Media Too Often Blame the Victim in Pedestrian Crashes

Geary_crosswalk.jpgAt-grade pedestrian crossing on Geary Blvd

The SF Examiner published an excellent editorial from Walk San Francisco Director Manish Champsee today that calls on the city and the media to improve conditions for pedestrians and not immediately blame the victim in crashes.  When a vehicle killed 87-year-old Victor Cinti in mid-December, the Examiner ran a front-page headline "Jaywalker Killed."  Sells papers, sure, but the headline and the article missed the details of the story and found culpability where they shouldn’t, argues Champsee.

The solution to avoid this kind of tragedy at intersections with a
pedestrian bridge is not to crack down on “jaywalkers,” but rather to
allow people to cross at street level. We also need to calm the traffic
in this area and make it more inviting to people walking at street
level, rather than trying to separate people from the street.

Though papers like the Examiner aren’t likely to be sensitive to subtleties, it added insult to death by running an online poll with the article asking readers whether the police should crack down on jaywalkers. 

The jaywalker in question was an elderly man who used a walker, both of which were strewn in the middle of the street in the original grisly photo run by the paper.  No attention was paid to why Cinti would have calculated that the risk of crossing the busy street was preferable to using the pedestrian bridge over Geary Boulevard at the scene of the crash.

Cinti was killed on the west side of the street, while the bridge is
on east side. This means that in order for Cinti to have used the
bridge he would have had to cross Webster Street twice just to cross
Geary Boulevard on the bridge, in addition to climbing up to cross.
That’s a lot of extra effort for someone using a walker.

If
the intersection of Geary and Webster allowed crossing at the street
level, city standards would dictate more time to cross than what is
currently the case. They would also dictate pedestrian countdown
signals, along with pedestrian refuge islands in the medians, so
someone who couldn’t cross the entire length of the street in one light
cycle could continue at the next cycle.

Flickr photo: awcole72

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Advocates: Despite Bike-Ped Death, Cars Still Greatest Danger to Peds

|
In the midst of a wave of media attention around the recent bicycle-pedestrian death in the Castro, walking and bicycling advocates today re-affirmed the greatest dangers facing pedestrians on San Francisco’s streets: high-speed roads and dangerous driving behavior. In a KQED radio forum this morning, Walk SF Executive Director Elizabeth Stampe, SF Bicycle Coalition (SFBC) Executive Director Leah Shahum, […]

Media Coverage of Pedestrian Deaths Misses the Big Story

|
Two men were killed by drivers in San Francisco yesterday, but only one of those fatalities made national headlines. The crashes were strikingly similar: Both victims were males in their 40s who were reportedly crossing mid-block, and both drivers were apparently sober and stayed at the scene. But while the death of 45-year-old Thomas Ferguson […]

In SF, Victims of Traffic Violence Don’t Have Equal Protection

|
SF District Attorney George Gascón is set to bring felony vehicular manslaughter charges against Chris Bucchere later today for biking into 71-year-old Sutchi Hui in a crosswalk at Castro and Market Streets, killing him. Any traffic death on our streets deserves a thorough investigation with appropriate charges filed against the responsible party. But this high-profile case raises […]

Fire Chief’s Pedestrian Victim-Blaming: Wrong and Dangerous

|
There’s no telling where San Francisco Fire Chief Johanne Hayes-White got the patently false stats on pedestrian safety she cited to the SF Examiner yesterday. Hayes-White argued that the city shouldn’t build proven pedestrian safety upgrades because most people hit by drivers while walking are to blame for their own injuries. The Fire Department hasn’t […]

Mission Neighbors Upset Over Proposed Pedestrian Fence

|
A group of skaters stopped on the Potrero Avenue median half-way between 26th and Cesar Chavez Some community members in the Mission are upset that the MTA has proposed building a fence along a median on Potrero Avenue between Cesar Chavez and 25th Street to prevent jaywalking.   Owing to the success of the recently […]