All Aboard the Great Streetcar Debate

Streetcars provoke strong emotions in transpo geeks. A recent post on Human Transit called "Streetcars: An Inconvenient Truth" precipitated a very informed and sometimes heated thread of discussion on the relative virtues of light rail vs. bus rapid transit (a mode that got its moment in the limelight just this morning).

3327872868_bf8fb17b97_m.jpgStreetcars: Everybody’s got an opinion. Photo by adamscarroll via Flickr.

The Human Transit thread, which features several members of the Streetsblog Network,
elucidates many of the most important arguments for each mode: cost of
infrastructure;? access for wheelchairs, strollers and the like; speed;
and perceived desirability as a chosen transport mode (that part is all
about class). It’s a conversation well worth reading, and joining, for
anyone interested in the topic.

Here’s what Jarrett Walker, the blog’s author, wrote in part:

I’m not saying that the bus will ever be a perfect replica of the streetcar. It won’t. But they key fact is that buses are not just improving, they’re improving in the direction of emulating rail.
 This
should suggest that the difference between bus and rail, as perceived
by ordinary people who don’t know which features are intrinsic, is
going to diminish over time, as it has been doing for the
past two decades. Doesn’t this suggest that while the short-term
urban-development advantage of streetcars is undeniable, the long-term
advantage may be much less? Big capital spending has to make sense for the long term.
 Speed
and reliability are eternal values; I’m quite confident that in 2050,
people will still choose a faster service over a slower one.  I’m not
sure that in 2050, people will choose an electric vehicle on rails over
an electric/hydrogen/whatever vehicle of the same size and shape, with
many of the same characteristics, running on tires.  Are you?

Head on over and join the debate if you will.

For network member UrbanReview STL,
the issue is not streetcar vs. bus, but vintage reproduction streetcar
vs. modern streetcar. Blog author Steve Patterson is concerned that the
Loop Trolley route
being proposed in St. Louis will be running old-timey replicas rather
than up-to-date cars that allow for ease of boarding — and also send
the message that this mode is not simply some quaint artifact, but a
step into the future:

The Loop
Trolley folks want that vintage look rather than providing the best
transportation for the 21st Century. They are looking backward rather
than forward.

They are looking at a system like they have
in Little Rock AR. Little Rock’s vehicles are new but have a vintage
look and feel. Filming a period movie? Great, use these. Investing tens
of
millions in a modern transportation system that will last into the
second half of the 21st Century? Wrong choice! The Loop Trolley folks
are stuck in 1904. The World’s Fair is over, guys. So what is the
right choice?

Modern “low-floor” vehicles such as the
[ones] in Portland. The same type was used in Seattle. The vehicle’s
low-floor center design with wide doors make entry/exit easy for
everyone.  Stroller & packages? No problem…

To make the
reproduction cars accessible they’d have a ramp like our buses do. As a
frequent wheelchair user I can tell you I would not use such a system.
It works most of the time but it would set me apart from everyone
else.  The ramp would take time to extend & retract — holding up
traffic in the meantime. Why not just build an accessible system with
low-floor vehicles?

The trick is the modern low-floor vehicles cost roughly three times the price of a reproduction vehicle.

Other provocative items from around the network: Exquisite Struggle
picks up on a mind-blowing story about a school system that forbids its
students from coming to school by bike or foot, pointing out the
ironies of trying to "protect" our children by moving them to suburban
settings. (Bonus irony: the town in question is Saratoga Springs, home
of anti-sprawl guru James Howard Kunstler.) Ecovelo decides to open up the always-contentious "vehicular cycling" debate. And The Transport Politic argues against using the promise of congestion reduction as a way of promoting transit.

Less controversial: Austin on Two Wheels features a really cool program that is using bikes to improve people’s lives in Kenya.

  • So for example, the sentence could be revised like this:

    A recent post on Human Transit called “Streetcars: An Inconvenient Truth” precipitated a very informed and sometimes heated thread of discussion on the relative virtues of streetcars vs. local-stop buses.

  • Clarification: The conversation at my blog is specifically about local-stop services, so it’s not about light rail or bus rapid transit. For more, see my comment on the NYC version of this post.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

Making Room for Modes Other Than Cars

|
When we talk about competing modes of transportation we’re usually focused on the strained relationship between drivers and cyclists, or drivers and transit, or drivers and pedestrians. With so much street space taken up by cars, tensions also erupt, of course, between cyclists and pedestrians, and even cyclists and transit. We’ve written before about the […]
STREETSBLOG USA

New Wave of Development Follows Streetcar Construction in Mid-Sized Cities

|
When selecting a parking lot along the Kansas City streetcar line as the site for a 50-unit, five-story apartment building, Boulder-based developer Linden Street Partners was clear: “The streetcar is the big thing that drew us, absolutely,” the company’s Scott Richardson told the Kansas City Star. “We like the demographics and the economic trends. I walked the […]

Freight Rail, Streetcars Are Tops in Stimulus’ TIGER Chase

|
The Obama administration today announced the winners of $1.5 billion stimulus in highly competitive stimulus grants under the program known as Transportation Investments Generating Economic Recovery, or TIGER. Southeastern and midwestern freight rail projects were the day’s biggest winners, with urban streetcar projects also making a big splash. Freight rail in Chicago, where the CREATE […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Beyond Bus v. Rail: A Nuanced Approach to Evaluating Transit

|
Class A Exclusive right-of-way and separated from cross traffic Class B Exclusive right-of-way, NOT separated from cross traffic. Class C Mixed with traffic, including mixed with pedestrians. Rail Most rail rapid transit, using “third rail” power sources. Most classic “subway” and “metro” systems. Most “light rail” in surface operations. Parts of some European and Australian […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Planning a Streetcar? Better Get Your Zoning Right

|
Streetcars aren’t necessarily the fastest or cheapest way to get people from point A to point B, compared to, say, light rail or additional bus service. But cities around the country are racing to install new lines because streetcars can be a powerful tool for promoting urban development, of the walkable, transit-oriented, mixed-use, high-tax-revenue generating kind. But there’s […]