BART Responds to FTA Rebuke, Defends Minority and Equity Practices

Coliseum_Station_small.jpgProposed Coliseum Station OAC connections. Photo: BART

In a strongly worded reply to Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Administrator Peter Rogoff yesterday [PDF], a number of BART Board Directors and General Manager Dorothy Dugger contested the FTA’s assertion that BART has not complied with its obligations to minority riders under Federal Civil Rights Act Title VI in relation to the fare for the future Oakland Airport Connector (OAC). Citing a number of public meetings and involvement by several minority organizations in planning for the OAC, the letter asserts that BART is inclusive in its planning process and encourages public input.

"Our organization always has been and will continue to be committed to providing non-discriminatory, equitable, accessible and safe public transportation to the communities and residents of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Area," reads the letter. "BART takes strong exception to the assertion in your January 15 letter suggesting otherwise and the alleged admission by BART during the compliance review conducted in December 2009."

At the same time, the letter says that BART will do everything required of it by the FTA to guarantee that the $70 million in federal stimulus funds in question will not be de-obligated and sent elswhere, a move that could imperil the OAC.

BART spokesperson Linton Johnson struck an even more conciliatory tone, saying that conversations with the FTA throughout the day yesterday had changed dramatically and that BART was confident it would meet all its obligations to establish an action plan by the March 5th deadline imposed by the FTA for the federal stimulus money.

"We believe that all the Title VI work that we’ve done over the years is legally sound and meets legal muster," said Johnson.

At the same time, Johnson acknowledged that BART needed to establish clearer standards. "The guidelines under which a policy is set that defines a major service change I don’t think has been met by BART." Explaining why BART didn’t do a more thorough equity analysis on the fares for the OAC prior to this point, Johnson said, "Our reasoning has been that we didn’t conduct a fare equity study because we don’t know what the fare is going to be."

"We have a clear path forward to resolve these issues and receive the federal money," vowed Johnson, adding that there were benchmarks along the way before March that would help them reach their obligations.

John Knox White of TransForm, a consistent critic of the OAC project, said TransForm and its allies would continue to push for BART to complete more rigorous analysis of the project’s equity impacts. He also said BART’s response demonstrates an inability to understand the issue at

"Nobody is arguing that there weren’t public meetings on the OAC,
the issue is that these meetings did not present accurate or credible
information," said White. "BART’s staff refused to present information requested by
MTC Commissioners, the ACTIA Board, Port of Oakland Commissioners, the
Oakland City Council, and members of their own Board, as well as Bay
Area residents and community organizations."

"BART has already
attempted a slapdash analysis of this project and it has been rejected
by the FTA. It is not be credible to have BART staff rehire the same
OAC consultants who were paid thousands of dollars to ‘debunk’
TransForm’s RapidBART proposal and the community," said White, referring to a May 2009 email from Tom Dunscombe, OAC Project Manager at BART, to several consultants on the project. 

In the email, Dunscombe asked the consultants to debase TransForm’s RapidBART proposal. "Any information you can provide to put holes in this would be appreciated – we have some worried Board members and I need to easily discredit this ‘paper,’" he wrote.

Notably absent from the BART letter to the FTA was Board Director Tom Radulovich, who yesterday told Streetsblog that BART staff has repeatedly "stonewalled" his requests for the agency to develop equity and social justice policies.

Johnson confirmed that Radulovich had asked for those policies, among many other requests. "He has asked staff to do a lot of work that in legal’s opinion wasn’t
legally required," said Johnson.

"We believe
we’ve been legally compliant in what we were supposed to do."

The Metropolitan Transportation Commission had no comment for this story, though spokesperson Randy Rentschler told Streetsblog they would have more later today.


BART Loses More Federal Funding for Oakland Airport Connector Project

Image: BART As transportation planners and transit agencies around the country celebrated the announcement of the $1.5 billion in Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery, or TIGER grants, yesterday, BART received more troubling news that could hurt the feasibility of its planned Oakland Airport Connector (OAC). After losing $70 million in stimulus funds last week because […]

Advocates Want Oakland Airport Connector Funds for Transit Operations

Image: TransForm With the civil rights imbroglio between BART and the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) making news last week, a problem that could imperil $70 million in federal stimulus funds obligated to the Oakland Airport Connector (OAC), advocates are calling on the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) to give the stimulus money to cash-strapped transit operators […]

FTA Probes MTC Civil Rights Policy, Casts Shadow on Funding Practices

MTC’s Executive Director Steve Heminger, foreground, listens to public testimony against MTC’s plan to use federal stimulus funds for the Oakland Airport Connector last year. Photo: Matthew Roth The Federal Transit Administration has increased the likelihood the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), the Bay Area’s regional transportation planning and funding body, will undergo a full civil […]

Oakland’s Stimulus Flap: A Shot Across the Bow for Transport Equity?

The Obama administration’s warning that the Bay Area has jeopardized federal stimulus funding for its Oakland Airport Connector (OAC) project could have national consequences for other urban transit proposals that risk harming low-income riders, civil rights and transit advocates predicted today. The proposed Oakland Airport Connector train. (Photo: BART via Streetsblog SF) Several Bay Area […]

Oakland Airport Connector Clears One More Hurdle

OAC image: BART Transit advocates, community groups, and faith-based environmental justice organizations made another plea to Oakland and regional policy makers to kill the half a billion dollar Oakland Airport Connector (OAC) with a resolution sponsored by Oakland City Council members Nancy Nadel and Rebecca Kaplan at their monthly meeting last night. Citing a significantly […]