Facing Resistance to Longer Walks, SFMTA Revises Some Muni Route Changes

Muni TEP Planning Manager Sean Kennedy explains proposals at an open house meeting last night. Photo: Aaron Bialick

The SFMTA is fine-tuning its proposals to change Muni routes as part of its Transit Effectiveness Project, an effort to make Muni more efficient. By consolidating stops and concentrating service on key routes, the TEP aims to make Muni faster and more reliable. The agency presented revisions at a public meeting last night intended to address pushback from some residents, many of whom are elderly, against proposals that would have them walk up to a few blocks more to their Muni stop.

A second open house will be held tomorrow morning, where the SFMTA will present the revised proposals again for feedback.

With input collected at 11 neighborhood meetings held throughout the city over the past few weeks, a few of the proposed line adjustments have undergone major revisions to avoid disrupting current service patterns, said Sean Kennedy, planning manager for the Muni TEP. “There are a couple of hot issues in each district,” he said.

For example, a proposal to move the 27-Bryant segment in the Mission to Folsom Street [PDF], replacing the 12-Folsom (proposed to be eliminated) and re-named the 27-Folsom, has been changed to keep Muni on Bryant. Residents, including Supervisor David Campos, protested the prospect of walking to parallel lines like the 9-San Bruno on Potrero Avenue (three blocks away) or the new 27 route (five blocks away). Planners said the original proposal would have allowed Muni to provide more frequent service on those lines, alleviating crowding on the 9 and 9-Limited.

“We heard from the community that people really need the service on Bryant,” said Kennedy, “that there are a lot of daycare facilities on there, and we thought that the 9/9L was close enough to serve those people on the 27. But it turns out, as we heard, that the 9 is super crowded, and not necessarily a safe line.”

Under the new proposal, Folsom will be served by a new line to be created as part of the TEP, the 11-Downtown Connector, which will stretch from North Beach to the outer Mission District.

Concerns from residents appear to be largely focused on the ability of elderly and disabled riders to walk longer distances, as well as people who feel unsafe walking in certain areas due to street crime. However, 61 percent of Muni riders in a 2010 survey said they would consider walking a longer distance to their stop if they knew it would reduce their overall travel time.

Photo: Aaron Bialick

The northern end of the 8X-Bayshore was also re-configured. The SFMTA’s original proposal was to eliminate the segment north of Broadway, since it attracted many riders who used it as a short run to Market Street, crowding out the crosstown riders boarding in Chinatown headed to Visitacion Valley and other southern neighborhoods. But after complaints from commuters who said they use the 8X to reach the north end, planners proposed reducing the frequency on the segment instead, with every other 8X bus continuing to run north of Broadway.

Although some of the people protesting TEP changes have seen them as service cuts, Kennedy said service is expected to increase overall by 10 percent, reaffirming that the TEP is a data-driven effort that aims to deploy service more efficiently by shifting resources from lesser-used routes to where the ridership is.

Muni TEP planners will present their revised proposals on March 14 and 28 to the SFMTA Board of Directors, which would need to approve them. To weigh in on proposals, you can head to an open house at the SFMTA offices at 1 South Van Ness Avenue (at Market Street), tomorrow at 10 a.m.

  • murphstahoe

    I was at Caltrain and needed to go to Civic Center. I saw the 83X there, thought about it for a minute, and grabbed a bike share bike instead. I left the 83X in the dust.

  • coolbabybookworm

    Good point, it’s such a short and flat route just about anyone of working age who would be on a commuter bus would be able to bike the route. Now if only the bike infra was there to enable everyone to feel safe enough to ride the route.

  • Easy

    Rolling the buses & drivers used to service the 27 into the 9 would be better. A single big pool of seats that can be used by all riders in the east Mission would absorb riders evenly, rather than having one route over crowded and the other under used. And you also end up reducing the waiting time for a bus.

  • Jesse

    Ugh, appease everyone and fail at everything.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

“Muni TEP Approved”? Not So Fast

|
The Muni Transit Effectiveness Project took a major step forward on March 28, when the SFMTA Board of Directors approved plans for route changes and street upgrades aimed at streamlining transit service. Judging from the headlines on major media reports, the vote sounded like a green light for the entire TEP. However, the reports glossed over some […]

Muni TEP Meeting: L-Taraval Travel Time Reduction Proposals

|
From SFMTA: Muni is considering proposed service and route changes as part of the Transit Effectiveness Project (TEP). Developed with extensive analysis and community input, the TEP proposals will modernize Muni for its 700,000 daily passengers. The TEP proposes to reduce by 25 to 30% the travel time for the L-Taraval using a combination of stop […]

Citywide Muni TEP Public Meeting

|
From SFMTA: Muni is considering proposed service and route changes as part of the Transit Effectiveness Project (TEP). Developed with extensive analysis and community input, the TEP proposals will modernize Muni for its 700,000 daily passengers. Attend this meeting to provide input and learn more. You can also visit tellmuni.com to give feedback and sign up for […]

Muni TEP Meeting: Routes 2, 28/28L, and 38L in the Richmond

|
From SFMTA: Muni Needs Your Input!  Give Feedback on Proposed Service Changes at Upcoming Meetings. Muni is considering proposed service and route changes as part of the Transit Effectiveness Project (TEP).  Developed with extensive analysis and community input, the TEP proposals will modernize Muni for its 700,000 daily passengers. Attend this meeting to provide input […]

Muni TEP Meeting: Routes 6 and 71 in the Upper Haight

|
From SFMTA: Muni Needs Your Input! Give Feedback on Proposed Service Changes at Upcoming Meetings. Muni is considering proposed service and route changes as part of the Transit Effectiveness Project (TEP). Developed with extensive analysis and community input, the TEP proposals will modernize Muni for its 700,000 daily passengers. Attend this meeting to provide input […]