The Rules of the Road Are Everyone’s Responsibility

I’ve been trying a little experiment lately as I ride around town on
my bike: doing my level best to follow the letter of the law. I’ve been
inspired by both the carrot and the stick. In the carrot department,
Transportation Alternatives’ new Biking Rules
handbook has made a very nice case for more rule-based cycling in the
city: "the simple principle that our responsibility to others on the
street increases in relation to our potential to cause harm. With
Biking Rules, NYC cyclists are taking the lead to create safer, saner
streets." I would like to be a part of that sanity, even if I think it
would be more appropriate for law enforcement to take the lead by
enforcing the laws that apply to motorists. So I’m giving it a shot. So
far I’ve gotten thanks from two pedestrians for stopping at red lights,
and that felt pretty good.

Officers ride the Hollywood/Vine crosswalk until they defer to the
primacy of the motor vehicle and ride out into the oncoming traffic.
Photo by SoapBoxLA.

the stick department was the $50 ticket I got for riding on a path in
Madison Square Park a couple of months ago. The Parks Department
employee who wrote it didn’t care that there were no pedestrians within
50 yards of me, or that I had chosen to ride through the park rather
than on 23rd Street because of the hazardous mash of traffic conditions
(buses stopped diagonally across the lanes, construction vehicles,
double-parked cars, etc.) that existed there at that minute. She was
just enforcing a rule, and I had to admit that I had broken it. (She
also suggested that I fight the ticket, which seemed just bizarre to
me. I paid it instead.) 

I’ve tried this experiment before, back in the dark ages of the
late ’80s, when I was commuting by bike from Morningside Heights to the
Gramercy Park area. As I recall, Mayor Ed Koch had told the cops to
crack down on cyclists, and tickets were being handed out rather
liberally. I was poor and didn’t want to get one. What I got instead,
as I waited for the light to change one day near Grand Central, was
rear-ended by a taxi that evidently expected me to run the light. I
wasn’t badly hurt, but I did need a new rear wheel, and I’ve been
skeptical of being law-abiding ever since.

As I read the posts from bloggers around the country about cycling and the law,
I’m continually struck by the confusion and misinformation that seems
to prevail almost universally. Today we’re featuring a post from SoapBoxLA that discusses a tragic case in which a woman riding a bicycle was struck and killed in a crosswalk:

LAPD’s Public Information Officer confirmed the report that the LAPD
considered the cyclist the "primary cause" of the incident because she
was riding a bike in a crosswalk which is a violation of CVC 21200
which requires a cyclist to obey the rules of the road. The PIO
explained that a cyclist must either dismount at crosswalks or ride on
the right side of the road with traffic.

I asked if he had ever
ridden the Orange Line Bike Path or the Chandler Bike Path or any of
the City’s bikeways facilities that actually direct cyclists into the
crosswalk at intersections. The PIO paused and then suggested that I
speak to the investigating officer.

I called the LAPD’s
Specialize Collision Investigation Detail (SCID) and spoke to the
investigating officer assigned to this case who also explained that
cyclists must obey the rules of the road which prohibit riding a bike
in the crosswalk. I asked for the actual vehicle code or municipal code
that prohibits cyclists from riding in the crosswalk and he simply
referred to CVC 21200 and repeated the claim that cyclists must
dismount before using a crosswalk.…

I believe we have an
obligation to be accurate in applying the law to this incident and it
is either illegal for a cyclist to ride a bike in a crosswalk or it’s
not. That is a simple issue that can be settled quickly and if the
LAPD’s appraisal of this incident is based on that ruling then it is
very important that we are accurate in applying the law.

contend that it is not illegal to ride a bike in the crosswalk. It
might not wise, it might not be advisable, but it is definitely not
illegal. cyclists are not required to dismount at intersections or at

The fact that
there is confusion over such a simple issue demonstrates the real need
for specific training for the LAPD on bicycling activities and
applicable regulations and laws.

Alternatives has the right idea with the Biking Rules initiative. But
in order for a truly law-based cycling culture to emerge in New York or
anywhere else, law enforcement, prosecutors and drivers all have to be
educated as well.The burden of doing things the right way — and
knowing what the right way is — shouldn’t fall primarily on cyclists.

Bonus: Today on Greater Greater Washington,
Stephen Miller writes about the opening of the fabulous Wilson Bridge
active transportation crossing between Virginia and Maryland — and the
baffling lack of bike access to the National Harbor on the Maryland

  • ian

    idaho laws should be nationalised.

    though i think they need to be modified so that the pedestrian, bike, car hierarchy is included… i.e. cars must yield to bikes but bikes must yield to pedestrians.


Carrots Are Good for You, and So Are Sticks

A very interesting post today on the Streetsblog Network from getDowntown, in Ann Arbor, Michigan. The getDowntown program, which aims to get more people using alternative modes of transportation through a variety of incentives and support systems, is a partnership between the Ann Arbor Area Chamber of Commerce, the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority, the City […]

SFPD Chief Suhr Misses the Point of the “Bike Yield Law”

SF Police Department Chief Greg Suhr doesn’t seem to grasp the point of the “Bike Yield Law” proposed by Supervisor John Avalos. “Stop signs are pretty simple. They say ‘stop,'” Suhr told KQED today. “They don’t say ‘yield,’ they don’t say ‘slow down.'” Suhr added that anyone who violates the letter of the stop sign law “will be […]

The Invisible People on Bikes Right in Front of Our Eyes

Today from Streetsblog Network member Honking in Traffic, an important reality check about a mostly overlooked segment of the bicycling population — people who ride bikes out of economic necessity and not necessarily by choice. These aren’t the oft-lauded "bike commuters" who ride for a sense of freedom and with at least some intention to […]

Wreckless Riding

Photo by Bryan Goebel. In 1978 I was a field manager for an environmental group’s canvassing operation and was driving "my crew" in an old beat-up Volkswagon from one suburb to the next. From about 3 p.m. we’d visit every house in a given area, knocking on doors seeking donations and support, ending around 8:30 […]