San Francisco Company Seeks to Expand Street Trees’ Reach

silva.jpgSan Francisco’s urban forest may look bushy and green, but below ground it’s suffering.

In order to pave a street, parking lot or sidewalk, the soil has to be tightly compacted to support the weight of asphalt and vehicles. Faced with hard-to-penetrate soil, tree roots have a difficult time expanding beyond their planting area — sort of like confining a person to their baby shoes for their entire life.

As a result, city tree growth is often stunted, with a meager canopy, shortened life span, and escalating costs for maintenance and replacement.

And that’s why DeepRoot, a national company with headquarters here in San Francisco, invented the Silva Cell.

"It’s a modular framework for creating empty vault surfaces underneath hardscapes or paving," explained DeepRoot Marketing Manager Leda Marritz. "You can stack them one, or two or three high — or higher — and fill them with high-quality, lightly-compacted soil that’s ideal for tree root growth."

The Silva Cell is like a Lego brick of tree-friendly soil, the kind of thing you might find at Ikea if they sold urban infrastructure.

Silva Cells are installed in the ground prior to paving, then paved over. Out of sight, they provide room for trees to expand, gaining water, nutrients, and structural stability.

"The vast majority of the street trees out there are suffering, and you can tell when you look at them," said Marritz. "On Market Street, for example, they’re tall but they’re in pretty bad shape. The canopy isn’t thick or even, the leaves are clustered around the outer branches. They don’t look like they would in a non-urban setting."

Unhealthy trees are expensive to treat and replace, but they cause other problems as well. Just last Tuesday, a tree at Fourth and Brannan split into pieces, collapsing onto cars. The tree was surrounded on all sides by an asphalt lot.

There are other consequences to unhealthy trees: They’re less attractive to wildlife, which reduces the city’s ability to support native species like songbirds and butterflies. And the tree’s potential to reduce stormwater runoff is reduced, placing further strain on the city’s overburdened sewage system.

DeepRoot’s Brenda Guglielmina explained, "A tree that’s just barely surviving every year is hardly pumping out any oxygen, hardly pumping water out of the ground. All that stuff just slows down, and it becomes a statue of a tree."

Silve_cell_Lincoln_Center.jpgSilva Cell installation at Lincoln Center in New York City. Image: DeepRoot.

"What’s sweet about the Silva Cell is that it can simply backfill with the existing native soil," said Doug Wildman, Program Director at Friends of the Urban Forest.

"We know that some trees can do okay with a limited soil volume," he said, but "their lifetime may be shortened, and in some conditions we’ll never achieve the volume that that tree requires."

Although he was cautious not to endorse the product without seeing more research about its efficacy, Wildman explained that space constraints often limit tree selection. "The size of the tree above ground is, in part, how we base the space," he said. "A large oak tree in the sidewalk would be kind of crazy in many situations, unless you had the space for it above and in the base itself."

So is the city of San Francisco on-board with Silva Cells? Not really. DeepRoot’s Marritz explained that there is only one Silva Cell installation in San Francisco, beneath Mint Plaza. It dates back to early in the development of the product, and doesn’t reflect the most up-to-date methodology.

The city’s reluctance to adopt the technology is in part due to its cost, which varies widely from project to project. Also, unlike many other cities in the bay area, San Francisco doesn’t have a legally required minimum soil volume. New developments in Palo Alto and Emeryville must devote a certain amount of below-ground space to trees; developments in San Francisco do not.

The Silva Cell’s cost becomes far more competitive when developers have to find a way to accommodate minimum soil volumes, which is why the company has pushed for the requirement in many municipalities.

"If the city had been working on soil volume goals, it would be a lot easier to slot us in," said Marritz.

Guglielmina agreed. "When we can get the cities to put in a tree soil volume requirement, then we can follow behind that," she said, and described the company’s work on the brand new tree-lined Hollis Doyle Park in Emeryville. "They left some trees in, and anyplace that they’ve replaced a tree, they’ve used Silva Cells.

"I know San Francisco is a great opportunity," she added, "but the city of Emeryville is all over our product, and I take the path of least resistance."

But the door hasn’t closed completely on Silva Cells in San Francisco. Rosey Jencks, who heads up stormwater planning at the Public Utilities Commission, remained open to their eventual use. "We are not in the business of promoting proprietary products," she said, "but I’m sure we’d look at them if someone wanted to use them to comply with the stormwater regulations."

In fact, it’s possible that in some situations, the Silva Cell’s stormwater advantages may outweigh its advantages for tree growth. "Stormwater is a huge component of it," Marritz explained. "The Silva Cell provides a legitimate ecologically-based system for managing storm water on site."

But the technology is still only a few years old, and many observers are waiting for further study before committing to it. "In some ways, San Francisco is really ahead of the game," said FUF’s Wildman. "This might be one area where we’re holding back."

