The Importance of Making the Connection

Yesterday, I made the trip from Brooklyn, NY, to Jersey City, NJ, to
visit the Liberty Science Center. It really wasn’t hard to do, although
it required three separate transfers — from the F train to the A
train, from the A to the PATH train, and then from the PATH to the
Hudson-Bergen Light Rail line.

All
in all, it was a fine trip. The light rail ride was especially
enjoyable, and the museum is an easy, well-marked walk from the stop.
I’m certainly happy the place was accessible by transit at all.

But
it took me a good bit of time at home on the computer to plot the
journey (which is probably less than five miles as the crow flies). And
aside from the across-the-platform transfer from the F to the A, the
connections all involved walking out of a station and through the
street with very little help from signs. Not everyone would go to the
trouble of figuring it out, especially when the perception is that it’s
so "easy" to drive there (a perception reinforced by acres and acres of
parking at the museum, and the primacy given to driving directions on
the Science Center’s website). This is especially true for those
traveling with young kids, which most people are in this case.

So I admit to feeling a little envy when I saw this post today from Human Transit about well-designed transfers between urban and suburban transit lines in Vienna:

6a00d83454714d69e20120a57d7c81970c_320wi.jpgIn Vienna, your connecting train will be waiting for you across the platform. It really will.

If
you’re going from a part of the city on
one line to an outer suburb that’s on the other, you just walk across
the platform. What’s more, the trains actually pause here for about
half a minute, so there’s plenty of time to make the move. 

The
trains make this timed connection even though they are both running
every five minutes. In most North American and Australasian systems, we
wouldn’t worry about trying to time a connection when things are that
frequent; we’d judge that a wait of less than five minutes for a
connection wouldn’t matter much. But it still matters some, especially
when lots of people are doing it, so the Austrians have taken the
trouble to get it right. Even at high frequencies, connections can be
points of stress for customers, who don’t know whether the connecting
train’s about to leave. The customers on this connection can relax,
because they know the trains will hold…

Connections
can’t always be this easy, but good agencies are always trying to make
them as easy as possible. Remember, if your transit agency makes it
hard to make connections, they don’t really have a network. They just
have a bunch of lines.

Of
course, in the case of my trip yesterday, different agencies run the
different lines I used. But that shouldn’t be an excuse in an area
where the geographic and economic links are so close. It’s a great
thing that you can use a NYC Metrocard on the PATH train. But even
better coordination between agencies is needed. In places where new
systems are being built, this kind of connectivity should be a priority.

Human
Transit’s observations apply as well to other issues people have been
talking about on the Streetsblog Network recently, including the need to fund both intercity and intracity rail and the importance of putting high-speed rail stations in the right locations.

More from the network: The New American Village writes about the American bicycling wilderness (and no, he’s not talking about mountain biking). Kaid Bensfield on NRDC Switchboard has a post about a really cool driveway conversion in Toronto. And CommuteOrlando Blog has an update on anti-texting-while-driving legislation.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

SPUR Talk: High-Speed Rail on its Way to Northern California

|
High-Speed Rail construction is well underway in the Central Valley, said Ben Tripousis, Northern California Regional Director for the California High Speed Rail Authority, during a forum at the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association’s (SPUR) Mission Street center. “The High-Speed Rail question has shifted from ‘if’ to ‘when,'” he told the packed house at today’s […]

The Bay Area Should be Hyper Skeptical about Hyperloop

|
Hyperloop, Elon Musk’s pitch for a transportation technology that he says will whisk people from somewhere north of Los Angeles to the East Bay in 35 minutes, was in the news again thanks to a two-day conference held at Texas A&M University. Engineering students from around the world displayed designs for a Hyperloop vehicle. So […]

Caltrain Wants Level Boarding — These Are the Hurdles That Remain

|
As Caltrain celebrates 150 years of continuous passenger rail service between San Francisco and San Jose this year, transit planners are finally preparing to modernize the service by converting from diesel to electric trains. This transition, which Caltrain aims to complete by 2019, will reduce travel times for passengers because electric trains can accelerate and […]