California’s Personal Vehicle Sharing Law Could Diminish Need to Own a Car

Photo: City CarShare
Will you be sharing your Mini? Photo: City CarShare

As more teens wait to get their licenses and young adults drive fewer miles annually, advertisers have begun to point to advances in digital technology to explain the trend. Many younger adults use digital media to connect to their friends virtually, the argument goes, and technological innovations will likely reduce the incentive to own and operate a car.

Now, with the passage of a new law in California that allows current car owners to share their personal vehicles in a car sharing service and make money without voiding their personal insurance policy, the age of owning a car as a rite of American adulthood may be ceding to a new vision of vehicles as a social service.

Because your car spends on average more than 90 percent of the time parked and idle, proponents of personal vehicle sharing argue, why not make money instead of sitting by as your investment depreciates in a garage?

“We feel like this is a historic moment. This legislation basically revolutionizes the idea of the automobile into being a shared service,” said Sunil Paul, CEO of Spride Inc, a personal car-sharing start-up company. “We think it can have a huge impact over the next many years about the way we think about the automobile.”

On the heels of the announcement that Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed AB 1871 into law yesterday, Spride and City Carshare, the San Francisco non-profit that helped pioneer car sharing, announced a partnership to facilitate personal car sharing in the Bay Area. Once AB 1871 takes effect January 1st, the new Spride Share pilot program will allow car owners to loan their vehicles to the more than 13,000 screened and qualified members of City CarShare, offsetting the costs and environmental impact of private car ownership while providing City CarShare members with access to a greater variety of vehicles.

Car owners who choose to participate in the program will outfit their cars with City Carshare’s key and lock technology and designate the hours their vehicle will be free through CitycarShare’s website. Very little will change for existing City CarShare members, except they will have a wider selection of vehicles, some of them owned by individuals instead of the non-profit. Paul announced he would be signing up his own Toyota Hylander Hybrid as the first personal vehicle in the fleet.

City CarShare’s mission has always been in part to mitigate environmental damage caused by excessive driving and they saw the new partnership as one that will expand their reach beyond San Francisco. “By adding Spride Share vehicles to our fleet, we can extend our service to more people in more locations through better utilization of existing vehicles,” said Rick Hutchinson, CEO of City CarShare. “Spride’s new model brings us one step closer to achieving our mission by helping our communities become transit-oriented while mitigating carbon emissions.”

Assemblymember Dave Jones (D-Sacramento), who wrote the law and guided it through the legislative process this year, said the bill had enjoyed bipartisan support because it was both an incentive to business entrepreneurs and because it promised to reduce the environmental impacts of driving. Jones, who is the Democratic nominee for California Insurance Commissioner in this November’s election, worked with car insurance companies from the beginning to craft a solution amenable to them. With the passage of AB 1871, he expected a rush of new for-profit and non-profit companies to join Spride and other start-ups in personal vehicle sharing.

“The insurance impediment had really frozen entrepreneurs from getting into the market,” said Jones. “I think it could have a very revolutionary impact. It will potentially reduce the need for as many personal vehicles, with concurrent reductions in traffic and parking impacts.”

Jones, who said he would sign his own vehicle up to a personal sharing service, was impressed with how personalized vehicle sharing could be as social networking becomes more sophisticated. The stigma of letting a stranger use your car, he argued, could be mitigated by limiting use of your vehicle to a designated circle of Facebook friends, for instance. “The potential to define the social network within which you would share your car based on some of the social media applications is fascinating,” said Jones.

Young adults are waiting longer to get their licenses and driving less. Image: Ad Age.
Young adults are waiting longer to get their licenses and driving less. Image: ## Age##.

Zipcar, the nation’s largest car-sharing company, has yet to make an announcement indicating it would add personal vehicles to its fleet and Jessica Scorpio, a co-founder of the personal car-sharing company Getaround, doesn’t imagine they will any time soon.

She noted the traditional car-sharing business model flourishes in dense urban areas, but doesn’t pencil out as well in suburban markets, where personal vehicle sharing companies see the greatest potential to entice new customers.

Getaround started as a thesis project by Scorpio and several classmates at Singularity University, an interdisciplinary school based at the NASA Ames facility whose mission is to “assemble, educate and inspire leaders who strive to understand and facilitate the development of exponentially advancing technologies in order to address humanity’s grand challenges.” Scorpio said reducing personal car ownership and limiting the impact driving has on the planet were two challenges that Getaround hoped to tackle.

