Cyclist Killed at Alemany Boulevard and Silver Avenue

This "black spot" intersection needs to be closed and investigated until it can be made safe

Some police tape and some surgical gloves were all that marked where a man was hit fatally yesterday. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick
Some police tape and some surgical gloves were all that marked where a man was hit fatally yesterday. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick

Hoodline is reporting that a cyclist was killed yesterday at around 5:30 p.m. in a collision with a car at the intersection of Silver and Alemany Boulevard. The San Francisco Bicycle Coalition says the victim’s name was Moises Chavez, a 51-year-old man. “Our hearts are heavy this morning and our thoughts are with family and friends of the victim,” they wrote on their Twitter feed.

“Alemany is a high-injury corridor–one of the 12 percent of city streets that account for 70 percent of severe and fatal crashes. So this tragic death is not an ‘accident’–it’s a predictable result of a dangerous transportation system,” said Cathy DeLuca, Interim Executive Director of Walk San Francisco. “To prevent future tragedies like this one, the City must build streets that protect everyone–especially people biking and walking, who are the most vulnerable in crashes.”

Streetsblog went to the intersection to survey it. There’s construction going on. The bike lanes are pretty much scraped away, covered, discontinuous; there’s gravel all about. But at this ‘black spot,’ as the Dutch call an intersection where someone is killed, there’s no sign of an investigation. In fact, there’s no sign of what happened at all, except perhaps for some leftover police tape (as seen in the lead image), a few surgical gloves blowing around that may be from the first responders, and just south of the intersection, there are some spots of what looks like dried blood.

Unfortunately, the work crews’ shift ended yesterday about an hour before the crash occurred. It’s a quiet residential area, without much pedestrian activity; no sign of security cameras or anyone who might have seen what happened. The driver of the car, it’s reported, remained at the scene.

But Russell Ibrahim Blank summed it up perfectly when he posted on the San Francisco Bike Ride Crew Facebook page “Damn, look at that intersection. It was designed for cars to speed through, not with pedestrian safety (or, in this case, a person on a bike) in mind.” Or as Nathan Woody posted: “Terrifying looking intersection. How many is that this year?”

It’s the second cyclist killed this year. The first was Gashaw Clark, 25, killed on April 28 in Mission Bay.

Streetsblog is familiar with this intersection and it’s an absolute travesty that this is what passes for bicycle infrastructure. There’s the aforementioned striped door-zone lane on a street designed for high speeds. But even that bike striping ends as cyclists enter the intersection–where they are most vulnerable. This publication could call on SFMTA again to fix these intersections with planters and safe hit posts or old railway ties or even toilet plungers or whatever they can find as soon as humanly possible, but what would be the point? Let’s just study it some more.

It’s worth noting that this death took place almost exactly a year from the deaths of Heather Miller and Kate Slattery. Their deaths on the same night in June of last year galvanized a city, albeit briefly. But the danger on our streets didn’t start and end that night. It’s about a broader problem–it’s about attitudes that prioritize parking, car throughput, and personal convenience over life and limb. That attitude is displayed by the actions of the very people charged with keeping us safe. And by the managers and politicians who maintain a culture where safety, despite the rhetoric, is very definitely not the highest concern. Otherwise, why isn’t the city doing what the Dutch would do–declare that intersection a black spot, close it, and get all the relevant city agencies there to investigate it. And then fix it.

“The City has the tools to save lives. They just need the guts to put them in the ground quickly, no matter the obstacles,” said DeLuca.

Maybe the guerrilla safety group SFMTrA can help on Alemany?

Streetsblog will aggregate more details on yesterday’s death as they become available.

A cyclist passing through the "black spot" where a man died yesterday in a traffic collision. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick
A cyclist passing through the “black spot” where a man died yesterday in a traffic collision. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick
  • Come Corrected

    For the benefit of anyone reading this article, don’t click on links. They aren’t relevant to the article itself. The blood in the left lane is true as well as the trash left after the investigation. This was right outside our house and it was very sad to see. Still looking to find out exactly what happened.

  • HappyHighwayman

    How does one deal with the CONSTRUCTION crews that block the bike lanes?

  • p_chazz

    Maybe by getting off your bike and walking it on the sidewalk?

  • dat

    Maybe you can get out of your car and push it through the intersection.

  • p_chazz

    I don’t have a car. I never even learned how to drive. But I do exercise caution when I am in a hazardous situation.

  • NoeValleyJim

    Did you ever find out?

  • leetramp

    I ride through this intersection everyday on my commute. The construction crew is great at putting ‘Bikes may use entire lane’ signs at the start of and throughout the section of Alemany that is reduced to one lane. I usually ride inside their coned construction lane until I get to the area where I encounter their digging, then I return to the travel lane and ‘take the lane’ until I clear the construction.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

SFMTA Crews Begin Striping Alemany Boulevard Buffered Bike Lanes

|
Alemany Boulevard will soon be dramatically safer for cycling as SFMTA crews began striping the city’s newest stretch of buffered bike lanes today. Despite acting as a vital connection between the Glen Park and Bayview neighborhoods, this stretch of Alemany between Rousseau Street and Bayshore Boulevard [pdf] has long been uninviting for people who bike […]

Proving to Caltrans That El Camino Real Can Be a Safer Street

|
Despite pockets of new development, El Camino Real remains a dangerous, car-oriented urban highway along most of the San Francisco Peninsula. If it can ever transform into a great street, it will have to become safer for walking and biking. And while enhancing walkability is a key goal of the Grand Boulevard Initiative — the long-term planning […]
better-market-street-project-map

Study: Diagonal Intersections Are Especially Dangerous for Cyclists

|
This week, Cambridge, Massachusetts, unveiled plans for a “peanutabout” that will make a tricky intersection with irregular angles safe for cycling. This type of design intervention could be crucial for locations that new research suggests are especially dangerous. In a study published in the journal Injury Prevention [PDF], a team led by Dr. Morteza Asgarzadeh of Harvard’s T. H. […]