Mayor Lee Vows to Veto Bike Yield Law

Updated at 6:46 p.m. with image of Mayor’s veto letter at the bottom.

Mayor Ed Lee has vowed to veto the “Bike Yield Law” put forward by six supervisors. Assuming the mayor follows through, it will take a vote from eight of the 11 supervisors to override him.

Mayor Lee and SFPD Chief Greg Suhr, seen here riding Bay Area Bike Share in 2013, have missed the point of the Bike Yield Law. Photo: Aaron Bialick

In a comment to the SF Chronicle, Lee showed that the point of the ordinance remains beyond him:

I’m not willing to trade away safety for convenience, and any new law that reaches my desk has to enhance public safety, not create potential conflicts that can harm our residents.

So the mayor’s spin is that the majority of supervisors want to “trade away safety for convenience.” How tone-deaf.

The Bike Yield Law, of course, is all about safer streets through the efficient allocation of law enforcement resources. By legitimizing the normal practice of bicyclists yielding at stop signs — even the SFPD captain who cracked down on rolling stops does it! — the ordinance would help urge police to focus enforcement on violations that actually hurt people.

Supervisor Scott Wiener explained it to the Chronicle:

When you have a cyclist that is approaching an intersection at a slow speed, cautiously and not violating anyone’s right of way, it doesn’t make sense to be ticketing them. That’s not creating any kind of danger. That’s not hurting anyone. That should not be the focus of law enforcement…

If the cyclist is blowing through the intersection and not entering slowly and cautiously, they absolutely should get a ticket. But when you look at what is causing injury and death on our streets, it’s not a cyclist entering an intersection at a few miles an hour.

So far, Lee’s legacy on safe streets and sustainable transportation is mainly one of obstruction, and this case is shaping up no differently. But if the experience with Prop B is any guide, Lee might come around to the Bike Yield Law after everyone else has already embraced it.

There’s growing recognition at City Hall that San Francisco will make streets safer by acknowledging the need to update a flawed law. As Wiener told KPIX, the Bike Yield Law is an example of how “San Francisco frequently lead[s] the way and lead the nation in terms of smart, progressive, forward-thinking policies.”

If Mayor Lee really cares about safer streets, he won’t stand in the way of an effort to bring traffic law into the 21st century.

Updated 6:46 p.m.: Supervisor John Avalos tweeted this photo of Mayor Lee’s letter explaining his opposition to the board:

Photo: John Avalos/Twitter
Photo: John Avalos/Twitter
  • longtermlowerhaighter

    Really? Really?

    I should have to just keep my mouth shut when someone is breaking the law and endangering my life for fear that I may be attacked? That is how you want me to live? Is that how YOU want to live? Also a really good example for my kid. “You know, when we see someone breaking the law we just shouldnt say anything. It might get us in trouble.” It isnt though I yelled at the guy….just calmly said that there was a stop sign there.

    This is not the way I will live.

    (Not to mention the 2 construction workers near me watching who yelled profanities at the guy nor the 27 years I have been studying 2 different martial arts. I really didnt feel unsafe at all.)

  • longtermlowerhaighter

    Definitely not the Colonel. If I was wouldnt I have made about 20 posts to this thread yesterday? I just dont have the time.

    I do miss him at times though.

  • murphstahoe

    the best sockpuppets know how to mix it up

  • longtermlowerhaighter

    Nope….not a sockpuppet =)

    Actually want to say I really appreciate you here and most places you comment. You seem to have a reasonable approach that the streets and city belong to everyone. No just cars, or bikes or pedestrians but to all residents.

    Unfortunately what I described above is far too common occurrence in my life. Todays anecdote is the most common one. Large vehicle stops for me to cross. Cyclist coming up behind rides beside car and doesnt see me because of large vehicle, then blows through crosswalk right in front of my face. At least that guy said sorry before I could say anything. Some do, most dont. That is when, in a low calm voice, I point out the stop sign. Tried playing the victim for years but most dont seem to care.

    Then for the second incident of the day I was waiting for muni and watching pedestrian crossing haight. Guy was coming down haight too fast, slammed on his brakes when the guy in the crosswalk didnt stop for him and cut right in front of him.

    As a side note I am pretty sure we met years ago on a ride/pub crawl up the peninsula.

  • murphstahoe

    “As a side note I am pretty sure we met years ago on a ride/pub crawl up the peninsula.”

    So you’re saying you bike while intoxicated…. 🙂

  • longtermlowerhaighter

    Not really 😉

    Only 2 places and then had to get back to the kid. Wife wouldnt give me a full night hall pass.

  • Jimbo

    i do bike and dont consider myself a hypocrite. my wife and i make sure to stop because we dont want to be associated with majority of cyclists who don’t and are afraid of the road rage that will come down based on the attitudes of the majority of SF cyclists

  • murphstahoe

    please post a photo of your bike.


Mayor Vetoes Bike Yield But Advocates Must Never Yield to Regressive Politics

Mayor Edwin Lee officially vetoed the “Bike Yield” ordinance yesterday. Without enough votes to override, supporting supervisors will have to figure out a compromise plan, such as a pilot project. The bill’s author, Supervisor John Avalos, already prepared for that contingency. Not surprisingly, Avalos was frustrated with the Mayor’s veto. “SFPD has focused traffic enforcement […]

“Bike Yield” Passes Without Enough Votes for Veto Override

The Bike Yield ordinance was heard by the full San Francisco Board of Supervisors yesterday. It passed, with six “ayes” and five against — two “ayes” short of what’s needed to override Mayor Edwin Lee’s veto pen. The San Francisco Examiner reports that mayoral spokesperson Christine Falvey was ready with a response. “The mayor believes this endangers pedestrians […]

Monday: Your Chance to Speak on the Bike Yield Law

On Monday at 1:30 p.m., the land use and transportation committee of the SF Board of Supervisors is going to discuss the Bike Yield Law at City Hall. This is an important opportunity to speak up for common-sense bike and traffic enforcement policies. The ordinance would instruct San Francisco police to, in practice, adopt an “Idaho Stop” […]

Bike Yield Law Passes Transportation Committee

Yesterday the Land Use & Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted to instruct SFPD to, in effect, allow cyclists in San Francisco to treat stop signs as yields. The proposal will now go before the full San Francisco Board of Supervisors on Dec. 15. Supervisors John Avalos and Scott Wiener voted “aye” on the […]