A Day After Their TIGER Win, Freight Railroads Carve Out More Turf
11:21 AM PST on February 18, 2010
The freight rail industry yesterday claimed
the top three awards in the Obama administration's competition for $1.5
billion in TIGER stimulus grants, with Transportation Secretary Ray
LaHood singling out train shippers for an online shout-out:
You know, although passengers and
commuters have human faces, we need to remember that trade depends upon
the safe, smooth, and efficient delivery of goods. Our groceries depend
upon it as well. And jobs depend on it.
This DOT understands that.
But freight companies are hardly resting on their laurels today. The Association of American Railroads (AAR),
a Washington trade group that represents freight movers as well as
Amtrak, is just out with a report that carves out the industry's turf
in a big way -- including a legislative wish list.
Great Expectations, the report positions the freight industry as an
economic powerhouse well-positioned to power the nation through a
recovery from its lingering recession. Freight railroads generate $265
billion of economic activity per year while emitting 75 percent less
than similar shipments carried by truck, according to the AAR.
illustrate the financial might of the top U.S. freight companies, the
AAR produced a chart (above) that compares train shippers' annual
spending on capital infrastructure and maintenance with the highway
budgets of major states.
So with the industry riding high from its stimulus victory, much to the dismay
of its trucking competitors, what's standing in the way of a freight
renaissance? Government regulations, according to AAR chief Edward
"Select legislative and regulatory proposals are creating an air of
uncertainty at a time when there is already too much of that," Hamberger said in a statement accompanying the report. "When so
much is riding on freight rail's ability to sustain a healthy national
rail network necessary to help America through to economic recovery,
now is not the time to undermine our financial viability."
AAR report puts federal policymakers on notice on several fronts. After
praising the White House's multi-billion-dollar high-speed passenger
rail program, which is proving
a boon to freight firms that control most existing local tracks, the
AAR warns: "[T]he development of a world-class passenger rail system
must not come at the expense of our country’s existing world-class
freight rail system."
Another bogeyman for the freight
industry -- despite its efforts to play up its own environmental upside
-- is the prospect of carbon emissions caps that could negatively
impact Big Coal. The AAR report effectively lashes coal and freight's
The impact of climate change policies on the railroad industry cannotbe weighed without first examining the impact such policies would haveon America’s coal industry. Coal generates close to half of America’selectricity, and railroads haul more than 70 percent of it.
Freight companies are also lamenting the government's mandate for positive train control (PTC), a computerized safety program recommended
by Congress after a fatal commuter train crash in Los Angeles in 2008.
Citing Federal Railroad Administration data, the AAR report puts the
20-year price tag of PTC installation at up to $14 billion and adds
that "this well-intended legislation will have negative unintended
Yet the industry is not wholly
concerned with beating back federal measures that could hurt its bottom
line. The AAR report makes a concerted push for a 25 percent tax credit
that would reward any company spending money on rail infrastructure.
Matthew Lewis of the Center for Public Integrity notes that the AAR has
a lobbying team well-stocked with congressional veterans and former
advisers to both GOP and Democratic presidents. Check out this map for more details.
More from Streetsblog San Francisco
Breaking News: Oakland Promises Protected Bike Lanes on Lakeshore
City has committed to building protected bike lanes on the east side of Lake Merritt
Commentary: Let’s Talk About the Real “Fatal Flaw” on Valencia
How many people have to die before professional advocates stop endorsing the Valencia Street "experiment" on people?