TOD Stalls as Lenders Continue to Bank on Parking

Elana linked to this story out of Salt Lake City in the Capitol Hill headline stack
this morning, and it’s worth everyone’s full attention. Derek Jensen
reports on what may be the biggest impediment to urbanism of them all: the widespread bias of banks against walkable development.

Salt Lake City’s
new-urbanism epiphany — fervently backed by Mayor Ralph Becker and the
City Council — appears to be catching static from an unlikely source.

Transit-oriented development isn’t stymied by outdated zoning,
unwilling developers or a lack of space. It turns out, banks, wedded to
old-fashioned lending standards that stress parking, may pose the
biggest blockade by denying financing.

The reason: Lenders operate from a tried-and-true principle that
maintains more parking means less risk and a higher return on their
investment. But ditching cars is the whole point of urban developers
looking to create 24-hour live, work and play environments that hug
light-rail hubs. 

mcmansion.jpgReal estate lending standards: A work in progress. Photo: MSN.

That’s right, the same sector that got such fantastic returns from the car-dependent suburban fringe
isn’t sold on the viability of neighborhoods where you can get around
without driving. Salt Lake City banks are hardly the exception. We’ve heard time and again that limits on parking in the Bay Area would send lenders running to the hills (or over them, to Walnut Creek).

If we’re ever going to build housing with limited parking and stop the tide of conditional use exemptions to parking restrictions, we’ll need banks to change their assumptions. As Jensen reports, Portland shows that it can be done.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

How Better Traffic Models Can Lead to More Mixed-Use Development

|
Here’s another obscure but significant obstacle to building walkable places in America: the Institute of Transportation Engineers’ shoddy traffic generation models for mixed-use development. The model used by traffic engineers around the country to measure “trip generation” at new developments consistently overestimates the amount of motor vehicle traffic produced by mixed-use projects, according to the […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Real Estate Trend: Parking-Free Apartment Buildings

|
A wave of new residential construction projects in places like Seattle, Boston, and Miami are showing that, yes, modern American cities can build housing without any car parking on site. Officials in Boston gave their approval last week to what Curbed called the city’s “first big-time parking-less condo,” a 175-unit project named Lovejoy Wharf. The “plan was met with […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Salt Lake City, Rising Transit Star

|
On the roster of cities making progress on green transportation in the western U.S., you have the usual suspects like Portland and Denver. But in terms of building track miles and adding busways, the city on the fastest pace might just be Salt Lake City, Utah. Over the last decade, the capital of the reddest […]

Proposed Developments Illustrate San Francisco’s Parking Dilemma

|
A simulation of the proposed discount mall on Market Street, City Place. Image: Urban Realty. At another marathon Planning Commission meeting last week, parking was all the rage. Two projects in particular had community members and housing and transit advocates fired up because of the parking that developers proposed to build, or in one case, […]