Mayor Lee Warms to Prop B Muni Funding Increase, Which He Opposed

Mayor Lee on another photo op Muni ride to yesterday’s press conference. Photo: Mayor’s Office/Twitter

Mayor Ed Lee held a press conference yesterday to mark a $48 million increase in transportation funding for Muni and safer streets. But the largest chunk of that increase, and the only one that resulted directly from political leadership, came from Supervisor Scott Wiener’s Proposition B — which Lee fervently opposed.

The funding increase “is a great thing for the eighth-largest transportation center in the country,” Lee told reporters yesterday, touting the boost it would bring to Muni vehicle maintenance and infrastructure. Lee was joined by Wiener, as well as Supervisors London Breed and Julie Christensen.

When the Board of Supervisors approved Prop B for the ballot last July, Lee threatened retribution for the six who voted for it, though he apparently never followed through.

At the time, the mayor called Wiener’s measure “disturbing” and said it “can be very damaging” to the city budget. “I have to hold the supervisors that did this accountable,” he told reporters. “Fiscally, it was not responsible to have done. It disbalances the budget, and it was not what we had all collaboratively agreed to do.”

Prop B passed with 61 percent of the vote in November, mandating an annual increase in funds for transportation and safer streets based on population growth. Since the measure also factors in the last 10 years of growth, it is expected to yield a $24.2 million increase this year.

The $48 million increase to the SFMTA’s budget also includes $7.2 million from the agency’s share of the general fund, a result of greater tax revenue from a booming economy. The other $16.7 million comes from a boost in development impact fees earmarked for street improvements, which resulted from an increase in building construction.

While that $48 million should help SF implement safer streets and better transit, the city could have raised much more had Lee been willing to ask car owners to chip in for the disproportionate costs they incur. However, the mayor passed up an estimated $77 million by repealing Sunday parking meters and abandoning his support for putting a vehicle license fee increase on the ballot.

Mayor Lee at the press conference yesterday on Jane Warner Plaza in the Castro. Photo: Mayor’s Office/Twitter

Sunday parking meters generated $11 million annually (and reduced car traffic). Restoring the local VLF rate to pre-Schwarzenegger levels, as recommended by the Mayor’s Transportation 2030 Task Force, was expected to generate more than $66 million per year.

Lee’s abandonment of the VLF measure is what spurred Wiener to propose Prop B as a stopgap measure. Prop B helps fund some needed transportation upgrades, but hands the bill to the general public, putting a disproportionate burden on those who drive the least.

Of the $48 million added to this year’s SFMTA budget, $17.7 million will buy 18 new buses, and $8 million will go toward a deposit to “secure an option” for 40 new light-rail vehicles on top of the 175 already on order, said agency spokesperson Paul Rose. An additional $5.9 million will go toward citywide bike and pedestrian safety measures and “signal improvements.” The rest, generated by development impact fees, will go towards street improvements near the development projects that contributed.

Those funds are in addition to the $66 million for transportation infrastructure coming this year from Proposition A, the $500 million general obligation bond also passed by voters in November. Mayor Lee campaigned for Prop A, but never mentioned Prop B publicly after he issued his initial condemnation.

When asked for comment on the mayor’s newfound enthusiasm for Prop B-mandated funds, Wiener told Streetsblog he’s “just happy” that Muni and street upgrades are getting some of the funding they need.

“That’s what matters, that we’re increasing investment at a very important time in our city’s history,” he said. “I’m in total alignment with the mayor. It’s not about who did what, who gets credit for what.”

  • SFnative74

    I appreciate Scott Wiener’s leadership and maturity on these issues. Thank you for having the foresight – even in the face of criticism and opposition – to plan for the tens of thousands of new residents and employees that are being added to this small city!

  • YWHYKNOT

    I’m so happy Aaron wrote about this. I saw this in the paper yesterday and thought specifically about Lee’s idle threats against Weiner we he proposed this measure which he had to do only because of Lee lack of fortitude. I say this almost everyday, “That guy is such an accidental mayor it’s crazy.” No ideas, no agenda, just kinda letting others figuring things out as he goes along. It has been good for morale at city hall I think, but it’s incredibly hard to be happy about a guy who literally doesn’t champion anything.

  • Politicians rarely stand for much of anything in the long term. And it’s political suicide to be against a voter proposition after it’s passed (see also: Jerry Brown’s flip-flop on Prop 13.)

    The real surprise is how fast our accidental mayor went from a city hall manager to operating like your average textbook politician.

  • DragonflyBeach

    Doesn’t Lee live near a BART line, in Glen Park?
    He has a real subway, he doesn’t care about Muni.

  • Filamino

    Lee is happy now because the city is flush with cash.

    When hard times come again, Weiner will be vilified for cutting other vital services due to electorate budgeting which is rarely ever a good idea.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Supes Approve Wiener’s Population-Based Transit Funding Measure for Ballot

|
The Board of Supervisors voted 6-4 today to put on November’s ballot a charter amendment that would increase the share of general funds devoted to transportation, based on population growth. Supervisor Scott Wiener introduced the measure as a backup plan to generate transportation revenue — 75 percent of which would go to Muni, 25 percent […]

Mayor, Eight Supervisors Promise to Ride Muni Every Day Until June 22

|
The SF Transit Riders Union’s challenge to ride Muni for 22 days kicked off yesterday with late sign-ons from Mayor Ed Lee and Supervisors London Breed and Mark Farrell, who had initially declined to commit. Supervisors Katy Tang and Malia Cohen still declined, and Supervisor Norman Yee has not confirmed a pledge since he tweeted a selfie on Muni after […]

Who’s Not Against Cars-First Prop L? Supes Tang, Farrell, Yee, and Mayor Lee

|
With only a few days left until the election, four elected officials have yet to take a stance on Proposition L, the Republican-crafted measure that misleadingly urges San Francisco to “restore transportation balance” by giving priority to private automobiles and free parking. Supervisors Katy Tang, Mark Farrell, Norman Yee, and Mayor Ed Lee apparently see no need to come out against […]