Market Street Pilot is an Encouraging Move by Mayor Newsom

Though much of the media reaction to Mayor Gavin Newsom’s Better Market Street Project is narrowly focusing on the traffic impacts of mandatory right-turns at two intersections on Market, the trial project will attempt to do much more to improve the public realm and public perception of San Francisco’s most iconic street.

"The new and improved Market Street will rival main streets around the world," said Mayor Newsom. "With input from the community, and the leadership of the five key agencies, we will identify specific solutions that work best for our main corridor."

The traffic changes at 8th Street and 6th Street are intended to reduce conflicts between cars, transit, bicycles and pedestrians, and the success of the restrictions will be measured by a stakeholder group that includes the MTA, the San Francisco County Transportation Authority (TA), DPW, the Planning Department, advocates like the SFBC and Walk SF, and business groups like the the Market Street Association, Building Owners and Managers Association (BOMA) and the Union Square BID. By bringing all the groups together, the Mayor’s office hoped to avoid the pitfalls from previous splintered efforts to improve Market Street.

Kit Hodge, Director of the Great Streets Project for the SFBC, said that some of the more reticent stakeholders concerned about the traffic changes got on board with the project when the Mayor’s office broadened the scope to include quality-of-life issues.

"What galvanized the stakeholders is the trial approach and the
placemaking approach, which reflects multiple looks on Market Street,
not just transportation, but seeing the street as a place," she said. "There are a number of other things happening beyond traffic changes, including ad hoc plazas on the sidewalks, art in buildings, music along the street."

Hodge said the Great Streets Project would continue collecting baseline data through next week and then would help the agencies with public feedback.  She encouraged all interested public to use the many options for communicating with project organizers, including the website, 311, Twitter, and Facebook.

Astrid Haryati, the Mayor’s Director of Greening, will oversee temporary greening measures along Market in the pilot area, what are being dubbed Greenpods, and will help to expand the lunchtime concert series People in Plazas that coincided with the opening of the Pavement to Parks plazas.

San Francisco County Transportation Authority (TA) Senior Transportation Planner Zabe Bent said the holistic approach improving the street was important for garnering support from business groups and advocates. She said that with their involvement, the planners and transit operators could consider bold long-term improvements, such as Calm the Safety Zones, which would add high-visibility markings to the street and clearer demarcations between transit, pedestrians, cyclists, and vehicles.

"The goal is to make sure that [we find] ways to
improve safety for bicyclists and pedestrians."

market_street_simulation.jpgThough a Calm the Safety Zone could take many forms, this TA image is an example rendering.

Bent said the MTA already has its half of the necessary funding from Safe Routes to Transit grants for Calm the Safety Zones and that with Board of Supervisor approval, the TA could release Proposition K money for the remainder. She hoped that the MTA could start laying down the treatments as early as November, but definitely by spring.

As part of the recent Strategic Analysis Report (SAR) completed for the Board of Supervisors, Bent explained, they have a placeholder in effect for additional pilots, which she said could mean "refining the existing pilot locations – or identifying additional improvements elsewhere."

She listed the intersections of 4th St, Sansome, and Battery as locations where stakeholders were concerned about conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians.

A further consideration for the TA and the MTA is the impact the restrictions will have on parallel streets in SOMA, such as traffic calming on Howard and Folsom to protect pedestrians there, depending on what comes of the evaluation process.

Though Bent said there is no guarantee that they would ban cars on Market Street, she said the TA had studied the scenario and could consider fundamental questions of how the street is used if there was a demand for it. She also said the trial was an important first step before the scheduled repaving of
Market Street in 2013, when agencies will need to have any significant engineering changes prepared.

"The TEP has identified Market Street as one of the main priorities for improvement.  As TEP implementation moves forward, we could dedicate Prop K funds to restricting autos altogether, changing how automobiles use the lanes," she said.

Whether or not the approach will fundamentally change Market Street and make it into a grand promenade (as the Mayor hopes) could depend on a number of issues bigger than street changes, according to Bent. "Long-term land use and social services are not going to change in the next six months. Those are things that need a deeper look among the stakeholders."

MTA spokesperson Judson True pointed to the broader issues on Market Street as well, saying the MTA will analyze the impacts of the restrictions on Muni and will use this as an appropriate time to consider the long-term goals for how the street is engineered and how it functions.

"We’re really excited to be participating in this effort. The time is right to re-imagine Market Street in its entirety."

  • Richard Mlynarik

    A positive development somewhere in the San Francisco Bay Area?
    It can’t possibly last!
    Think of the children/merchants/disabled/Chinatown/Golden Gate Restaurant Association/Rob Anderson/tourists!

    PS NO RIGHT TURN from Third ONTO Market!

