Carlyle Group’s New Infrastructure Public-Private Partnership: Donuts

As the federal deficit squeezes the Obama administration’s options for
financing ambitious new infrastructure projects, public-private
partnerships (PPPs) are gaining
currency as a possible solution. And in an illustration of PPPs’
potential, the $86 billion private-equity firm Carlyle Group yesterday struck a deal with the state of Connecticut to run … 23 highway rest stops.

628.x600.ft.dunkindonuts.jpgThe future of public-private partnerships? Hopefully not. (Photo: Time Out NY)

The $178 million Connecticut deal is the first PPP in the three years since Carlyle began raising money for its $1.15 billion infrastructure group, according to the Washington Post:

agreement … will include putting Subway restaurants as well as
Dunkin’ Donuts locations in the centers, according to a Carlyle
spokesman. Dunkin’ Donuts is owned by Carlyle.

the same Connecticut governor who called Carlyle’s donut investment "an
unprecedented commitment to … meeting the needs of the traveling
public" recently vetoed legislation that would have eliminated the need for significant transit fare hikes.

Is this what President Obama meant when he called for "more creative, new approaches" to fixing "infrastructure that is falling apart"? Let’s hope not.

Given that government audits have found
existing federal transit regulations riddled with obstacles to
attracting successful PPPs, perhaps it’s not surprising that Carlyle
chose to go the donuts route rather than collaborating on Connecticut
transit-oriented development projects in the vein of the New York MTA’s
Beacon Station revitalization.

But that’s no reason for Carlyle to take a victory lap while plans for a National Infrastructure Bank (NIB) remain
frustratingly unclear. If the administration follows through on its NIB
plans, information-sharing and incentives will be needed to prod
private capital into genuinely beneficial projects rather than new fast
food joints.

For a taste of how groundbreaking federal infrastructure PPPs could happen on the local level, this presentation [PDF] by the deputy general manager of the Boston area’s Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority is a good place to start.


The Footnote to All Those Complaints About Tax Cuts as Stimulus

Transportation reformers and status quo-lovers alike smacked their foreheads in frustration when the White House’s first stimulus plan lowballed infrastructure to make room for tax breaks that had little demonstrable effect on job creation — particularly the $70 billion adjustment of the alternative minimum tax (AMT). HOT lanes on Virginia’s I-495 are one of seven […]

Five Factors That Will Determine Whether TIFIA Benefits Transit

Phineas Baxandall is a senior analyst at the U.S. Public Interest Research Group. Last week, Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood touted his department’s $545.9 million TIFIA loan to construct Los Angeles’ 8.5-mile light rail transit line along the Crenshaw corridor as “just one example of how DOT’s TIFIA credit assistance program extends the value of America’s transportation dollar.” But will […]