Zero Progress on Vision Zero

New Year's Eve crash in SoMa that took two lives highlights San Francisco's inability to stem traffic violence

Hanako Abe, one of the victims in a Dec. 31 crash that took two lives. Photo from her gofundme page
Hanako Abe, one of the victims in a Dec. 31 crash that took two lives. Photo from her gofundme page

“Twenty-nine people were killed in traffic crashes in 2020, the exact number killed in 2019,” wrote Jodie Medeiros, executive director of Walk San Francisco, in a statement about the New Year’s Eve deaths of Elizabeth Platt, 60, and Hanako Abe, 27. They were crossing at Mission and Second in San Francisco when a speeding, intoxicated driver in a stolen car ran a red light and fatally struck both women.

The mainstream press has come down hard on District Attorney Chesa Boudin for failing to prosecute the suspect, Troy McAlister, prior to the crash. McAlister is a parolee with multiple arrests–including one, NBC Bay Area reports, on Dec. 20 for another alleged car theft.

For the advocates at Walk San Francisco, however, this most recent tragedy is part of a larger, more disturbing trend.

Also from Walk San Francisco’s release:

In 2014, the City of San Francisco committed to end severe and fatal traffic injuries within ten years: Vision Zero. Vision Zero launched an interagency, data-driven approach to traffic safety. But while some important changes have come out of this commitment, including a focus on redesigning the streets with the highest crash rates, progress has stalled. City budget challenges put Vision Zero at further risk.

“Vision Zero continues to be the right approach and our best hope for traffic safety,” said Medeiros. “Streets can be designed and enforced to keep people safe. But it will take real commitment and real changes from City leaders, as well as much deeper interagency coordination.”

In 2014, 13 City agencies are committed to Vision Zero: the Mayor’s Office, SF Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA), SF Dept of Public Health, SF Police Department, SF Public Works, SF Planning Department, SF District Attorney, SF County Transportation Authority, SF Dept of Environment, SF Fire Department, SF Unified School District, SF International Airport, SF Recreation & Parks.

On average, 30 people are killed and 600 severely injured in traffic crashes in San Francisco each year. People walking continue to be the most vulnerable and suffer the greatest burden with traffic safety.

There was a drop in 2017, when there were 20 fatalities, despite a booming economy–which is usually linked to more driving and more crashes. That now appears to be an anomaly.

It’s difficult to say for sure if this particular crash might have been less deadly if the street had more robust safety treatments, especially ones designed to force speed reductions. However, the aggregate of 30 deaths a year in San Francisco and many more throughout the Bay Area is absolutely attributable to a lack of serious political commitment, bad road designs that prioritize speed over safety, and the watering down of projects.

And for people who think Vision Zero isn’t actually achievable, Streetsblog strongly recommends they watch this eight-minute video:

Abe, meanwhile, was originally from Fukushima, Japan where she survived the earthquake, tsunami and nuclear disaster of 2011. Her friends and family set up a Gofundme page to help bring home her remains.


Supes Call for Aggressive Enforcement Against Dangerous Driving

In an emotionally-charged discussion, the dangers of walking on San Francisco’s streets took center stage at yesterday’s Board of Supervisors meeting, the first since an alarming number of San Franciscans were injured and killed by drivers over the holiday season. Every supervisor except Katy Tang, Mark Farrell, and Malia Cohen spoke to express condolences to the […]

A Walk & Roll to School Day Event in San Francisco

Yesterday some 13,000 San Francisco children at 95 schools walked–and in some cases rolled in wheelchairs–to school as part of the 20th annual Walk-to-School Day (now called “Walk-and-Roll-to-School Day,” at least locally). The event is intended to encourage kids to walk to school and spend more time walking and playing outside. This is part of a global […]
Walk SF's Cathy DeLuca, SFBC's Brian Wiedenmeier,  Supervisor Jeff Sheehy, Families for Safe Street's Alvin Lester, Acting Mayor London Breed, and  Police Chief Bill Scott, at this morning's event at City Hall to discuss progress towards Vision Zero. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick

Advocates and City Officials Discuss Progress on Vision Zero

“Think about how fast you’re driving. Think about that next stop sign. Just think if you’re driving a motor vehicle,” said Alvin Lester, co-founder of Bay Area Families for Safe Streets, and the father of 21-year-old Arman, who was killed in 2014 while riding his skateboard at 3rd and Cargo Way in San Francisco. Lester made […]