Bike Share Takes a Beating

Slashed Tires, Trashed, Drowned, and Stolen Bikes

A Ford GoBike dismantled and hung. Photo posted by Erika Dumaine‎  on the San Francisco Bike Ride Crew Facebook page
A Ford GoBike dismantled and hung. Photo posted by Erika Dumaine‎ on the San Francisco Bike Ride Crew Facebook page

The Bay Area’s bike share system, which expanded in San Francisco and launched less than a month ago in the East Bay, seems to be off to a rocky start, with many reports on social and traditional media of slashed tires, stolen bikes, and even one bike dumped into Lake Merritt.

It’s important to note that, as much as it’s interesting to see a picture of a stripped-down Ford GoBike hung from a tree, it doesn’t say much about whether the system is working or not–the roll out numbers are still not crunched. No matter what, a certain number of bikes were bound to get stolen and/or damaged.

“The data I have seen is … showing usage at each pod,” wrote Dave Campbell, Advocacy Director of Bike East Bay, in an email to Streetsblog. “I intend to take a closer look at this data, but it is still early.” The San Francisco Bicycle Coalition expressed similar sentiment, that it was just too early to say anything about whether the system is taking off or not.

People familiar with bike-share systems in other cities say it’s not that unusual for vandals to go after the bikes initially–after all, it’s a new target and it can even get your handiwork on TV. “… vandalism and theft of private vehicles and bikes is also a common occurrence around here, sadly, so it should also be no surprise when this extends to the bike share bikes as well,” wrote Robert Prinz, Education Director for Bike East Bay.

The bike vandalism may also be part of a general blow-back effect other cities have seen after launching bike-share systems. Remember the Wall Street Journal‘s Dorothy Rabinowitz’s comment about New York neighborhoods getting “begrimed” by bike shares? If you’re not familiar with that, and some of the other ‘bikelash’ that took place when New York launched its system, check out this hilarious video of unintentional self-parody embedded in a post by Streetsblog NYC.

Meanwhile, bike-share operators are doing their best to clean up the messes and get the bikes back into circulation. “Our team operates 24-hours a day and we are rapidly responding to any reports of vandalism, and making any necessary repairs,” said Dani Simons, a spokesperson for Motivate.

“It’s all speculation at this point, but I see everyday in Oakland, bus shelters smashed, BART cars trashed, litter all over the freeways and car windows broken into. I guess someone hates transportation in general,” wrote Campbell.

Still, the pictures of the abused bikes are oddly amusing. One has to wonder if Bluegogo, the renegade bike share company that was essentially chased out of San Francisco by regulations, is laughing at it all. In addition to the bike hung from a tree and the submarine bike in Lake Merritt, Hoodline has a shot and video of a row of Ford GoBikes with slashed tires. And, in case you think this is particular to the Bay Area’s official bike share system, Streetsblog found this Jump electric bike with both tires popped, on Valencia.

This Jump electric bike also suffered some wrath. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick

The reasons for the bike-share vandalism are unclear. Is it an anti-gentrification protest statement? Or generalized bike-lash as they saw in New York City? Or all-too-common vandalism of objects in the public realm? Or multiple reasons?

Is all this abuse beating up bike-share, making it difficult to use? Do you ride Ford GoBikes? Do you find the recent expansions useful? Tell us what you think.

  • Dr_Ace

    It does seem like this implementation of bike-share’s target audience is people commuting to work, and emphasizing last-mile service. That’s not my use-case, so I wasn’t focusing on the annual membership, but I can see how it’s much more cost-effective.

  • mx

    Yeah. GoBike’s pricing doesn’t really make much sense outside of an annual membership, I don’t think. The old $99 membership was a little easier to swallow as “pay to give me another option and I’ll use it whenever it makes sense.” At $150, it’s a little harder for me to justify that without having specific trips I’d use it for regularly.

  • Dallas

    Considering I know a bit about Bike Share program circus I’ve worked on the oldest in California for the past 7 years I guarantee you that there’s a GPS on each of the bikes

  • FlappyMcGee

    that’s exactly my use model: walk/bike partway to/from work. almost every day. Or maybe from home to any number of neighborhoods I need to visit.

  • FlappyMcGee

    dock blocked…


As Bike-Share Pilot Lurches Along, Supe Wiener Calls for Full-Scale Launch

While San Franciscans eagerly await the repeatedly-delayed launch of the Bay Area’s small-scale bike-share pilot program, which has now been downsized to a minuscule 700 bikes (350 of them in SF), Supervisor Scott Wiener says San Francisco needs to take the initiative to move ahead and launch a “full-scale system” throughout the city by next year. Wiener plans […]
Jay Walder and Darlene Gee at SPUR Oakland. Photo: Streetsblog

SPUR Talk: Bike-Share and the Transportation Revolution

Last night, the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR) and Young Professionals in Transportation hosted a talk and discussion about bike-share and the transportation changes taking place in our cities. The event, which was held at SPUR’s Oakland location, featured Jay Walder, the CEO of Motivate. One of many items that stood out: […]
Advocates and community members get an update on Bike Share at the Excelsior Library. Photo: Streetsblog

Bay Area Bike Share Outreach in the Excelsior

Last night ten people attended a Bay Area Bike Share meeting at the Excelsior Branch Library on Mission. The meeting was designed to solicit input from the public about preferred locations to place bike stations. It’s part of a ten-fold expansion of  the program, which will eventually end up with 7,000 bikes across the Bay […]