Transit Center’s Car-Free Street in Danger

Even on this tiny stretch of Natoma, right next to San Francisco's new transit center, some want it all for cars

The city wants to turn this tiny stretch of car-free Natoma into a ramp for a parking garage. Photos: Streetsblog/Rudick
The city wants to turn this tiny stretch of car-free Natoma into a ramp for a parking garage. Photos: Streetsblog/Rudick

The San Francisco Planning Commission approved a development yesterday afternoon for Parcel F of the Transbay Transit Center Area, between Howard and Natoma. The 800-foot tower will include hotel rooms, housing, office space, and bike parking.

Bringing more high-density development to the area around the Salesforce Transbay Terminal, home to AC Transit and other bus services and the future home of Caltrain and High-speed Rail is great–density should be maximized around a huge transit hub. But Livable City’s Tom Radulovich is leading the charge to correct a major defect: the new building will also include lots of car parking. And providing access to that parking, at least according to current plans, means destroying one of the few car-free spaces in the city.

From an email Radulovich sent to Streetsblog:

The block of Natoma between First and Second is currently car-free for most of its length. The development … proposes extending a roadway through the car-free space to serve a large new parking garage. The project also proposes slicing a truck loading entry through the Howard Street bicycle lane.

It would be a shame to lose an entire car-free block to another auto-oriented development. The transit center is planned to be region’s most important transit hub, and we should follow in the footsteps of progressive cities by preserving and expanding car-free, people-oriented public spaces around our central transit station. The Transbay streets are dominated by traffic, garage entrances, and loading docks, and this one block of Natoma is our last best chance to preserve a significant car-free space.

The plan still has to go before the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. Radulovich is asking people to contact the office of Supervisor Matt Haney, who is normally a champion of protected bike lanes and car-free space.

“Supervisor Haney is the legislative sponsor; his staff seemed genuinely surprised that the project proposes eliminating one of the longest stretches of car-free street in SoMa,” added Radulovich. He had this to say to Haney: “It would be a sad and bitter irony if the longest car-free street in District 6 was destroyed by legislation you sponsor.”

These bollards give emergency vehicles (and food trucks) access to this otherwise car-free space
These bollards give emergency vehicles (and food trucks) access to this otherwise car-free space. Parcel F is on the right of this photo.

For more on this, see Radulovich’s post on the Livable City page. To contact Haney’s staff, email them matt.haney@sfgov.org or call 415 554-7970.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Transbay Transit Center to Fill Downtown With People, Not Cars

|
The new Transbay Transit Center is expected to transform San Francisco’s downtown core by focusing new development around a massive regional transit hub in eastern SoMa. Scheduled to open in 2017, it will link 11 transit systems and eventually CA High-Speed Rail. Some have called it the “Grand Central of the West.” The SF Planning Commission last week approved […]

SFCTA to Test Variable Road Pricing on Treasure Island

|
Treasure Island will serve as San Francisco’s proving grounds for road pricing that adjusts in response to traffic conditions, as the city looks to minimize Bay Bridge car congestion generated by residents expected to move to the development site. When the first housing units on the artificial mid-bay island, formerly owned by the Navy, are occupied in 2019, the SF County Transportation […]

Will Caltrans Get On Board With a Contraflow Bus Lane on the Bay Bridge?

|
The proposal to improve transbay transit with a contraflow bus lane on the Bay Bridge is gaining traction, as the SF Chronicle reported yesterday. The idea has been pushed by proponents at SPUR, AC Transit, and some BART board members for years as a relatively quick and inexpensive solution to move more people between SF and the East Bay. BART is already […]

TSP Rebooted: Bureaucratic Revamp Could Boost Transit and Livable Streets

|
San Francisco agencies have re-introduced the Transportation Sustainability Program, a bureaucratic overhaul that could dramatically expedite improvements for walking, biking, and transit, while discouraging car parking in new developments. In developing the program, SF planners are also nearing completion of the nation’s first major study showing that dedicated car parking encourages driving. The TSP is three-pronged: It would overhaul SF’s development fee […]