Supervisor Wiener Wants to Remove Clutter From SF’s Narrow Sidewalks

As if San Francisco’s sidewalks weren’t narrow enough, they’re often cluttered with objects like newspaper racks, utility poles, street signs, and utility boxes.

Photo: ##

In a hearing yesterday, Supervisor Scott Wiener set out to question the necessity of such structures, calling on city staffers to answer for things like the empty newspaper racks at busy corners like 18th and Castro Streets.

“Whether or not particular street furniture has value, they can all block pedestrian access and reduce automobile and pedestrian visibility,” said Wiener. “It’s essential that we’re very thoughtful and strategic about what we place on our sidewalks and where, exactly, we place it.”

While Wiener noted that his recently-passed legislation should help streamline sidewalk expansions, he questioned the amount of space carved out from existing walkways, which often don’t meet the new sidewalk design standards set out in the city’s 2010 Better Streets Plan. “There are bus shelters where you almost have to walk single file to get past,” he said.

Walk SF Executive Director Elizabeth Stampe pointed to improvements like bike corrals, which add bike parking in the street bed, as a “great example” of how to avoid cluttering city sidewalks.

“For decades, our roads have been designed to create a clear path for vehicles by shoving people over to the edges, where they need to thread their way between poles and empty newsracks and utility boxes,” said Stampe. “We need to widen the space for people to enjoy on foot. We also need to think creatively about how we can start using some of these elements to calm traffic and make the street safer.”

When it comes to removing or reducing the size of amenities like Muni shelters, newspaper racks, and traffic control boxes, city staffers said their hands are often tied by bureaucratic requirements and contracts. SFMTA staff said Muni shelters, an important amenity for riders, can’t be manufactured at a smaller width.

John Kwong, manager of the Department of Public Works Bureau of Street Use and Mapping, said the reason empty newspaper racks are an increasingly common sight is because digital media has reduced demand for print media at a faster rate than the city is allowed to remove racks. Under the city’s 2002 contract with Clear Channel, which owns the racks, only two percent of them — which currently amounts to about six racks citywide — can be removed each year, according to Kwong. The contract expires in 2022.

Supervisors Wiener and David Chiu also questioned the SFMTA’s efforts to provide standalone restrooms for Muni operators at a cost of $170,000 apiece, as the SF Examiner reported today. Chiu urged the SFMTA to seek out agreements with businesses near the terminals of Muni lines to allow operators to use their restrooms, for which the agency typically pays a business $4,000 to $5,000 per year. SFMTA staff argued that many route terminals aren’t near businesses, or aren’t open at all the times that Muni operators need them.

  • Michael Petrelis

    I’m happy to see the BOS picking up on the problem of street furniture clutter that has been a concern of mine for years. This link will take you to links of my blog posts about removing or consolidating news racks:

  • Anonymous

    He’ll be changing his tune after he loses his seat on the BoS and is reduced to selling food from a sidewalk cart — titled, appropriately, SUPER WIENER… then he’ll wish there were bathrooms LOL!

  • Oozeironic

    How about starting with the AT&T Uverse boxes approved by the Board?

  • Thoughts

    Perhaps AT&T can fund underground cables thereby removing poles and making space for their Uverse boxes.

  • John Dunlap

    One thing I can’t understand is why a beautiful city like San Francisco is taking 75 years to remove utility poles and to underground these lines! So much for this can do city.

  • Anonymous

    Our city has some unique features, including a certain amount of bedrock. I’ve always assumed it was just not practical to bury power lines in SF. But I’ve never researched it.

  • Anonymous

    Our geology is nothing compared to Norway. They undrgrounded everything, requiring utility poles to be undergrounded whenever pipelines were upgraded, or requiring the telecoms to underground when installing upgrades. Proposed this to Supes 2 years ago and they laughed at the idea. They would rather spend money on homeless services.

  • Anonymous

    unfortunately, Weiner is a proponent of AT&T Uverse’s Surface Mounted Facilities.

  • John Dunlap

    Most of the city is sitting on sand other than Diamond Heights and few other hilly areas.

  • John Dunlap

    Its so disappointing how people don’t care about the visual pollution caused by all the telephone poles and wires! I recall how much better Dolores Street looked once the utility lines were placed underground, but how soon we forget.


Noe Valley Gets Sidewalk Extensions and Decorative Crosswalks on 24th

City officials celebrated new brick-trimmed crosswalks and sidewalk bulb-outs on 24th Street in Noe Valley at a ribbon-cutting ceremony today. The changes will make for a more pedestrian- and transit-friendly environment on Noe Valley’s commercial corridor. At Castro and Noe Streets, the transit bulb-outs — curb extensions at bus stops — will help speed up Muni’s 24 and […]

City Moves Forward on a More Pedestrian-Friendly Castro Street

San Francisco’s world-famous commercial strip on Castro Street, which gained a popular pedestrian plaza in 2009, is poised to become a more inviting destination as the SF Planning Department develops plans to widen the sidewalks and install other improvements from 17th Street to 19th Street. The sidewalks on Castro, currently 12 feet wide, could reach widths up […]

Getting More Out of San Francisco’s Carved-up Curbs

Could cantilevered racks help San Francisco get more out of vacant curbside street space? / CC BY-SA 2.0 In a city strapped for bike parking and sidewalk space, there is an abundance of one commodity: small strips of curb that seem to be of use to no one. As the lifting of the bike […]

Castro Street Redesign Breaks Ground, Rainbow Crosswalks Unveiled

The new Castro Street is on its way, with the Department of Public Works breaking ground today on the two-block street redesign, which will include wider sidewalks. One detail of the plan was also unveiled at the event — rainbow crosswalk designs for the Castro and 18th Street intersection. “This streetscape project will be transformational […]