Planners Turn to World’s Best Streets for Inspiration on Market

Photo: Aaron Bialick

A new set of reports released yesterday by the Better Market Street Project, a coordinated effort between San Francisco city agencies and urban designers, presents ideas for optimizing the mobility, safety and overall experience on lower Market Street when it is rebuilt in 2015.

While the authors didn’t explicitly recommend the growingly popular idea of a car-free Market Street, they did point out that “car volumes… are low, but have disproportionately high effects on other modes” and recommended a study of vehicle restrictions “both for traffic along Market Street and for traffic turning onto Market Street…to determine what diversion may occur and what benefits to other modes might be derived.” (For a full-throated endorsement of a car-free Market, check out yesterday’s editorial in the Huffington Post, where Michael Portanova points out that “most anyone who has ever used a car in San Francisco knows that if you’re driving on Market Street, you’re doing it wrong.”)

Urban design consultants have been teaming up with a raft of public agencies the last couple of years to analyze Market Street and collect public input on the upcoming reconstruction. The reports include some interesting output from that partnership, including a summary of the top priorities voiced at public workshops last May. Creating a more attractive pedestrian environment and more comfortable bicycling infrastructure are toward the top of the list.

“The Better Market Street Project is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to transform Market Street and bring this major artery for the Bay Area to its full potential,” said Mohammed Nuru, director of the Department of Public Works (DPW), one of the leading agencies on the project.

The reports present a collection of best practices from similar streets throughout the world that can be adapted to improve Market Street. “It’s very valuable background information to help us know if we’re on the right track with our design concepts,” said DPW Project Manager Kris Opbroek.

Drawing on some of those celebrated streets for inspiration, the reports make a wide-ranging series of recommendations to improve safety and mobility on Market. To speed Muni vehicles, the recommendations include extending and enforcing bus-only lanes, optimizing stop locations, longer boarding islands, off-vehicle ticket machines, bus-priority traffic signals, and seeking alternative locations for deliveries. The reports also suggest that continuous protected bikeways could reduce conflicts with pedestrians and buses, and recommend multi-modal solutions like locating bike share stations at transit hubs.

“We are looking forward to this much-needed renewed commitment and sense of urgency from the city to design and construct a next generation Market Street,” said San Francisco Bicycle Coalition Executive Director Leah Shahum. “We hear every day from the huge and growing number of people biking on the street about how important a better Market Street is for getting them to work, school and around town.”

Here are a few of the more intriguing ideas and possibilities:

The "Copenhagen left turn," the report notes, could help bicyclists cross streetcar tracks safely. Click to enlarge.
Street trees like those on Las Ramblas in Barcelona, Spain could create a more attractive pedestrian environment. Click to enlarge.
A few treatments that could improve the pedestrian experience at side streets. Click to enlarge.
Ideas for "flex" loading zones include a local proposal from the San Francisco County Transportation Authority to create sidewalk extensions on Columbus Avenue that would also be accessible by delivery vehicles. Click to enlarge.

In the meantime, the SFMTA is testing two pilot projects to reduce the impact of cars on Market, said spokesperson Paul Rose, including the removal of peak-hour parking bans near Market on Sixth Street, which had led to speeding, and the installation of a right-turn traffic signal at Market and New Montgomery to reduce back-ups.

This year, Better Market Street planners will consider the practices showcased in the reports as they develop conceptual drawings and begin the environmental review process — a promising sign that Market Street’s next redesign could be the most thorough plan developed yet.

Since the construction of BART, “there’s been no holistic re-envisioning of Market Street such as this,” said Opbroek.

The public will be invited to review the first concept drawings at a meeting to be scheduled in the spring. The full reports can be viewed on the Better Market Street website.

  • Felix Sargent

    Which is the new report? The only reports available on the site are from July 2011. 
    Can you link directly to the new documents?

  • Aaron Bialick

    The link at the top and bottom of the article link to the page titled “Reports and Documents”, which shows reports all dated December 7, 2011 (though they were just released publicly).

  • Jim Frank

    All the intersections from 3rd street to the Ferry building are the real problems for transit traffic on Market. Especially Montgomery and 2nd street. All these folks are heading to get on the bay bridge.

    Further parking restrictions and increased prices for on-street parking could help reduce the number of people who drive into downtown. Even though the mode share is pretty good for downtown, people always tell me its really easy to drive there.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Learning From Other Cities, Planners Shop Early Visions for Market Street

|
Planners presented early concepts for a new Market Street to the public yesterday, moving the discussion forward on revitalizing San Francisco’s grand boulevard with features like car-free zones, raised bike lanes, faster transit, and more inviting public spaces. The ideas and visualizations, which are available on the Better Market Street website, were presented by planners […]

SFMTA Directors Favor More Car Restrictions to Improve Market Street

|
The idea of getting more private automobiles off Market Street is gaining serious traction at the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA). Following the success of measures diverting cars off Market at 6th and 10th Streets, the SFMTA Board of Directors today showed a broad consensus favoring potential pilot projects that could further reduce the […]

Streetscast: An Interview with District 4 Supervisor Carmen Chu

|
San Francisco Supervisor Carmen Chu represents the Sunset District, which includes some of the city’s major thoroughfares: the Great Highway, 19th and Sunset avenues and Sloat Boulevard. She was appointed to her post by the Mayor in 2007 and elected last November. Chu’s main mode of travel tends to shape her views on transportation issues. […]

SFMTA Proposes New Car Restrictions, Extended Bus Lanes on Lower Market

|
Last week, the SFMTA presented its proposal to ban private auto drivers from turning onto Market Street, between Third and Eighth Streets. The move would be complemented with extended transit-only lanes, plus a new system of wayfinding signs aimed at keeping drivers off of Market. The new plans, named “Safer Market Street,” would be implemented over nearly a […]