare fiscal emergencies such as the San Mateo County Transit District and the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (Muni).

The public can submit comments to the SamTrans Board of Directors until September 2 at changes@samtrans.com.

  • The legacy of Bart to SFO lives on…

    Of all the transit agencies in the Bay Area, SamTrans probably has the most room to raise fares. Fares are still only $1.50, even for a trip from San Bruno to Palo Alto which would cost $6.25 on Caltrain (sure, SamTrans is a whole lot slower, but it’s still way too cheap).

    The most concerning part of the cuts are those to East Palo Alto, which is already very isolated and lacks good public transit. I think SamTrans is planning on cutting something like 4 of the 6 lines to EPA, which would be disastrous for what is probably the most transit-dependent city in San Mateo County besides Daly City.

  • I love transit, and I occasionally take Sam Trans. But I can’t tell you how many empty Sam Trans buses I see on a regular basis. KX is a great caltrain/BART alternative though.

  • Sue

    SamTrans raised fares in February 2009 as follows:

    Adult:
    Adult Local Cash $1.75 — proposed to go up to $2.00 in Feb. 2010
    Adult 391/292/397, Out of S.F. Cash $3.50 — proposed to go up to $4.00
    Adult Express Cash $4.50 — proposed to go up to $5.00
    Adult Tokens (10) $14.00 — proposed to go up to $16
    Adult Monthly Pass $56.00 — proposed to go up to $64.00
    Adult 391/292/397 – Out of S.F. Mo. Pass $84.00 — proposed to go up to $96.00
    Adult Express Monthly Pass $144.00 — proposed to go up to $165.00

    Youth:
    Youth Local Cash $1.00 — proposed to go up to $1.25
    Youth 391/292/397, Out of S.F. Cash $2.00 — proposed to go up to $2.50
    Youth Express Cash $2.00 — proposed to go up to $2.50
    Youth Tokens (10) $8.00 — proposed to go up to $10.00
    Youth Monthly Pass $29.00 — proposed to go up to $36.00
    “Needy Family” Youth Monthly Pass $18.00 — proposed to go up to $22.00
    Summer Youth Pass $35.00 — proposed to go up to $44.00

    Other fares are also going up. Follow this link:
    http://www.samtrans.com/news_2009_proposed_service_and_fare_changes_07-28.html

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

SamTrans to Raise Fares and Cut Nearly All Express Routes

|
Four of these six routes will be discontinued or have reduced service. Flickr photo: 4nitsirk The SamTrans Board of Directors voted today to cut nearly all express routes to San Francisco, reduce service on several local lines, and raise adult one-way fares by 25 cents in an effort to narrow a $28.4 million budget deficit. […]

San Mateo County Supes Vote to Fund Bike/Ped Coordinator, SamTrans

|
The San Mateo County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously Tuesday to approve $10 million to boost SamTrans service and $156,000 to create a new full-time bicycle and pedestrian coordinator position over the next two years. The funds come from Measure A, a ten-year, half-cent sales tax approved by voters last November, which is expected to generate $64 […]
San Mateo County officials are desperate to widen Highway 101 from eight to ten lanes at a cost of over $300 million. Photo: Andrew Boone

Ten Lane Widening Planned for Highway 101 in San Mateo County

|
Still seeking to widen Highway 101 from eight to ten lanes, Caltrans and San Mateo County’s transportation agencies are now halfway through the required environmental review. At a community meeting on Wednesday evening, agency officials gave an update on the project [PDF] to widen the highway by adding express lanes, which allow buses and carpools […]