Vote to Hand Latham Square Back to Cars Bodes Ill for Downtown Oakland

Latham Square as it exists today. Photo: Alec MacDonald

After a trial public plaza at Latham Square was undercut by Oakland’s Planning and Building Manager, the Oakland City Council voted last week to reinstate two-way car traffic on the small, southernmost block of Telegraph Avenue, caving to merchants and developers pushing for unfettered car access.

At their January 7 City Council meeting, Oakland council members considered different proposals for the layout of Telegraph at Broadway, a key gateway linking the bustling offices around City Center BART with the burgeoning Uptown dining and entertainment scene. Besides the critical role Latham Square Plaza will serve in the ongoing revitalization of the area, it also stands as a flashpoint in the broader movement to make Oakland more people-friendly. The council’s vote to maintain lanes for car traffic was undeniably a setback for that movement.

Last summer, the city closed off vehicular lanes along the 1500 block of Telegraph and filled the space with seating, planters, and other pedestrian amenities as part of a six-month pilot project intended to gauge the feasibility of a permanent street closure. Complaints from nearby business owners, however, prompted the city to prematurely reopen one southbound lane of Telegraph after just six weeks.

The council’s final decision last week undermined the effort to create a people-friendly space in the heart of downtown Oakland. Although the proposal that city leaders adopted will still expand the plaza’s square footage from 2,500 (before the pilot project) to 9,500, livable streets advocates feel the restoration of two-way auto traffic will undercut the appeal of the space and create a safety hazard for people who use it. Altogether, two of the three original traffic lanes will be reinstated.

Photo: Alec MacDonald

While some of the 34 people who spoke at the City Council meeting pushed for a totally car-free option (11,000 square feet of pedestrian space), many others were willing to meet halfway and endorse a design that would retain one southbound lane of Telegraph for traffic.

Jonathan Bair, board president of Walk Oakland Bike Oakland, told council members that his organization preferred a total pedestrianization, but in the spirit of compromise encouraged officials opt for the design with one traffic lane. He spoke against the two-way traffic proposal, asserting, “Faster and more cars and big rigs running alongside what amounts to a large median is not a good use of our scarce public resources.” Several subsequent speakers echoed WOBO’s position, and though Council Member Dan Kalb later submitted the one-lane idea within an alternate proposal, the council quickly voted it down.

Most of the 11 people who testified in favor of the two-way traffic proposal cited car access to retail as their primary concern. These speakers — business owners along Telegraph and residents of the Cathedral Building that borders the plaza on the north — claimed the plaza trial had resulted in a drop in business, and argued that disrupting vehicle flow would discourage people from visiting downtown.

“Ever since the pilot project was started,” said Travis Kuhl, “my business has fell off immensely. I think today three people walked in my door.” The proprietor of Kuhl Frames + Art added that two shoe stores on the next block north had just gone out of business, “so obviously this project didn’t work.”

Photo: Alec MacDonald

One large and especially well-heeled entity managed to cast a shadow over the proceedings in absentia.

A developer — identified by the Oakland Tribune as Strategic Urban Development Alliance — is looking to purchase the underutilized Sears building cradled by Telegraph, 20th Street, and Broadway, with the intent to turn it into a retail and office center. Lynette Gibson McElhaney, who represents the downtown area as council member for District 3, called the prospect a “game-changer” and mentioned she had received comments from the developer indicating “the desire there to see two-way traffic.”

After several speakers expressed frustration that this information held too much sway over the council’s deliberations — and after McElhaney had formally moved for the council to adopt the two-way proposal — she clarified the developer’s position. “It is not that the developer has said they would not bring the investment, but the question is, whether or not they can continue to pull together the economic investment from the investment community that they need, and they have suggested that this, having one-way traffic, would be a deterrent to the capital drive that is underway,” she said.

In the end, these vague financial concerns about car access appeared to dictate the council’s decision, demonstrating how skittish Oakland has felt over the rapid and surprising resurgence of its downtown, which just five years ago felt more like a ghost town in certain pockets. As city leaders attempt to keep the turnaround going, residents will want to monitor the process, urging officials to embrace innovative and inclusive planning. Clinging timidly to the cars-first status quo is a bad strategy to keep the momentum going.

The next opportunity to discuss Latham Square Plaza will be on Thursday, January 30 from 6 to 8 p.m. in the office of AIA East Bay at 1405 Clay Street, where city staff will host a public meeting to solicit input about lighting, landscaping, furniture, fixtures, seating, paving treatments, and more.

  • dkzody

    Sounds very much like what we are seeing in Fresno. The mayor says the business owners want Fulton Mall reopened to cars. Sigh.

  • withak30

    So local business owners just get to walk in and say that this change in traffic has ruined their business and the city jumps to do their bidding? No one asks to see the data?

  • Don’t Ever Change Ever

    This Latham Square issue is a farcical distraction. You know what would be more helpful for pedestrians? Convert all the demand-actuated walk signals in Oakland to signals that don’t require people to press a button just to get a walk signal.

  • Jeffrey Baker

    Fat chance on that one. All the new signals around the lake are beg buttons.

  • Jame

    A six week pilot with limited outreach to area residents and workers doesn’t constitute complete data by any means.

    I didn’t realize that one of the shoe stores closed, but I did go to both. They were the types of boutique-y shoe stores with high end shoes, that really need to be along a corridor with a lot more retail and 7 day a week activity. It isn’t an ideal block for either store with the current mix. They’d be better served on Grand by Farley’s I think. This is a harder type of business to incubate as one of the only apparel retailers on the block. Your business plan needs a big online component.

    City leaders have a small obligation to residents, to keep their word, and the city failed. If you outline a process you need to follow it, and that did not happen here. It is hard to make meaningful changes if you don’t give them a chance to happen.

  • Jeffrey Baker

    I would add that the city doesn’t really have an obligation to incumbent retailers to perpetuate the conditions that made their shops possible. The city _does_ have an obligation to maximize the potential of retail corridors present and future. This will always cause some failure of existing businesses, which is too bad for those people individually but good for the city generally.


Latham Square's moveable street furniture

Oakland’s Latham Square: Plaza to the People

Just two weeks after Oakland’s Latham Square opened on August 16, office workers could be seen arriving in ones and twos at lunchtime. A clutch of high schoolers from the nearby Oakland School For the Arts zoomed in on skateboards and sat together on a big bench in the shade, looking cool and disaffected. The park, which made […]

Oakland Latham Square Plaza Grand Opening

From EBBC: Latham Square Plaza is a ‘Pilot Project’ and it open August 16, 12:00noon. Join us! Oakland is revitalizing the intersection of Broadway and Telegraph as a place for people, by redesigning the 1st block of Telegraph as a pocket park, with the road closed to cars and open to people. Between 16th St and […]

This Week: Addressing Anti-Ped/Bike Bias at the SFPD

This week, the SF Bicycle Coalition will hold an advocacy strategy meeting on the push for better SFPD crash investigations. The Planning Department hosts an open house on its Living Alley Project in Hayes Valley, the Department of Public Works hosts another open house on the Potrero Avenue redesign, and the SFMTA Board of Directors […]

Oakland Proposes Parking-Protected Bike Lanes on Telegraph Avenue

The City of Oakland has released preliminary design options [PDF] for a redesign of Telegraph Avenue, which include parking-protected bike lanes, improvements to speed up AC Transit lines, and pedestrian safety upgrades. Planners will hold open house meetings to collect input on the design options starting next week. “We’re very excited they’ve released a lot […]