Killing the Myth of the ‘More Shovel-Ready’ Road Stimulus

During debate over the White House’s $787 billion economic stimulus law, transit advocates watched as their projects were shortchanged and more "shovel-ready"
road projects got the lion’s share of the transport pot — about $8.4
billion, compared with $26.5 billion for highways and bridges.

Shovel_ready.jpg(Photo: DMI Blog)

transit money is getting put to use on the state level just as quickly
as highway money, according to state-level stimulus data released today by the House transportation committee.

the 50 states, 5 percent of transit stimulus money has been spent (as
opposed to allocated for for future projects), according to a
Streetsblog Capitol Hill analysis of the House data. Just 3 percent of
road stimulus money has gone out the door.

Those numbers certainly look low across the board; members of Congress fear that red tape is getting in the way, but Transportation Secretary LaHood has chalked the pace up to the traditional process of transportation bidding and contracting.

Looking at the states’ breakdown of stimulus cash associated with
projects already "out to bid," however, transit remains on par with

Sixty percent of stimulus dollars for roads have
started to move through the contracting process, according to today’s
House data, while 57 percent of transit stimulus money is already "out
to bid."

Which states are doing better at putting road and
transit money into the pipeline, and which are lagging behind? More
details follow after the jump.

Only one state has
already finished the job of putting its road and transit stimulus "out
to bid": Maine, which received $130.8 million for highways and $13.3
million for transit.

California, Illinois, and New York are
all doing well, moving more than half of their road and transit aid
into the contract bidding stage. But Massachusetts has a notably slow
spend-out rate — just $35 million of its $238.8 million transit pot is
associated with "out to bid" contracts, and less than $200 million of
its $437 million road pot is in that phase.

Some states
appear to be all but sitting on their transportation stimulus money to
keep it warm. Mississippi has bid out more than $255 million of its
$355 million in road funding, according to the House, but has not moved
at all on its $20.3 million in formula-based transit aid.

Delaware has reported no contract bidding associated with its $19
million transit pot, and Idaho has reported no action on its $30
million in transit money. Perhaps New York’s two Democratic senators
will revive their offer to take unwanted economy recovery money off of other states’ hands.


Killing the Myth of the ‘More Shovel-Ready’ Road Stimulus, Part II

It has become one of the most enduring anecdotes surrounding the Obama administration’s $787 billion economic stimulus law: Democrats’ contention that White House adviser Larry Summers sliced transit aid by more than half, to $8.4 billion, out of concerns that projects were not "shovel-ready" enough. (Photo: DMI Blog) Has Summers been vindicated by the data? […]

CBO Echoes Obama’s Candor on the Pitfalls of ‘Shovel-Readiness’

During last month’s White House jobs summit, President Obama carved out some common ground with critics of his first stimulus law’s $47 billion in infrastructure spending — which was distributed mainly by the book through state DOTs. "The term "shovel-ready," let’s be honest here, doesn’t always live up to its billing," he acknowledged. The CBO […]

The Boxer/Inhofe Amendment: Not Green Enough

A revised draft of the Boxer/Inhofe amendment just came over the transom from a source in DC close to the negotiations (PDF).  This is a draft from yesterday and negotiations are ongoing, so expect changes.  Specifically, enviros are trying to get a "green screen" put in place, so that USDOT can pick from the priority […]