To Reduce Pedestrian Fatalities, Focus Enforcement on Cars

Today the issue of pedestrian safety has popped up a couple of times on the Streetsblog Network. First, the folks at WalkBike Jersey
report that a bill giving pedestrians more protection in the crosswalk
has passed the State Assembly and is moving to committee in the Senate:

2592590374_3239f9c206.jpgPhoto by tomswift46 via Fickr.

the bill, motorists would be required to stop and remain stopped at a
crosswalk while pedestrians pass through the driver’s lane of traffic,
even if a light changes to give the motorist the right of way.

Primary Sponsor — Assemblywoman Linda Stender has been a champion of
pedestrian safety over the years. “The number of pedestrian deaths in
our state has been increasing instead of decreasing despite our best
efforts in recent years,” said Stender (D-Union), vice chairwoman of
the Assembly Transportation, Public Works and Independent Authorities
Committee. “This measure will clearly give pedestrians the right of way
so that school children and people on foot can safely walk to their

The Assembly passed the bill, which
simply seems to represent common sense, unanimously. If it becomes law,
it will be interesting to see if it is enforced or used by prosecutors.
But in a state where the latest figures show a recent surge in pedestrian deaths, any move to increase legal protections for those traveling on foot is welcome.

In Savannah, as we wrote a couple of weeks ago,
the police have been reacting differently after a high-profile case in
which a tourist was killed by a car. They’ve decided to focus
enforcement on jaywalkers. As Sustainable Savannah
reports, the flurry of jaywalking tickets has caused a backlash because
of the high fines they carry, but the underlying problem with the
strategy is much more profound:

I see a critical question that’s not been answered: Is jaywalking
enforcement the best way to reduce pedestrian injuries and deaths?

In yesterday’s Savannah Morning News,
Alderman Tony Thomas said while the fines are too high, “We have to
change the culture of pedestrians and bike riders. Those safety issues
have got to be altered.” Meanwhile, WTOC-TV reports, “Chief Berkow isn’t pulling any punches as he stands by what he calls strictly ‘a safety measure.’”

reviewing pedestrian safety literature published by state, federal and
municipal agencies, many references to enforcement can be found. In the
vast majority of reports, studies and guidelines that I’ve seen, motorists are the recommended focus of enforcement efforts.
If the goal of the “jaywalking crackdown” is public safety, why are we
pursuing a course of action that appears at odds with best practice
models? Are we blaming the victim, as Connect Savannah’s Jim Morekis suggests?

business owner Ruel Joyner told WTOC, “It’s not the jaywalking ticket
itself. It’s the sentiment under it. That’s not the signal we should be
sending when we are the number one walking city in the nation.” And,
“We need to be as inviting as we can and look out for the good of

There’s real potential for the next transportation bill to include provisions for "complete streets" that would address, from a federal policy perspective, the idea that streets need to serve all users — not just cars. The Complete Streets Blog, newly online from the National Complete Streets Coalition, has word of a briefing in Washington this morning on the subject. We’ll be following them for news on that front.


Image: Streetsblog/Rudick

San Mateo Joins Legislative Charge into ‘Jaywalking 2.0’

Yesterday, the San Mateo Board of Supervisors passed a resolution that could be the first step towards a statewide ban on texting while walking in a crosswalk. The resolution, introduced by Supervisor David Canepa, “urges the state legislature to take action to promote traffic safety by prohibiting use of cell phones while crossing streets or, […]

Closed Crosswalks Remain Even in Today’s Walkable Hayes Valley

Hayes Valley may be one of the country’s densest and most walkable urban neighborhoods, but believe it or not, it still has three closed crosswalks — vestiges of the mid-20th century’s cars-first planning. “For many years, traffic engineers devised ways to pen people in, so that cars weren’t inconvenienced,” said Walk SF Executive Director Nicole Schneider. “Nowadays, […]

Advocates: Despite Bike-Ped Death, Cars Still Greatest Danger to Peds

In the midst of a wave of media attention around the recent bicycle-pedestrian death in the Castro, walking and bicycling advocates today re-affirmed the greatest dangers facing pedestrians on San Francisco’s streets: high-speed roads and dangerous driving behavior. In a KQED radio forum this morning, Walk SF Executive Director Elizabeth Stampe, SF Bicycle Coalition (SFBC) Executive Director Leah Shahum, […]