Coming to Caltrain: Longer Trains With More Room for Bikes

Caltrain Bombarier Bike Car With Folding Bikes
Caltrain’s Bombardier trains currently only carry 48 bikes each. With trains receiving a third bike car, 72 bikes can fit on board. Photo: John Woodell/Twitter

Caltrain will add a third bike car to all six of its Bombardier trains, Executive Director Michael Scanlon announced at the transit agency’s monthly board of directors meeting last week. With the new cars, bike capacity will increase from 48 to 72 on each of the Bombardier trains. But it could take up to one year to place the six-car trains into service.

The new bike cars are part of a larger $15 million project to acquire and refurbish 16 used rail cars from Los Angeles Metrolink, adding about 2,000 seats across Caltrain’s fleet. The agency’s 15 older gallery-style trains already carry 80 bikes each, since seats are not placed in the center of the two bike cars on those trains, and will not receive more bike capacity.

Crowding on Caltrain is becoming increasingly severe during the morning and evening rush. A record 61,670 passengers packed into the agency’s five-car trains on an average weekday in October 2014, and “standing room only” is now the norm during peak hours. With ridership growing more than 10 percent each year since 2009, the trend shows no sign of stopping. New office space and housing construction in San Francisco, along El Camino Real in San Mateo and Santa Clara counties, and within walking distance of Caltrain stations are also quickly filling up any remaining passenger capacity even on trains running outside the traditional commute times.

The number of passengers bringing bicycles on Caltrain has grown four times faster than overall ridership since 2008. Strong growth in the Bay Area’s tech and finance economies continues to bring thousands more workers every year to suburban office developments located far from any practical rail or bus services — making train-plus-bike the only feasible alternative to commuting by car.

Caltrain officials were initially leaning toward adding refurbished rail cars to the Bombardier fleet with total seating for about 650 passengers but no spaces for bikes. That would have actually cut the share of passengers who can bring a bike on board compared to the status quo, even as bike-plus-train trips continue to outpace overall Caltrain ridership growth.

Passengers crowd into San Francisco’s 4th and King Caltrain Station on a typical weekday evening. Photo: John Woodell/Twitter

“Only 20 seats must be replaced with bike racks to configure a Bombardier car as a bike car, leaving over 110 seats in the rest of the car,” wrote Shirley Johnson to The Daily Journal in December. Johnson coordinated the BIKES ONboard campaign with the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition and other bike groups to convince Caltrain officials that adding space for bikes has a number of important indirect benefits, including “reducing traffic congestion, freeing costly parking spaces, freeing seats on publicly subsidized buses and shuttles, reducing our dependence on fossil fuels, reducing air pollution and improving public health.”

When new electric trains are operating in 2021, the BIKES ONboard coalition aims for Caltrain to have enough capacity to allow 20 percent of passengers to bring bicycles on board.

Caltrain’s older and more common gallery-style trains can hold up to 80 bikes, and they regularly reach capacity during weekday rush hours. Photo: @GeraldFitt/Twitter

Caltrain finalized the purchase of 16 used rail cars for $5.6 million in early December after negotiations with the Southern California Regional Rail Authority, which operates Metrolink and has phased out its use of Bombardier rail cars. The cars Caltrain acquired are similar to the rolling stock that currently comprises five of the agency’s 20 trains.

Refurbishing the Metrolink rail cars and modifying some Caltrain platforms to accommodate the longer six-car trains will cost another $9.4 million. The improvements will be financed using a 2015 farebox revenue bond.

Caltrain hopes to modify both its Bombardier trains and gallery-style trains to run an all six-car fleet, which would alleviate some of the worst rush hour crowding, although demand for train travel isn’t expected to stop growing anytime soon.

  • Richard Mlynarik

    I think there would be a lot of opposition to just adopting it on Caltrain

    Sure there was. It came from the staff and consultants who wanted their own UNIQUE IN THE WORLD (caps just for you) signalling system for their own little toonerville trolley.

    $150 million of pure pork is a lot of incentive to commit fraud.

    And guess what? You can get away with it every time! Score! USA USA USA!

  • baklazhan

    If you’re going to claim that, at least get the numbers right. Each set of 4 bikes takes up the same space as a set of 4 seats.

  • murphstahoe

    That solution is a solution for people saying “screw this” and driving. Caltrain’s mission is – or at least should be – to maximize ridership. Caltrain has disproven your argument about scale as they have scaled from 24 per train to 72/80 per.

    Perhaps Caltrain should get rid of the seat robbing luggage racks and bathrooms? Those are nice conveniences. The bike racks drive ridership.

  • Summer Lee

    I don’t get why Caltrain even has bathrooms other than when your stuck because they struck some moron. Plus bikers should be forced to stand with their bikes since they chose to do this. No special seating just for them. Let us lazy bums have the seats.


Caltrain Will Boost Bicycle Capacity But It’s Still Not Enough

Although capacity is increasing, bicyclists will continue to get left behind at Caltrain stations. Caltrain’s Board of Directors has approved a plan to improve bicycle capacity that is a step beyond staff’s recommendations but will it be enough to keep bicycle commuters from getting bumped? No. Still, advocates were pleased with yesterday’s decision to increase […]

Caltrain to Present Plan to Increase Bicycle Capacity

Caltrain claims it "values bicycle commuters." In its goals and objectives the agency says "Caltrain must be a competitive alternative to traveling by automobile." That goal will be tested tomorrow when the agency presents its final plan to increase bicycle capacity on Caltrain to the Board of Directors. Advocates are frustrated it isn’t being made […]