Why Buy More Trains if You Can’t Afford to Run Them?

Down in balmy South Florida, D-Day is approaching for riders of the the
popular Tri-Rail transit system. A looming $18 million shortfall has
forced the Tri-Rail board to approve a budget that slices daily service and stops all trains by 2011 — although ridership has doubled since 2005.

tri_rail.jpgTri-Rail trains like these could stop running by 2011. (Photo: National Corridors Initiative)

troubles are largely attributable to the bad economy, which has clipped
the amount that the network’s three participating counties can
contribute to the transit system by an estimated $9 million. Making
matters worse, the county aid must be matched dollar for dollar by the
state DOT, doubling the size of that gap and forcing Tri-Rail to the

As the Palm Beach Post noted
yesterday, Tri-Rail’s request that state legislators okay a $2 rental
car tax to save transit service is hardly a politically extraordinary
one. But the Post’s editorial also reveals Washington’s role in
perversely perpetuating the funding crisis.

Here’s the rub: Tri-Rail got $16 million for new trains in the recent
stimulus bill, but none of that can cover the shortfall because federal
money generally cannot be used to cover operating costs.

matters worse, the Federal Transit Administration has informed Tri-Rail
that it risks losing a crucial $256 million grant if daily service dips
below 48 trains. Meanwhile, members of Congress are requesting up to
$400 million in earmarks to extend Tri-Rail service to the northern end of Palm Beach County. What’s the use of money to lay new tracks if Tri-Rail can’t afford to run any trains?

simple fix for this conundrum would be allowing local transit agencies
to spend money from Washington on operating costs, an idea welcomed by
both Transportation Secretary LaHood and lawmakers on Capitol Hill.

the devil will be in the details, because expanding the potential uses
for federal transit aid doesn’t mean an automatic increase in the size
of that pot of federal aid — which is already illogically small.
Saving transit systems such as Tri-Rail could mean a painful trade-off
between building worthy new projects and making sure existing trains
can run on time.

  • BART has me wondering the same thing…

  • bikerider

    Go ahead and flame, but Tri-Rail has always had its share of problems. $47 million annual budget for a mere 14k trips (i.e. 7k round trips) is very poor cost/benefit, even for a sprawly location like Florida. The antiquated Amtrak-style train shown in the photo is a big part of the problem — extremely expensive to operate in terms of fuel and crew requirements, and not at all appropriate for this type of service. If they do purchase new trains, hopefully they can at least do a full fleet replacement with modern trainsets that have much lower operating costs.

  • Henry James

    Using federal money for operating costs is an incredibly bad idea. The entire transit system is capital starved — blowing the money on operating will only result in one time rescues at the cost of long term benefit. We need to be honest and look hard at transit operating costs, which, unfortunately, people on the left are terrified to do. They would find that transit workers may make about the same hourly wage as their peers in the private sector, but have far richer benefits, much more restrictive and costly work rules, and generous retirement benefits. How can any transit advocates endorse wage packages of $50 to $100 per hour for unionized transit operators when the people they carry make minimum wage? It is no wonder that we can’t get voter support for more transit taxes with these compensation packages.


Conservative Tea Party Movement Targets Florida Rail Plan

The conservative "tea party" movement, last seen complaining about the government-funded local transit system that they took during an anti-government march in Washington D.C, is veering back to form in Florida with an organized protest against the state’s proposal for broad new investments in rail transit. The "Tea Party" is now a registered political party […]

CA Awards $390 Million in Cap-and-Trade Funding for Transit Capital

This week, the California State Transportation Agency (CalSTA) announced the recipients of its Transit and Intercity Capital Program (TIRCP) grants. TIRCP distributes state cap-and-trade funding to local transit agencies for projects that will reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The TIRCP awards total $390 million statewide. The largest awards include $82M for rail improvements between San Diego and San […]

Sales Tax Hike Could Save Olympia’s Transit System

If transit supporters don’t turn out at the polls, service in Thurston County will plummet by about 25 percent compared to levels made possible by a small sales tax hike. Image: Seattle Transit Blog It may be the middle of summer, but if you’re paying attention, it’s already election season. With a string of primaries […]
An eBART trainset. Photo: BART

BART, BART, Muni for this Memorial Day Weekend Roundup

Lots of important transit milestones going into the Memorial Day weekend. Three important items are listed below: 1) Livermore Extension Rejected. The BART Board, by a 5 to 4 vote, rejected the proposed Livermore extension of the Dublin/Pleasanton line down the center of I-580. The Chronicle did some excellent coverage of the dynamics of the […]