Ballot Primer for an Election that Will Drive You to Drink

A standing-room only crowd drank beer and listened to the experts at SPUR breakdown SF's ballot measures. Photo: Streetsblog
A standing-room only crowd drank beer and listened to SPUR’s experts break down SF’s ballot measures. Photo: Streetsblog

Yesterday evening, over 220 people squeezed into the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association’s (SPUR) downtown S.F. location to hear the organization’s policy experts explain which ballot measures they are endorsing. With 25 measures on the San Francisco ballot this November 8, each of the six SPUR experts spent just a few minutes on each decision–and it still took nearly two hours to get through them all.

Thankfully, they also offered bottles of beer at the door.

Here’s a sampling of some of the most Streetsblog-relevant “yes” recommendations:

Measure RR (for “Railroad”)

SPUR started with Measure RR, the $3.5 billion regional bond measure to update, repair and replace all of BART’s aging infrastructure. “Obviously, we say vote ‘yes'” said Ratna Amin, SPUR’s Transportation Policy Director. She spoke about the Washington D.C. Metro, which is about the same age as BART–and has suffered serious breakdowns as a result of deferred maintenance. “We don’t want to go down that road.” She praised the bond for offering some monies for studying a second set of BART tubes, which she described as “dreamy things.” Streetsblog, of course, agrees that RR should be a “yes,” and officially endorsed it earlier this week. This could be a tough one, as it’s a dedicated tax and therefore requires two-thirds of all votes in the three-county BART District (San Francisco, Alameda, and Contra Costa) to pass.


SPUR's panel. That's Ratna Amin, SPUR's transportation expert, in the foreground. Photo: Streetsblog
SPUR’s panel. That’s Ratna Amin, SPUR’s transportation expert, in the foreground. Photo: Streetsblog

Measures K and J (money for homeless services, transit, and safe streets):

These two measures would go to fund homeless services, transportation, and Vision Zero goals. They are written in a way that gets around the two-thirds threshold for a dedicated sales tax, and each requires a simple majority to pass. K increases the effective sales tax in San Francisco by 0.75 percent, from 8.75 to 9.25 percent (the math works out because a previous sales tax expires concurrently). Prop. J, meanwhile, is a city charter amendment that dedicates money from the general fund to homelessness and transportation programs. Taken together, that means $95.5 million will go to San Francisco transportation in the first year. “It protects against future cuts, with eighteen percent going to infrastructure and the Muni fleet, escalators, rails, wires… nine percent for optimization and expansion, twelve percent for Vision Zero, bike lanes, driver education,” explained Amin. ” This will close a $6 billion gap in our transportation needs between now and 2030.”

Proposition E (for “Tree”)

Laura Tam, Sustainable Development Policy Director, discussed Proposition E, which transfers responsibility for maintaining street trees to the city. This measure pays for the costs through a $19 million set-aside from the general fund, adjusted annually. “Currently it’s inconsistent,” said Tam. “Seventy percent of trees are the responsibility of the [adjacent] property owner and thirty percent are maintained by the city.” But, she added, it’s often difficult to know which ones fall under which umbrella, which results in many trees dying because of lack of maintenance. “E recognizes that this is bad policy,” she said.

Another look at SPUR's center during the Ballots and Brews discussion. Photo: Streetsblog.
The SPUR panel discusses ballot measures while the audience drinks brews. Photo: Streetsblog.

It was obvious from the discussion that SPUR’s experts had done their homework. Streetsblog encourages its readers to follow their recommendations, especially on the decisions specified above. For the full slate of SPUR recommendations, including a few undecideds, check out its voter guide. Or follow the chart below:

SPUR created this handy cheat sheet/voter guide. Image: SPUR
SPUR created this handy cheat sheet/voter guide. Image: SPUR

As to the rest of the ballot, SPUR also has the right idea–it’s best combined with beer.

For more events like these, visit SPUR’s events page.


SPUR Young Urbanists: Ballots and brews

"Join the Young Urbanists for an informal gathering and learn what’s on the ballot for the June election and what it means for San Francisco. You’ll hear the inside story from SPUR policy staff and other members of our ballot analysis committee. BYOB: Bring your own ballot and we’ll provide some wine (and beer), snacks […]

SPUR: Ballots and Brews

From SPUR: With twelve measures before voters, the November 2014 ballot is shaping up to be one of the most complicated and interesting in recent years. Come join the SPUR policy staff all-stars in an annual tradition as they explain the ballot over drinks. Generously sponsored by the Koret Foundation. + Egon Terplan / SPUR + Ratna Amin / SPUR + Eli Zigas / SPUR + Ben […]

SPUR talk on Local Measures: BART Bond Passes, Mixed Results on Others

This afternoon, the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR), hosted a post-election analysis of local races and measures with political consultants David Latterman of Fall Line Analytics and Alex Clemens of Lighthouse Public Affairs. Clemens started off his presentation and summed up the mood in the room with a single word: “sh*t!” […]

This Week: Vision Zero, Fruitvale Bike-Share, Ballots and Brews

Here are this week’s highlights from the Streetsblog calendar: Tuesday Vision Zero Action Strategy Workshop. The city is in the process of updating its two-year action strategy for Vision Zero. Join this public meeting to help determine what works and revise elements as part of the next 2017-2018 Action Strategy for Vision Zero San Francisco. The […]

Ballots and brews

From SPUR: Join the Young Urbanists for an informal gathering and learn what (and who) is on the ballot for the November election. This year’s election will include eight ballot measures and will decide who will be San Francisco’s next Mayor. BYOB (Bring Your Own Ballot) and come hear the inside story from SPUR policy […]