Want to Foster Walking, Biking and Transit? You Need Good Parking Policy

The high-water mark for American parking policy came in the early
1970s, when cities including New York, Boston, and Portland set limits
on off-street parking in their downtowns. They were compelled to do so
by lawsuits brought under the Clean Air Act, which used the lever of
parking policy to curb traffic and reduce pollution from auto
emissions. This level of innovation went unmatched over the ensuing
three-and-a-half decades. Only now are American cities implementing
effective new parking strategies that cut down on traffic.

parking_graphic.jpgGraphic: ITDP

A report released today by the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy [PDF]
highlights the new wave of parking policy innovation that could pay
huge dividends for sustainable transport and livable streets. If your
city aspires to make streets safe, improve the quality of transit, and
foster bicycling, your city needs a coherent parking policy.

"There
was a 35-year parking coma during which the federal
government, cities, and environmentalists forgot why parking was
important," said John Kaehny, who co-authored the report with Matthew
Rufo and UPenn professor Rachel Weinberger. "This study shows people
are starting wake up and understand
that parking is one of most important influences on how cities work and
what form of travel people choose to use."

The early 70s
parking limits beat back the cycle of more car storage, wider roadways,
and greater sprawl that decimates urban areas. The underlying idea was
simple: Manage the supply of parking, and you can reduce the demand for
driving. Yet in America this notion has gone largely unheeded, even in
cities.

Instead, the authors note, parking policy is
typically divorced from transportation policy and goals like reducing
congestion or encouraging walking and biking. In most of our urban
areas, planners determine parking volumes using suburban standards,
drawing heavily on ill-suited recommendations in "Parking Generation,"
a manual published by the Institute for Transportation Engineers. The
product is abundant, cheap parking — much of which sits unused most of
the time.

Fully 99 percent of car trips in America end in
free parking, an incentive that crowds out all other modes of
transportation. "Even when the price of parking is free," said
Weinberger, "it’s far from free."

The resulting congestion
impedes the effectiveness of transit. Traffic volumes and
double-parking make bicycling less pleasant and more dangerous.
Walkable environments give way to curb cuts, dead walls, and
land-devouring parking facilities that spread destinations farther
apart. The whole vicious cycle is heavily subsidized, with the cost of
parking absorbed into the price of everything from housing to movie
tickets.

"In a time of economic distress, we can’t afford
to continue these policies,"  said ITDP’s Michael Replogle. "Continuing
to subsidize parking is very costly for all of us."

mpls_surface_parking.jpgSurface parking in downtown Minneapolis. Photo: ITDP/Zachary Korb

The
good news is that some cities are introducing more rational parking
policies guided by coherent goals. The ITDP report pulls together case
studies of several places where these reforms are underway —
information that the authors hope will spur other cities to take
notice. "American parking policy is like bike policy a decade
ago," said Kaehny. "Cities are doing lots of different and interesting
things. But they aren’t sharing what they learn in an organized way,
nor are the feds helping spread the word about what is working and what
isn’t."

In San Francisco and New York,
programs to bring the price of curbside parking more in line with
off-street parking are reducing the incentive to cruise endlessly for a
cheap spot. In Portland, planners have reduced parking requirements for
new development near transit lines, helping to improve walkability and
increase ridership.

wrapped.jpgThis parking structure in downtown Boulder is wrapped with street-level retail. Image: ITDP/City of Boulder

Boulder
provides an intriguing study in parking management as an economic
development tool. This small Colorado city is one of the only places
that introduced new parking policies during the 80s and 90s. After
deciding they couldn’t compete with suburban malls by imitating them,
local merchants led an effort that effectively capped the volume of
downtown parking and directed revenue from parking facilities to
improve transit, walking, and bicycling.

Other cities will be able to replicate the innovations in the report, said UCLA planning professor Donald Shoup, author of The High Cost of Free Parking.
"Weinberger, Kaehny, and Rufo show how cities can begin to repair the
damage caused by decades of bad planning for parking," he said. "The
case studies of six cities that have reformed their parking policies
provide clear blueprints that any city can adapt to fit the local
circumstances."

  • sunday_free_for_all

    what a contrast, boulder’s progressive parking plan vs. this regressive nonsense from the chronicle:

    http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/blogs/inthemission/detail?entry_id=57763

    it seems that the merchants of san francisco in particular are the major impediment to a more livable city. little do they know that most shoppers who actually have time to come in and buy are on foot. cars do not equal business.

    in spite of many valiant attempts to improve the parking policies, we seem to be more stuck than ever under the thumb of the free parking crowd.

    perhaps direct action speaks louder than policies that never take off. key a car today (or a whole block of street-parked cars)! let these freeloaders know that there’s a cost to the land they take and the streetscape possibilities they prevent. with the extent that most american drivers’ ego is intertwined with the aesthetic of their vehicles, a good keying sends a clear message. park in this city and beware!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

European Parking Policies Leave New York Behind

|
Flashback to Europe, sixty years ago. Only still emerging from the ruin of total war, the continent was in the midst of a nearly unprecedented reconstruction. Over the next decade, however, industry finally was able to turn toward consumer products, from stockings to refrigerators and, of course, the automobile. Italians owned only 342,000 cars in […]
STREETSBLOG LA

Donald Shoup Responds to California APA’s Opposition to Parking Reform Bill

|
[Editor’s note: The full letter from Donald Shoup to the American Planning Association on AB 904 can be found after the jump.] In 2004, when the American Institute of Certified Planners inducted Donald Shoup as a fellow — the American Planning Association’s (APA) highest honor — it called the UCLA professor “an academic authority on parking and its effects on […]

CA Poised to Reform Auto-Centric Level of Service Environmental Rules

|
California administrative rulemakers recently moved a step closer to reforming the section of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) that has compelled cities to focus undue attention on the age-old Automobile Level of Service (LOS) threshold for impacts of new projects and has led to the construction of excess off-street parking. Photo: pbo31 The state’s […]