Transit Fare Inflation Hitting Health Insurance-Like Levels?

That’s the implication buried in a roundup
of dismal news from urban transit agencies that ran in Saturday’s Wall
Street Journal. After noting the overall ridership decreases tallied by APTA and the specter of punitive service cuts in many cities, the newspaper noted:

3811098633_86047dae97.jpgRiders
of Chicago’s El train, shown above, were spared fare hikes in 2010
thanks to a last-minute deal. (Photo: ~JudyCrawford via Flickr)

The cost of riding public transit rose at a 17.8% annual rate in the
six months ended in November, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported.
Overall consumer prices were up at a 4.2% rate in the same period.

That statistic is a bit tricky, since it projects twelve-month inflation rates by looking at six months of data.

But
it’s still striking — and scary — to see transit fare inflation
hitting levels that look as bad as price increases for health
insurance, which in recent years has grown 8.7% faster than the annual inflation rate, according to the Kaiser Foundation.

Heading
into 2010, it’s easy to see urban transit agencies falling into a
vicious cycle driven by state budget woes verging on the apocalyptic
(see California), local resistance to fare increases that disproportionately affect non-car-owning commuters, and federal inaction on much-needed transportation reform.

If
there’s any upside to the grim picture, it may be that scarce funding
is likely to force lawmakers into honestly apportioning scarce
resources based on infrastructure projects’ true value to local
communities — not the political popularity of ribbon-cutting
ceremonies or promises of local job-creation that ultimately fail to materialize.

Such
an outcome could well put transit and road projects on a more equal
footing. But much like incremental emissions reductions taking shape
at the state level, any change will surely take longer than most
Americans would like. One thing that might help prod political leaders
into action: more of a spotlight on the Journal’s transit inflation
number.

  • Well, much of the increase in transit costs comes directly from higher health insurance costs… after all, most of the operating costs of transit are labor costs.

  • I was smug in the security of my employer provided transit benefit… until I got the news late in the last year that we might not have transit benefits in 2010! I’ve yet to receive my 2010 EcoPass.

    I don’t see my employer ripping out the acres of free parking available for those who drive….

  • Jeff

    Very alarmist. For how long were transit fares held static though and what was the previous annual inflation rate in fares? Have fares kept pace historically with inflation? Important factors that are sorely missed in this article.

  • Rocky

    If you want to know what your transit future may look like, look at socialist Toronto’s transit fares: $3 cash fare for adults, $2 for seniors. The public employee unions are very powerful and well paid.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Six Ideas for Saving Bay Area Transit

|
[Editor’s note: This article is re-published with permission from the transit-themed March issue of The Urbanist, the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association’s (SPUR) monthly member magazine. The article, written by SPUR Regional Planning Director Egon Terplan, is based on a discussion paper developed by the SPUR Transportation Policy Board. Read the full paper at spur.org/tsp.] […]

White House: Transit Inflation Outstripping Private Transportation

|
The White House’s annual economic report, in addition to its endorsement of inter-city rail and transit spending, also sheds more light on transit inflation, which is often reported anecdotally in the many cities struggling with fare hikes but rarely put in statistical terms by economists. (Photo: UPI) In the appendices of its report, the president’s […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Beating the Fare Hike Blues

|
Transit fares have been ballooning across the country in recent years; if you live in a city that hasn’t raised prices and cut service, consider yourself lucky. It can be upsetting to get socked with an unexpected expense. But as much as it hurts to fork over a little more of your paycheck every time […]

MTC Report Shows Dismal Future for Transit Operators

|
Image: MTC The 2009 Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) Annual Report paints a sobering picture of funding crises at nearly every Bay Area Transit operator — crises we’ve covered extensively on Streetsblog — and sums up the situation bluntly: "There is no way to sugarcoat it: These are difficult, daunting days for public transit in the […]