Gauging a Transpo Bill’s Chances in the Senate

It remains to be seen whether lawmakers will move on a new long-term federal transportation bill
this year. If they do, what might the opposition look like, and how
will legislators react? These are the questions posed today by Yonah
Freemark at The Transport Politic.


get an idea of how a new funding package might fare in the Senate,
Freemark has compiled a scorecard of key transportation votes — which
he’s dubbed the Transport Index 2009. As with most issues, the Index
finds that support for investment in sustainable modes and maintenance
of existing infrastructure is split along party lines.

In response to the President’s State of the Union Address in February, Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal (R) criticized the stimulus, arguing that it was "larded with wasteful spending."
He pointed to the $8 billion devoted to high-speed rail as a
specifically unnecessary expenditure. It became clear at that moment
that the road to an improved American transportation system would not
be a straight shot. How will the members of the Senate react when they
are forced to consider expanding the federal commitment to
transportation? That’s what this Transport Index is intended to

The health reform debate of the last several
weeks has made evident the fact that Republicans in Congress will be
able to rile up an intimidating opposition to legislation proposed by
the Democratic Party. Though Democrats have 60 seats in the Senate — a
number that is large enough to vote down a potentially fatal filibuster
— the sudden arrival of thousands of right-wing demonstrators on scene
at town hall meetings has slowed down and problematized the passage of
any legislation.

Would Republicans stage a similar temper
tantrum if the Congress embarked on a massive transportation program?
It’s unclear, but Mr. Jindal’s reaction in February indicates that it’s
a distinct possibility.

What do you think of this ranking
system? Can Democratic senators from Montana, North Dakota, and
Arkansas be counted on to support a bill that invests in urban transit?

More on the Network: Hard Drive details how a bike shop owner in Portland, Oregon has instituted his own Cash for Clunkers program; Urban Review STL looks at how towns are messing up Main Street; Copenhagenize anticipates the arrival of "bicycle superhighways"; and Plan Philly reports on a city plan to speed bus travel.

  • soylatte

    Well… you learn something new every day. Prior to reading this article, I didn’t think it was possible for my despise of Bobby Jindal to increase any further.



Sneak Preview: 2013 in Transit

Bus rapid transit projects in Austin, Tampa, and the Twin Cities. Streetcars in St. Louis, New Orleans, and Detroit. Those are just a few of the transit projects beginning construction or entering service in 2013, which looks to be a pretty good year for transit expansion in the U.S., says Yonah Freemark at the Transport […]

Suburban Poverty and the Transit Connection

Today on the Streetsblog Network, Yonah Freemark of The Transport Politic looks at the new Brookings Institution report on suburban poverty levels and the connection to future transportation planning in those regions. Freemark, who recently wrote about how the city of Paris is extending its transit infrastructure to its traditionally lower-income suburbs, points out that […]

Reminder: States Already Control Transpo $, and They Waste Billions

To hear some key Republican lawmakers talk transportation policy, you’d think that state DOTs are straining under the burden of onerous national mandates. Even some notable voices in the urbanist camp, like Harvard economist Ed Glaeser, are saying that federal control leads to inefficient spending, notes Yonah Freemark at the Transport Politic in his latest post. Freemark points […]