The company has been operating for a year and a half in the admittedly gray area of insurance liability that had prevailed until the new law was passed. Though Scorpio declined to provide membership statistics, she said car owners who participated in Getaround were covered by the company’s insurance during the rental period. She also noted there could have potentially been questions from insurance companies in the event of an accident, but none had occurred.

“[AB 1871] makes it more black and white. It ensures that insurance companies cannot penalize people who share their vehicles,” said Scorpio, who doesn’t own a car but occasionally rents one from Getaround. She also thought advances in technology would continue to chip away at car ownership.

“We see smart phones as a huge enabling factor in the whole thing,” she said, pointing to the inefficiency of leaving a private vehicle idle for so much of its life as an incentive to switch from owning to sharing. She even imagined a scenario where city governments and car-sharing companies provided a fleet with taxpayer money that would complement more traditional public transportation. “People are hopefully going to use cars much smarter. Having them sit around more than 90 percent of the time doesn’t seem smart.”

As for those car owners who are too attached to their own car and protest at the thought of sharing it, Scorpio wasn’t too concerned. She said there was an enormous market of drivers who would give up their cars if they could reliably use a shared vehicle to meet their mobility needs.

“More and more people are going to access a car when they need it for an activity, rather than owning a car,” she said.

UPDATED: 11:06 am

  • this is a great idea! this is especially great for young people. I remember when I was going to school what a huge budget hassle it was to pay for a car all the time. if I could have shared it in a car sharing service to recoup some costs, or better yet NOT own a car and just pay when I needed one, I would have saved a lot of money.

  • Clutch J

    AB 1871 was authored by Sacramento Assemblymember Dave Jones, the Democratic nominee for CA Insurance Commissioner. This bill is indicative of the innovative, energetic leadership we can expect from the tenacious, ambitious Jones should he win his race in November.

  • Stephen G

    Just was curious if this law means I can now use my buddy’s extra car for a couple months and pay him for it. The problem I have is that my insurance won’t let me insure a vehicle where I’m not the registered own. And his would be invalidated if he accepts money from me for it.

    But this law doesn’t really change that at all, as the insurance must be through a “personal vehicle sharing program”. The only benefit to me might be that it could be possible to run his car through one of those programs, except I’m the only renter. Seems to be too early yet though to see if that will be possible, and how much.

    But this opens up a bunch of opportunities, for both entrepreneurs and for occasional drivers! Awesome move forward!

  • @ Stephen G,
    You raise some excellent points that have yet to be ironed out. As you note, the vehicle would still need to be insured by the car-share company, which would have the comprehensive $1 million-plus coverage, so it doesn’t directly address your concern. That said, I think the innovative opportunities to come will be very interesting. There may be a time where he can rent it just to you with an insurance package that doesn’t have to go through the car-sharing company. I’m intrigued to see where this all goes.

  • It’s just too bad even car sharers still block crosswalks (see photo).

  • Bob Davis

    The idea of restricting use of the shared personal car to a limited circle of friends, members of an affinity group, etc. rather than a large number of strangers may answer one of the questions: What if my car is used in the commission of a crime? To bring up an issue that’s often discussed in sites like this: What if one of the drivers other than me runs over a bicyclist? What if one of the other drivers totals the car after a night of drinking?

  • Carol S.

    I have just recently run head-on (pun intended!) into this problem, as my mom has just sustained a hand injury that is preventing her from driving her car, the sole vehicle in our family. If she and I could “car-share” her vehicle, I could drive her around everywhere she needs to go. We don’t have this law in Canada yet… might be a good idea for people such as myself who don’t own a car but need access to one to take care of an older parent or sibling.


California Assembly Passes Personal Car-Sharing Insurance Bill

Photo: Scott Beale/Laughing Squid The California Assembly voted unanimously yesterday to support AB 1871, a bill that would allow car owners to share their personal vehicles in coordination with car-sharing services without voiding their personal auto insurance. The bill opens the door to redefining car ownership, leading to economic, environmental and traffic congestion improvements, according […]

Does Car Sharing Reduce Your Driving?

A spirited debate broke out a few weeks back on the Car-free Living listserv run by Livable City about the merits of car sharing. Does it reduce driving and car ownership or increase the impetus to drive among the car-free? One poster who didn’t own his own car called car-sharing a gateway drug that encouraged […]

How Car Sharing Gradually Weans Users Off Driving

A number of studies have attempted to put a figure on the reduction in vehicles that results from car sharing services. Research from UC Berkeley’s Susan Shaheen goes a step further and quantifies how car sharing reduces driving. Even though most customers didn’t own their own cars before subscribing, Shaheen found that the overall impact […]