Wiener Proposes Bills to Hack Through Red Tape for Ped Safety Upgrades

The bureaucratic red tape encumbering the city’s progress on life-saving pedestrian safety measures is the target of a new legislative package set to be introduced by Supervisor Scott Wiener at today’s Board of Supervisors meeting.

Photo: Streetsblog

“Current city procedures and rules significantly undermine the delivery of pedestrian safety improvements, with insufficient agency coordination and policies that de-prioritize improving pedestrian safety,” Wiener’s office said today in a press release.

The legislation has four components, including the creation of a new entity to streamline coordination between the different agencies involved in street design:

(1) an ordinance that mandates interagency coordination by creating a centralized Street Design Review Committee, which was a key recommendation from a 2010 Controller’s Audit [PDF]; (2) an accompanying resolution calling for city agencies to modernize street code provisions , better coordinate their efforts around public projects and to formulate clear procedures to do so [PDF]; (3) an ordinance making it easier for developers to build pedestrian safety projects and gift them to the city [PDF]; and (4) an ordinance amending the Fire Code to ensure that pedestrian safety projects are not unnecessarily impeded by the code’s definition of minimum street width [PDF].

Walk SF Executive Director Elizabeth Stampe applauded Wiener’s move to help speed the implementation of safer streets. “It is critical to reduce the delays and vetoes behind closed doors that drive up costs, weaken projects beyond recognition, or kill them entirely,” she said. “From Valencia to Fell and Oak to Broadway, there are examples of this on almost every street-improvement project in the city, plus many more that never happened at all, despite clear community demand. It’s time to change that, and deliver on the promise of safer, better streets.”

The legislation seems like a promising step toward achieving the targets set in the SF Municipal Transportation Agency’s draft Pedestrian Strategy — a 25 percent reduction in injuries by 2016, and a 50 percent reduction by 2020. The strategy calls for substantial pedestrian infrastructure improvements on five miles of “high priority” streets per year.

As Streetsblog has reported, two to three pedestrians are injured on San Francisco streets every day. Four pedestrians have been killed by drivers this year alone, and 19 were killed last year.

One commonly cited reason for SF’s slow pace on pedestrian safety upgrades is what an SF County Transportation Authority official has described as “fragmented responsibility” between the SFCTA, SFMTA, the Department of Public Works, and other agencies. Wiener’s proposed Street Design Review Committee would help address this issue by creating “a central clearinghouse for project disputes among agencies.” His office says this “will ensure that proposed improvements are consistent with established policies like the Better Streets Plan and the Transit First Policy.”

The committee would include representatives from the Mayor’s Office, DPW, the SFMTA, the Planning Department, the Public Utilities Commission, and the Office of Economic and Workforce Development.

“Currently, there is no formalized coordination among agencies when implementing pedestrian safety projects,” Wiener’s office said. “Instead, each department has its own veto power, with little or no requirement that agencies work together to find a path forward for projects. This lack of coordination undermines the city’s ability to deliver pedestrian safety projects.”

Another component of the legislation is aimed at making it easier for developers to implement safety improvements on the streets surrounding their sites. An example would be the proposed sidewalk expansions and crosswalk improvements at Market and Dolores Streets, where an apartment building and Whole Foods Market are going up. Those improvements, part of an agreement to waive $510,000 in developer impact fees, are going to the Planning Commission on Thursday with the support of Wiener, who represents the district.

Wiener says this type of improvement is hampered because the city requires developers “to go through what can be years of uncoordinated permit approvals” and other red tape. By creating a new “Public Improvement Permit,” his proposal aims to streamline the process for developers to construct safety improvements.

Wiener also seeks to amend the city’s Fire Code, since pedestrian safety improvements like corner bulb-outs can be blocked by a “strict interpretation” of minimum requirements for street widths to accommodate fire trucks. He’s proposing to exempt unobstructed pedestrian infrastructure from those requirements. Since the changes to those rules are restricted by California’s state Fire Code, the legislation also includes a resolution [PDF] urging the state legislature to give local governments “more flexibility in determining minimum street widths.”

“While our city polices identify pedestrian safety as a priority, our actual rules undermine pedestrian safety by causing projects to get tangled up by inter-agency bureaucracy, conflicting policy priorities, and outdated codes,” Wiener said in a statement. “As a result, projects that do get built are unnecessarily expensive while others are either watered down or killed through death by a thousand bureaucratic cuts. We have one of the highest pedestrian injury rates in the state, and it’s imperative that we do all that we can to make our streets safer.”

The legislation is expected to go to a supervisor committee for initial approval in the coming weeks.

  • CBrinkman

    Thank you Supervisor Wiener.

  • Jim Frank

    Bravo. Let’s hope things will get better walking around on the streets.

  • There are too many departments to coordinate road improvements.
    Let’s make a coordination department.
    http://xkcd.com/927/

  • mikesonn

    my thoughts exactly!

  • Mario Tanev

    This Wiener is an impressive one!

  • He’s the man.

  • Susan

    Can we make sure these bulb outs don’t make for a more dangerous situation for cyclists?
    The pedestrian bulb out at Market and buchanan (where the bike lane disappears and all road traffic is funneled into one lane) makes cyclists choose between using the sidewalk and sharing a lane with fast-moving vehicles on the street.

  • GS

    Can we get him to be our supervisor? I want him! GS

  • G S – Scott may be the D8 supervisor but that only means he only does his pothole fixing and cat saving in D8. Larger issues like this he has a city-centric viewpoint.

    Of course, he’s a worthy successor to Bevan Dufty when it comes to being Supervisor Pothole as well

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Board of Supervisors Unanimously Passes Wiener’s Ped Safety Reforms

|
Supervisor Scott Wiener’s package of legislation aimed at streamlining pedestrian safety projects was passed unanimously by the Board of Supervisors yesterday, and will be incorporated into the city’s administrative code. Here’s what the legislation will do: Create a Street Design Review Committee to foster better coordination between agencies on street infrastructure projects. Call upon agencies to “modernize street […]

Wiener’s Proposals to Streamline Ped Safety Upgrades Pass Supes Committee

|
A package of legislation aimed at cutting through the bureaucratic red tape that encumbers the city’s progress on life-saving pedestrian safety measures was unanimously approved by the Board of Supervisors Land Use and Economic Development Committee yesterday. The full board is expected to approve the proposals in the coming weeks. Supervisor Scott Wiener, who proposed […]

SFMTA Shows Off Vision Zero Upgrades, Promises Quicker Implementation

|
Several top officials from state and national transportation agencies were in town today to see some of the SFMTA’s latest street safety measures. Meanwhile, local street safety advocates continue to push the SFMTA to pick up the pace on delivering pedestrian and bike safety infrastructure. At a City Hall committee hearing yesterday, SFMTA Sustainable Streets Director Tom […]

SFMTA’s Tom Maguire Promises Reforms to Streamline Safe Street Fixes

|
Tom Maguire, the SFMTA’s new Sustainable Streets Director, said he’s working on reforms that will fast-track implementation of numerous street safety fixes that will help SF accomplish Vision Zero. Maguire, who started at the SFMTA two months ago after serving in an executive role in New York City’s Department of Transportation, told the supervisors’ Vision […]

SF Planning Department: Castro Street Design Workshop #1

|
From SF-Planning: The City of San Francisco in coordination with the Castro/Upper Market Community Benefits District, the Merchants of Upper Market and Castro, and the Eureka Valley Neighborhood Association invite you to the first CASTRO STREET DESIGN WORKSHOP.Please join us to discuss the future of Castro Street from Market Street to 19th Street. In 2011, […]