Muni Operator Wage Measure Now Official


A ballot measure that would change the way Muni operator wages and benefits are set now has an official name and summary from the City Attorney’s Office.

The measure [PDF], titled "Setting Transit Operator Wages Through Collective Bargaining," would do just that: instead of the current City Charter provision requiring the MTA to set operator wages at the average rate of the two highest paying transit agencies in the country, salaries would be set entirely through collective bargaining.

Supervisor Sean Elsbernd and the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR) drafted the measure and must collect 70,000 signatures by July 6 to get it on the November ballot. They can begin gathering those signatures as soon as they publish the title and summary of the measure in a major newspaper.

"We are getting ready to take the next step in a major effort to improve the management of Muni, by asking voters to place a reform measure on the November ballot," said SPUR Executive Director Gabriel Metcalf. "Our goal is to be on the street collecting signatures by April 1."

The measure’s supporters argue it would not only lead to more manageable operator costs, but would also give the MTA leverage to negotiate work rules that could curb widespread absenteeism. Irwin Lum, President of Transport Workers Union Local 250-A, which represents Muni operators, has argued that the current charter provision has led to over 40 years of labor peace.

Here’s the full summary of the measure, straight from the City Attorney’s office:

  • Allow the City to set Muni operator wages and benefits through collective bargaining, and eliminate the requirement that Muni operator wages be at least as high as the average wage rate for transit operators in the two highest paying comparable transit systems.
  • Eliminate the transit operator trust fund and any City payments into it.
  • Make incentive bonuses for the MTA Director and "service critical" MTA managers and employees optional instead of required.
  • Require binding arbitration when the MTA and employee unions representing Muni operators are unable to agree in collective bargaining.
  • Set rules for arbitration proceedings regarding MTA employees. The arbitrators would consider the impact of disputed proposals on Muni fares and service and on the ability of MTA management to schedule and assign transit employees according to riders’ service needs. And employee unions representing transit employees would have to justify any proposal that would restrict the MTA’s flexibility in deciding schedules, staffing, assignments or the number of part-time time personnel.
  • Provide that past practices and "side letters" would not bind the City regarding terms of employment for MTA employees, unless the MTA Board or Director has approved them in writing and included them in the affected employees’ collective bargaining agreements.


Elsbernd: Muni Operator Salary Ballot Measure is Back On

Supervisor Sean Elsbernd. Photo courtesy the City of San Francisco. With the Muni operators union rejecting a concessions proposal last night that would have helped the MTA balance its budget deficit, Supervisor Sean Elsbernd said he now plans to bring back a ballot measure that would end the practice of setting Muni operator wages at […]

Common Ground and Key Differences in Two Muni Operator Pay Measures

SPUR Executive Director Gabriel Metcalf gathers signatures for Supervisor Sean Elsbernd’s ballot measure. Photo: Michael Rhodes Depending on how you count it, the sweeping Muni ballot measure that four members of the Board of Supervisors introduced earlier this week has at least six major components, ranging from the governance of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation […]

Commentary: Proposition G and the Vision of the City

Editor’s note: Jason Henderson, a geography professor at San Francisco State University who writes about the politics of mobility, explains why he’s voting against Proposition G on November 2. We’ve invited the Yes on G side to write an op-ed and hope to publish it soon. A lot of well-meaning people are leaning towards voting […]

Proposition G and the Fix Muni Syndrome

As the November election draws near and the bunkers are dug on either side of San Francisco’s Proposition G, the Fix Muni Now ballot measure spearheaded by Supervisor Sean Elsbernd, the rhetoric is escalating, with Mayor Gavin Newsom, the San Francisco Chronicle’s Editorial Board and Elsbernd on one side decrying Muni operators for taking raises […]

Elsbernd Muni Reform Measure Has Money and Signatures to Spare

Supervisor Elsbernd displays his abundance of signatures. Photo: Matt Baume. Supervisor Sean Elsbernd triumphantly delivered eighteen Bankers Boxes full of signatures to the Department of Elections on Thursday, signifying the successful completion of the first phase of a Muni reform campaign that many had claimed was politically impossible. Elsbernd’s drop-off date was no coincidence: on […]