The MA Senate Race: Consequences for Transport and Climate Policy

Democrats awoke this morning to find their worst fears realized,
as lackluster Senate hopeful Martha Coakley (D-MA) was upset by
Republican Scott Brown. Voters, lawmakers, and advocates are left to
wonder what becomes of their issues in a year already marked by
political upheaval.

brown_victory.jpgSen.-elect Scott Brown (R-MA), with his family on election night. (Photo: Globe)

On the transportation front, Brown’s election is unlikely to make passage of a new six-year bill any more difficult than it already is, with Democrats still in search of a way to finance the $450 billion-plus legislation many of them envision.

Brown ran as a critic of the gas tax increase floated early last year
by Democratic Gov. Deval Patrick (MA) to help close the state’s
transportation budget gap. As Brown’s campaign gained momentum in
recent weeks, however, he found himself taking fire from Democrats for voting in favor of a budget that merely preserved, rather than raised, an existing state fuel tax.

exchange underscores the conundrum that continues to stall a
reform-minded federal transport bill, whether Brown would vote yes or
not: Democrats have little appetite to find a way to pay for it.

Senate’s climate change debate, however, is a different story. Brown’s
election narrows the already slim chance of corralling enough Democrats to
approve an emissions-cutting bill opposed by fossil-fuel industries.
The promise of billion-dollar grants for local clean transport
programs, which was included in the Senate environment committee’s
bill, may well be lost for the time being.

What is possible on the environmental front? An "energy-only" bill that includes a renewable electricity standard has a stronger chance
of winning a Senate majority, and a Green Bank-type proposal focused on
leveraging private-sector money for transportation projects is still in the mix.

biggest question mark, then, is whether the Obama administration will
follow through on its intention to curb pollution through the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) if Congress fails to pass
legislation. The EPA’s air-quality chief suggested
last week the agency is on track, but a collapse of the White House’s
top priority — health care — could throw a wrench into the works.

  • An energy-only bill is not good enough to be the basis for an international agreement. We need the commitment to lower emissions that a cap-and-trade provides to negotiate internationally. That is where Obama got the numbers for the cuts that he promised in Copenhagen.

    Scientists generally agree that world ghg emissions must peak by 2015 in order to avoid the worst effects of global warming; a group of Nobel laureates issues a statement about a year ago saying that this is the scientific consensus.

    If the US passes a cap-and-trade bill this year, and an international agreement follows, then there is some chance of emissions peaking by 2015.

    If the US does not pass a cap-and-trade bill this year, then I think there is no chance of an international agreement for the next several years, at least – which means there is no chance of emissions peaking in time to avoid catastrophic global warming.

    We live in very strange times. We are making decisions about the world’s climate that will affect humanity dramatically for thousands of years. There is no doubt that people one hundred years from now will look back on this at the most important issue we are now facing. Yet most people are completely unaware of the deadlines that scientists say we face, and they place this issue somewhere in the middle of their priority list.

  • I want Howard Dean back as the Chair of the Democratic National Committee because I think he might be in a better position to smack “Change” back into elected Democratic D.C. politicians – get the message through that they need to stop pandering to lobbyists and big campaign contributors and concentrate on doing what is right for the other 96% of Americans who scrounged up small contributions to elect President Obama and who feel a bit betrayed at the moment.