Should St. Louis Make Mass Transit Free?

346519139_4af4e316de_m.jpgPhoto by klabusta via Flickr.

Like so many systems around the country, St. Louis’s Metro is facing a devastating budget crisis. And yet St. Louis Urban Workshop, one of the newer members of the Streetsblog Network, is adding its voice to a highly counterintuitive chorus of people
who are calling not for fare increases to help fund the systems — but
for eliminating the farebox altogether. Some have suggested that free
mass transit be seen as a stimulus measure. Even MarketWatch,
part of the Wall Street Journal’s digital network, has run an editorial
in favor of making mass transit free, saying, "This is not as
far-fetched as it looks."

So how would St. Louis replace the
20 percent of revenues the system gets from fares? here’s what St.
Louis Urban Workshop suggests:

The region could
charge employers (businesses, government offices, universities, co-ops,
etc.) $1 per employee every day that he or she travels to the
workplace. This works out to a one-time "wage increase" of 12.5¢ per
hour. That’s not very much. If regional employers would commit to mass
transit in the mode of Washington University and fully subsidize
employee travel we would be there.

The region could also
implement a 1% sales tax to fund mass transit. We could
redistribute spending on roads. We could also end the wasteful use of
TIF for retail development, a practice that distorts commercial
development and produces zero net gain for the St. Louis MSA (report here).
should also ensure that the system is useful and require retail
developments to make accommodations for mass transit (bus
turnaround/stop, walking connections to Metrolink, etc.) or pay a fee
to build accommodations elsewhere.

Free-transit plans have come up before in New York and other places. Is there any real prospect of their implementation? 

Elsewhere around the network, the National Journal opens a thread on what role public-private partnerships might play in the future of the American transportation system; Twin Cities Streets for People reports on a drop in crime near a new greenway in Minneapolis; and Trains for America digs into the reasons for an improvement in Amtrak’s on-time performance.


Clipper Card Upgrade Could Bring Seamless Regional Travel, Or Not

The Metropolitan Transportation Commission will soon renew its contract for Clipper, the Bay Area’s “all-in-one transit card.” Transit advocates are urging MTC to use the opportunity to create a more seamless fare system, and remove barriers that could allow Clipper payments on both the region’s transit agencies and “first-and-last-mile” trip services. Transit riders can currently […]

Should Cities Try to Keep Out Big Chains?

Chain stores. A lot of people hate them because they often muscle out local businesses that give a neighborhood character (the excellent film Twilight Becomes Night documents this painful loss in New York City). But clearly a lot of people vote with their pocketbooks by spending money in chains. And the question of the effects […]
Image: MTC website

Clipper Update and the Potential to Rationalize Fares

Yesterday evening, at the San Francisco Transit Rider’s new digs on Folsom Street in downtown, Sara Barz of the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) and Arielle Fleisher, with the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR), gave presentations about the move to replace the Clipper fare-collection system with a new generation of technology […]

How to Expand Your Transit Network Without Expanding Its Budget

Here’s what’s happening around the Streetblog Network today: Strategic Transit Network Redesign: With transit funding tight around the country, public transportation agencies have to find creative ways to stretch existing dollars. Today, Jarrett Walker at Human Transit offers a no- or low-cost way to expand coverage. “Network redesign,” or route reconfiguration, can help cities get […]

Funding Transit in St. Louis: Another Crack at a Sales Tax

Cities and counties across the country are struggling with the funding of their transit systems in these hard times. In New York City, the payroll tax solution touted in Albany last year has failed to meet projections. In Lorain County, Ohio, the rejection of a sales tax by voters resulted in crippling cutbacks to that […]