Clear Enough? SFMTA Installs New Traffic Signals at Fell and Masonic

A new arm hangs a “straight” traffic signal over Fell, and an additional left-turn arrow (the right-most one) replaced a former “straight” signal. Photos: Aaron Bialick

Last December, the SF Municipal Transportation Agency installed a camera to enforce the left turn signal at Fell Street and Masonic Avenue, which prohibits drivers from turning during a bicycle and pedestrian crossing phase. But drivers upset about receiving a ticket and fine of roughly $500 for violating the light have continued to complain that the red left-turn signal isn’t visible enough. Whether or not that’s the case has been an ongoing debate that has drawn 139 comments on our story over the year.

To help make the red left-turn signal more apparent, the SFMTA installed two new traffic signals at the spot last week. A new signal showing a “straight” green arrow now hangs over the middle of Fell, attached to a new pole and signal arm. A new left-turn arrow was also installed on the left corner of the intersection, replacing a former “straight” traffic signal.

While violations of the left-turn signal are still regular, they seem to have dropped this year. In 2011, six people were reported hit by drivers while walking and biking at the intersection. The last known crash occurred on December 20, and it’s unknown if anyone has been hit since then.

The SFMTA installed the left-turn signal along with a bicycle traffic signal in late 2008 to protect pedestrians and bicyclists crossing Masonic along the Panhandle’s heavily-used path. Previously, left-turning drivers were expected to yield to people crossing the street, but it has remained one of the city’s hot spots for injuries to vulnerable street users. Drivers violated the signal routinely, and crashes remained high, even after the SFMTA installed a shield on the bicycle signal to block it from the view of drivers who might mistake it for a turn signal.

Bicycle and pedestrian advocates have for years pushed for improvements to Fell and Masonic — both dangerous, high-speed thoroughfares for cars. Coincidentally, the redesign plan for Masonic is up for approval at the SFMTA Board of Directors meeting tomorrow. However, the plan stops short of improving the Panhandle crossing, and construction is years off (funding hasn’t been secured yet).

Do you think the new signal configuration will finally put the issue to rest? For comparison, see a photo of the old one after the break.

Here’s what the traffic signals looked like up until last week.
  • The sign means “No turning left on red arrow”. They omitted the word “left” because it’s obvious from the context, and to keep the sign from being too wordy.

  • Meredith

    As a violator of this red light, I would like to speak my case. Most if not all intersections, ( this one being the only exception I’ve come across) which allow for a left turn and is indicated by a turn signal, will have the turn signal right next to the straight forward signal, not at the far left of the intersection. Most intersections that have only a straight ahead signal want you to yield to oncoming traffic, but since this portion of Fell Street was oneway, I thought I had the right away.


Four Protected Bike Signals Coming to Polk Street By May

Today the SFMTA announced details about the first package of safety upgrades coming to Polk Street in the next few months. They include signals at four intersections that will give southbound bike traffic a separate phase from drivers turning right, making Polk the second street in SF to get the configuration. By May, the SFMTA said it would install the bike signals at […]

SFMTA Installs Red Light Camera at Fell and Masonic

Just before Christmas, the SFMTA installed a camera at the corner of Fell and Masonic on the Panhandle to help enforce the left-turn signal frequently violated by drivers. Dale Danley at the Panhandle Park Stewards blog first reported the new automated enforcement mechanism, as well as a crosswalk upgrade at the nearby Oak Street intersection. The red […]