Savings from Muni Service Changes May Not Prevent Additional Cuts

2618718909_fb26e6a846.jpgThe 38-Geary Ocean Beach branch will be eliminated in December, but the 38L-Geary Limited will get increased service. Flickr photo: juicyrai

In light of news that the Mayor opposes extended parking meter hours and that taxi medallions may bring in $12 million less than anticipated, the MTA’s mid-year budget could be in trouble, threatening to bring deeper Muni service cuts than the ones on the way later this fall.

Adding to the uncertainty, it’s not clear that the first round of service cuts will result in the savings originally envisioned.

The Muni cuts approved by the MTA board in April will not be nearly as painful as they first appeared, when a five percent reduction in service hours was proposed to help cover the agency’s $129 million budget gap. Thanks to a compromise reached with the Board of Supervisors, the $13.4 million in service cuts will be partially offset by $8.7 million in added service, including greater frequency and extended hours on some lines. The result left net service reduction far less than five percent, and net savings closer to $4.7 million.

Over the past five months, MTA staff has worked to finalize the package of service changes, which are scheduled to go into effect December 5. Julie Kirschbaum, who coordinates the MTA’s Transit Effectiveness Program (TEP), said the overall service reduction will be much lower than five percent.

"There will be a much lower percentage of overall service reductions," said Kirschbaum. "We’re also working very hard to try to get efficiencies out of the schedules that don’t come from service hours, that come from, for example, cutting the schedules more efficiently, having less operator downtime."

At a SPUR Transportation Committee meeting today, Kirschbaum also noted that though the "TEP itself was never envisioned as reducing service," it "very much informed our budget," allowing the MTA to make more precise and rational choices about where to make cuts.

For now, the precise amount of savings from the service changes hasn’t been nailed down, but MTA spokesperson Judson True said the agency is still aiming for savings in the $5 million range approved in May. If the changes don’t yield as much savings as anticipated, the MTA’s mid-year budget crisis could become even more intense.

Asked whether further service cuts would be on the table, as The Snitch at SF Weekly suggested today, True said that isn’t the case, yet. "I am not aware of any plans right now to even consider service cuts," said True.

Faced with a mid-year budget gap well in excess of $10 million, however, the MTA may be forced to make new plans. Along with parking meter enforcement and taxi medallion revenue, add the exact savings from the December Muni service changes to the list of factors to watch closely.


MTA Budget Shortfall Could Seriously Impact Muni Service

The previous budget crisis, in May, brought Muni fare hikes and service cuts. Flickr photo: Steve Rhodes With memories of last spring’s budget battle still fresh in mind, the MTA announced in a mid-year budget presentation [PDF] today that it now faces a $45.1 million deficit and plans to cut 250 positions across the agency […]

MTA Board Braces for Budget to Get Worse

The 44-O’Shaughnessy actually got increased service in December 2009, but future service cuts could leave passengers waiting longer. Photo: Michael Rhodes In case it wasn’t clear before, this week’s MTA Board meeting eliminated any doubt that solving the agency’s $45.1 million mid-year budget deficit – not to mention future budget deficits – won’t be pretty. […]

Mayor Newsom Weighs in on SFMTA Budget in Weekly Address

If you’re wondering why Mayor Gavin Newsom supports a San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency two-year budget that continues major Muni service reductions, you just might find your answer in the Mayor’s weekly YouTube update. In a thirteen-minute discussion of the SFMTA budget, the Mayor admits he’s not proud of the budget, but defends it as […]

Muni Weighs How to Restore Service If It Gets the Chance

Photo: Myleen Hollero/Orange Photography If Muni operators approve a concessions agreement their union leaders brokered with the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency last week, the agency and the riding public could be faced with an unusual task. Instead of public hearings to determine what Muni service will be cut, the SFMTA could be holding hearings […]