Indeed, it’s often suburbs that adopt the Silva Cell before it spreads to nearby cities. "I can’t tell you how many cities around Seattle used the Silva Cell before Seattle did," said Guglielmina. "I think it’s easier to get through the politics in smaller cities."

  • throgers

    There’s an alternate system of “structural soil” that was developed by Cornell University:

    http://www.hort.cornell.edu/uhi/outreach/csc/index.html

    Now branded as “CU-Soil.” It’s patented, but licensed to a number of producers.

  • Very interesting – there always seems to be a new area of urbanism to explore and improve.

  • I really like this and never really thought of it. My only thought on urban trees was that the opening is usually so small that I can’t seem them getting access to much water.

    Also, how does this system work with utility lines?

  • One study showed that the Silva Cells outperform CU-Soil … but that study was done by DeepRoot, so take that however you will.

    Regarding utility lines: I’m not certain, but I think you would want to avoid having them close to roots. But as luck would have it, DeepRoot also makes a root barrier than can prevent encroachment.

  • Leda Marritz

    Hi there!

    I just wanted to chime in that the Bartlett Tree Lab study is not a Deep Root study. Bartlett is an independent lab that chooses their own test parameters, conditions, and technologies. Deep Root did not influence, pay for, or at any point become involved in the planning or design of that study. We also have no sway over the results, which we expect Tom Smiley to continue to publish about over the coming years.

    To answer the inquiry about utilities: because the Silva Cell is modular, there are a lot of easy ways to work around utilities. Practically every project we’re on has them and we have several established techniques for accommodating them effectively. I’d be happy to go in to more detail if you wish, but won’t bore you with it here!

  • Sean T Hedgpeth

    Does anyone know what sort of system Redwood Park uses next to TransAmerica? Redwood roots grow very shallow and have a huge range. I wonder if there is a ratio one could use to see how tall those trees could grow in urban conditions.

  • That’s an excellent question, Sean, and I don’t know the answer. It is particularly relevant as a pretty major construction project is planned for the area: http://www.flickr.com/photos/walkingsf/4610332903/

  • =v= The urban forest is a passion of mine, in part because I’m such a treehugger and also because they’re very imnportant for a good streetscape. Nothing calms traffic better than mature street trees, and an improved tree basin will allow more trees to live longer.

    The ficus at 4th and Brannan suffered from a much worse problem, though. In general, San Francisco street trees are very poorly maintained and usually malpruned. The usual situation is that they are “lion’s-tailed,” with the entire lower canopy cut away, which destroys their traffic-calming value, and also weakens the lower branches to the point where they come crashing down.

    Part of the problem is that many tree species are a poor fit for urban environments. San Francisco has many broadleaved evergreen trees, and since they don’t shed leaves in the winter, many homeowners have them malpruned to let more light in. In commercial districts they get hacked away so people can see window signs. All of this makes our streets less liveable.

  • mattymatt, I think that project is on hold (or scraped) because the supes shot down 555 Washington.

  • Jason Dewees

    Keep up the excellent arboreal reportage. The urban forest is a neglected aspect of urban planning, transportation, and our San Franciscan lives. Whether we’re talking about ROI or QOL, trees make a huge, often subtle, impact.
    The use of cookie-cutter trees (e.g., London plane, Callery pear) in San Francisco’s unusual climate and soils leaves many plantings looking threadbare and deprive us of the sense of place arising from the trees and plants that would actually thrive here, even in sidewalks.

  • James

    Always enjoy good tree coverage. Thanks!

  • Anonymous

    Good job !! thanks for the valuable share!

    http://www.home2garden.co.uk/acatalog/Garden_Planters.html

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

San Francisco Moves to Lessen the Impact of Truck Traffic

|
Click to enlarge: The revised San Francisco truck route map. Image: SFMTA In a city as dense as San Francisco, it’s inevitable that truck traffic often travels along streets where people live. But public health and environmental justice groups, the MTA and the Department of Public Health are now collaborating to ensure that the impact […]
STREETSBLOG USA

NACTO to Take Safer Street Designs to Developing World Cities

|
Last year, the National Association of City Transportation Officials brought us the Urban Street Design Guide, and now it’s going global. During the organization’s national conference in San Francisco last Thursday, NACTO chair and former New York City transportation commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan announced that it will be developing a “Global Street Design Guide” to help developing […]

San Francisco is Sinking!

|
UN Plaza, Market and 7th, the waters from the subterranean "Mighty Hayes River"!! Famously, we live on a crack in the earth. The San Andreas Fault gets most of our attention, followed not too far behind these days by the equally ominous Hayward Fault. A major earthquake on either of these could alter local landscapes […]