Have Your Say on How to Spend $226 Billion Over the Next 25 Years

1_Overview.jpgPhoto by Barrie Rokeach (Copyright 2009 All Rights Reserved)
By 2035 the Bay Area is expected to grow by 25 percent
— 2 million new residents. Auto trips will increase even faster, by 32
percent, delaying vehicles an additional 135 percent, and increasing
particulate matter emissions up to 30 percent. Traffic congestion in
the region is already the second worst in the nation, and
transportation is responsible for half of all global warming pollution
in the Bay Area, mostly from private cars and trucks.

Realizing these sobering forecasts, the regional transportation planning organization, the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), spent the last two years deciding how to spend $226 billion on transportation over the next 25 years. The Draft Transportation 2035 Plan: Change in Motion was released last month for public review and comment. Now it is your chance to send in comments or attend a public hearing tomorrow or Wednesday. For more details visit the Transportation 2035 website.

The plan proposes reducing carbon dioxide emissions to 40 percent below 1990 levels, and relieving freeway congestion by 20 percent below 2006 levels. It outlines a carbon or vehicle-miles traveled (VMT) tax, parking surcharges, congestion tolls, encouraging new residential projects to be built close to jobs, transit, shopping and services; and various bicycle, pedestrian and transit projects.

The plan does support allocating funds for sustainable transportation but it is too heavily dependent upon technology to merely accommodate increased auto traffic on freeways. Sixty five percent of total funding is dedicated to transit and 32 percent to roads and bridges, leaving only 2 percent for bicycles and pedestrians. It is unacceptable to underfund the least polluting modes of transportation. The plan severely underestimates the huge displacement of auto miles traveled possible by investing in bike and pedestrian infrastructure.

As shown in the graph below, bicycle projects meet 3 goals to reduce pollution and VMT, compared to freeway projects, which achieve 2 goals. However, the bicycle projects are allocated much less funding and designated as achieving a “low” benefit to cost ratio compared to freeway projects determined to have “high” benefit to cost ratios.

performance.jpgBenefit to Cost Project Performance Measurements Pg. 40 Draft 2035 Plan
Rather than concentrating on reducing the amount people drive by investing in sustainable transportation, the plan allocates too much funding to implement intelligent transportation systems (ITS) to merely manage an increase in freeway traffic, and High Occupancy Toll (HOT) lanes so wealthy motorists can pay to use carpool lanes.

One reason the MTC underestimates the impact of investing in bicycles is because they use inadequate bicycle and pedestrian counting methods to forecast future trends. These models are not in line with local and national statistics that show bike use is on the rise, and the degree to which improved facilities increase bicycle travel.

It is important the MTC hears what you think about funding highway management and expansion over bicycle, pedestrian and transit projects. The more cyclists, pedestrians and transit riders at the meeting the better. So come with your bike helmets  and Muni passes in hand to one of the two public hearings scheduled this week. For more talking points read Livable City’s RTP analysis and TransForm’s comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR). All comments submitted in writing and recorded at the meetings will be documented and responded to in the EIR.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Public Hearing/Workshop: San Francisco
7 p.m. to 9 p.m.
San Francisco State Downtown Campus
Room 609
835 Market Street, San Francisco


Wednesday, January 28, 2009
Public Hearing: Oakland
10:05 a.m.
MTC Commission Meeting
Joseph P. Bort MetroCenter
Lawrence D. Dahms Auditorium
101 Eighth Street, Oakland
(at the Lake Merritt BART station)

Please RSVP via E-mail to info@mtc.ca.gov or via phone to
510.817.5757. Leave your contact information and which hearing you plan to attend.


MTC Adopts Aggressive 15 Percent Target for Reducing Emissions by 2035

Photo: Keenahn The Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), in a historic vote Wednesday that will help guide the future for more sustainable land use and transportation planning in the Bay Area, recommended a 15 percent per capita target for reducing greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) by 2035, the most aggressive goal to date among California’s metropolitan planning […]

San Mateo County Drafts Business As Usual Transportation Plan

Note the ‘call to action’ at the end of this post. City/County Association of Governments of San Mateo County (C/CAG) officials unveiled a draft update of the agency’s Countywide Transportation Plan [PDF], the first since 2001, at three community meetings last week. The new plan calls for billions of dollars in highway expansion projects [PDF] over the […]

Congestion Pricing: Vital for Funding a Sustainable Transpo Future in SF

Take a shot at budgeting San Francisco’s future transportation revenue with the new online “Budget Czar” simulator from the SF County Transportation Authority, and it will quickly become clear: If residents want better transit and safer streets for walking and biking over the next 25 years, the city needs to collect new sources of transportation revenue […]