  • That has to be one of the more annoying right turns around. I’ll probably have to deal with it tonight on the 30/45 heading back to North Beach. Cars are always cutting off the bus and end up waiting the whole light for the pedestrians to clear the intersection.

  • Nick

    How about a series of mixed-use high rises along mid-Market? If done right, it would turn the area around while helping the local economy.

    -2 levels of retail
    -10 levels of housing
    -10 levels of office space

  • 2013 before they repave?!!!! There will be no road left by that time! The potholes grow on a daily basis and some of the manhole covers are actually sinking into the street. I am happy to see the City finally looking at something creative and constructive about finally tackling Market street, but letting the street crumble further…. it makes me think that the future vision that SF holds for its self is to be Roman era- crumbling and picturesque but completely unusable. Next thing you know, Market street will be like the Leaning Tower of Pisa- held up with ropes and winches and a prayer.

  • “Kit Hodge, Director of the Great Streets Project for the SFBC, said that some of the more reticent stakeholders concerned about the traffic changes got on board with the project when the Mayor’s office broadened the scope to include quality-of-life issues.”

    Uh-oh. I’m all for the proposed changes, but Newsom’s been around long enough for us to know that “quality-of-life issues” means let’s sweep the human trash out of sight of the tourists, office workers, and easily offended people who matter. The vilification of poor people in San Francisco has been a major obstacle to the kind of social gathering spaces advocated by Jan Gehl and the Penalosa brothers. The first concern when such spaces are proposed is, How do we keep certain people out?

    I’m not suggesting that the Great Streets or TA folks share this sentiment, but it has been a theme of Newsom’s political career. We need to watch these developments very closely, lest valid streetscape improvements be used as an excuse to crack down on unsightly residents who don’t fit in with the new image.

  • It’s nice they’re trying out a test project, rather than have it be picked to death by the “what ifs” and “this is gonnas” and other ways we talk stuff down. If it seems to work, great and if not then we move on and do something else. What a noble concept!

  • CBrinkman

    Happy and hopeful that will make Market St better for cyclists, peds, transit riders, and merchants. I am getting so tired of being bullied by car drivers on Market St.

  • ZA

    Suggestion: shop for the 6 weeks of the pilot test in that area of Market St, and make sure you tell the merchants you are there to support these improvements to Market.

    You’ve got the following breakfast/lunch selections for you and your coworkers:
    – At least 3 donut place
    – At least 2 taquerias
    – At least 2 pizza joints
    – At least 3 sandwich shops
    – At least 1 juice place
    – At least 2 burger places
    – At least 2 Chinese food sites
    – At least 1 Brazilian meat place

    (burn the grease on a ride later)

    …and a handful of clothing stores. (too bad those pool halls are gone, I think)

    And that’s only along Market Street itself, when there isn’t the Farmers Market.

    If only 1% of bicycling commuters on Market St stopped over for a doughnut or a banana, it’ll make a good impression, and its something almost all of us can afford.

  • CSB

    To fully realize and test the positive impacts of a car-free Market Street, they are going to have to shut down more than just 2 blocks. It would be great if politicians in our city [and entire country for that matter] would stop going 30% “just to see”, you’ve really got to COMMIT to the execution of a plan.

  • Karoline

    Thanks for doing this, Gavin! I’m excited to see what happens.

  • SFnative74

    I happen to read this now in 2014 while looking for another story – nice premonition of what would be happening now!


Mayor Newsom Unveils SF’s First Pavement to Parks Plaza

Supervisor Dufty and Mayor Newsom at the 17th St. plaza dedication cerimony, via Jamison on Flickr Standing before a crowd of more than 100 people, many of them city staff who had worked to realize the transformation of an underutilized street into a "Pavement to Parks" pedestrian refuge, Mayor Gavin Newsom dedicated the first of […]

Mayor Newsom, Caltrans Announce Plans to Remove Portions of I-280

A controlled explosion from the filming of the TV series "Trauma," on a closed portion of I-280 Mayor Gavin Newsom yesterday announced one of his most ambitious plans for re-shaping San Francisco, telling reporters at a press conference with Caltrans Director Will Kemption and Caltrain Director Michael Scanlan that the city would move forward with […]

Better Market Street Project Announces Citizen Advisory Committee

Mayor Newsom and Blick’s Edward Ogorzaly. Photo: Mayor’s Press Office. On the same day San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom announced yet another intervention along central Market Street aimed at rejuvenating the beleaguered section between 5th and Van Ness, the Department of Public Works (DPW) announced it was convening a citizens advisory committee (CAC) to help […]

The Clamor for a Better Market Street Grows Louder

A rendering of the 1900 unit Trinity Plaza development at Market and 8th Street As we reported last week, several city agencies have begun to look at ways to improve Market Street when it is repaved, including an inter-agency process spearheaded by DPW and the Planning Department.  Yet, we’ve still heard nothing from Mayor Gavin […]