SFMTA Management Audit Released

IMG_2042.jpgSupervisors David Campos, David Chiu, and Ross Mirkarimi discuss the management audit at a press conference today. Photo: Michael Rhodes

San Francisco Budget and Legislative Analyst Harvey Rose has published the results of a limited-scope management audit [PDF] of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, which includes 22 recommendations that could save the agency a total of $3,090,645 annually.

We’re still combing through the details along with everyone else — including members of the Board of Supervisors. Among the top recommendations and areas for savings:

$1,215,645 in reduced transit operator standby pay

$500,000 in reduced salary costs for six transit operators currently serving as full- time union representatives, thereby permitting one transit operator to serve as a full- time union representative

$1,375,000 in estimated reduced unscheduled overtime costs.

The report also looks at issues with the governance structure of the SFMTA and its financial oversight. At a press conference this afternoon, Board of Supervisors President David Chiu said the results "confirm a lot of what we already know." The supervisors will discuss the results with Rose tomorrow at a 1:30 p.m. meeting of their Budget and Finance committee, where they’ll also take up a discussion of the SFMTA’s two-year budget.

We’ll have a full story on the report, including reaction from the SFMTA, later today. For now, check out its 22 recommendations for yourself.

  • Benjamin

    The management audit comes right out and says that, because of the salary floor in the City charter, “operators have no incentive to bargain over revision of [the] work rules” costing the City millions of dollars spent on absentee drivers and overtime for operators who haven’t actually worked more than forty hours a week.

    We need to reform the Muni work rules, which is exactly what Sean Elbernd and SPUR are trying to do with their Charter amendment campaign. If you haven’t already, visit fixmuninow.com to see the one chance we have this election cycle to make a positive difference in how things are done at Muni.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Many Recommendations, Few Surprises in SFMTA Management Audit

|
SFMTA Executive Director Nat Ford, SFMTA Board Chairman Tom Nolan, and SFMTA Board member Jerry Lee discuss the results of an SFMTA management audit. Photos: Michael Rhodes The results of a Muni management audit are out, and its 22 recommendations have set off a discussion about the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency’s governance and labor […]

Common Ground and Key Differences in Two Muni Operator Pay Measures

|
SPUR Executive Director Gabriel Metcalf gathers signatures for Supervisor Sean Elsbernd’s ballot measure. Photo: Michael Rhodes Depending on how you count it, the sweeping Muni ballot measure that four members of the Board of Supervisors introduced earlier this week has at least six major components, ranging from the governance of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation […]

Muni Operator Wage Measure Now Official

|
A ballot measure that would change the way Muni operator wages and benefits are set now has an official name and summary from the City Attorney’s Office. The measure [PDF], titled "Setting Transit Operator Wages Through Collective Bargaining," would do just that: instead of the current City Charter provision requiring the MTA to set operator […]

Supes Committee Holds off on Muni Operator Wage Proposal

|
An operator in training. Flickr photo: Troy Holden A proposed ballot measure that would change the way Muni operator salaries and benefits are set didn’t appear to have much steam after a tense Rules Committee meeting on Thursday. As the SF Appeal reported, the measure was roundly opposed by the Transit Workers Union, which represents […]