Today’s Headlines

  • BOS Prez David Chiu Lines Up Votes to Reject Muni Budget (SF Gate, SF Examiner, SFBG)
  • Snapping Photos on Muni Property Can Get You in Trouble (What I’m Seeing)
  • Do Tourists Ride Replacement Buses When Cable Cars Are Broken? (SF Weekly)
  • More on BART’s Plans to Upgrade Trains (ABC7)
  • BART Says Test Run of Program to Pay Fares With Cell Phones a Success (KCBS)
  • James Oberstar Gives Preview of House Transpo Bill (Reuters via Infrastructurist)
  • Brookings: Fund Transpo With VMT Tax + Congestion Pricing (Bellows via Streetsblog.net)
  • Berkeley City Council Passes Climate Action Plan on Unanimous Vote (SF Gate)
  • Palo Alto Neighborhood Backs City’s First Residential Parking Permit Program (Merc
  • East Palo Alto to Restripe Crosswalks Where Girl Was Killed (Merc)
  • Portland Mayor Says He’ll Try Living Car-Free (Oregon Live via The Overhead Wire)
  • At first I was annoyed by the idea of a VMT (vehicle mileage tax) since gas taxes are so much simpler to collect and do the best job of discouraging carbon emissions. But the idea won’t die because of the sense of injustice that hybrids and electric cars (all six of them on the road right now) don’t seem to be paying their fare share to support the roads.

    After some reflection, I think a VMT would be okay as long as it’s prorated based on the weight of the vehicle. After all, it’s the weight of the vehicle that causes the wear and tear on the roads, so it’s ridiculous a Smart Car (1609 lbs) should have to pay the same amount of road repair tax as a Humvee (5200lbs). With a weight-based prorate,a Prius (2932 lbs) would pay 54% of the tax that a Range Rover would pay (5465 lbs).

    Even though if we were remotely concerned about climate change and the possible collapse of our very civilization we would place a serious carbon tax on all fossil fuel, at least a weight-based VMT would discourage gas-guzzlers (since they tend to be heavier) as well as encourage people to turn to transportation options other than private vehicles altogether. If the VMT goes forward, we must hold politicians feet to the fire and require it be prorated by weight. It’s only fair.

  • Road damage is, I believe, proportional to the fourth power of gross vehicle weight, so that Hummer would be paying twelve times more than the Prius in your example.

    See “The AASHO Road Test”, 1962

  • just got a response from Muni. you can read it here: http://bit.ly/lSIDg

    thanks, all, for your comments and support. happy shooting!!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Today’s Headlines

|
Supes Committee Delays Decision on Proposed Sit/Lie Ordinance (BCN via CBS5, KCBS) Treasure Island Development Plan Approved by Supes Committee (SF Examiner) More on the Mayor’s "Lesson in ‘Muni Math’" (City Insider) Sonoma Transpo Authority Backs Vehicle Registration Fee Increase (Press Democrat) Merc Op-Ed: "Palo Alto Could Do a Better Job Getting People Out of […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Woman Killed by Driver on Fell Street was a Recent SF State Graduate (SF Examiner)  14-month-old Girl Killed After Being Run Over by a Family Member in a Car in East Palo Alto (Merc) Driver Fatally Struck by Caltrain While "Trapped" on the Tracks (ABC 7, Merc) Santa Rosa City Council Raises Parking Ticket Fines […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Chronicle Editorial Says SPUR Alternative Budget Has "Plenty to Hate," But Better Than Cuts Will the MTA Board Consider SPUR Alternative Budget Proposals? (NBC) (SF Weekly) Muni Could Extend Fiscal Emergency Designation at Meeting Today (KCBS) (SF Gate) A Closer Look at the Growing Chorus of San Franciscans Upset With Muni (SFBG) "March Against Muni" […]

Today’s Headlines

|
SF Supes Propose Ballot Measure to Reform Muni (SF Appeal, BCN via CBS5, SF Examiner) More on Why Yesterday’s SFMTA Board Meeting Was Canceled from City Insider, SF Appeal Chronicle Editorial: "Muni Riders Feel Pain of Recession," Operators No  SF Supes Approve Treasure Island Purchase (SF Examiner) Caltrain Hopes for High-Speed Rail Stimulus Money (Palo […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Fear of BART Strike Prompted Many to Consider Telecommuting (SF Gate) Nevius Weighs in on Mason Street Closure in North Beach (SF Gate) Routsey App Back at Apple Store, Muni Re-Asserts Claim to Own Real-Time Data (SF Appeal) Multiple Cars Set Ablaze Last Night in SF and Oakland (SF Gate) (SF Gate) Lombard Street Turned […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Pedestrian Struck, Critically Injured by Driver in Golden Gate Park (BCN via SF Appeal) 8 Washington Faces Board Re-Vote, November Referendum (SF Examiner) More on Muni’s E-Embarcadero Line Trial Run (Transbay Blog) Fremont St. Closed Through Long Weekend for Transbay Terminal Construction (ABC 7) Allstate Insurance Ranks SF 10th Worst Drivers Out of 200 US […]