Study: Even in Car-Centric Atlanta, Transport Reform is Health Reform

The connection
between transportation reform — an emphasis on land use that makes
biking and walking as viable as auto travel for routine trips — and
health reform is one that’s not often made, despite the best efforts of the Obama administration.

050509_traffic_study_vmed_6a.widec.jpgEven in traffic-choked Atlanta, denser residential neighborhoods had positive health effects. (Photo: MSNBC)

a team of researchers led by Lawrence Frank of the University of
British Columbia took a particularly novel approach to the relationship
between transport and health for a study recently published in the
journal Preventive Medicine. For their observations, the group eschewed
Chicago, New York, Portland, or other highly walkable cities in favor
of sprawl-heavy Atlanta.

Frank, Steve Winkelman of D.C.’s Center for Clean Air Policy, and
Michael Greenwald of the Seattle-based firm Urban Design 4 Health used data from Atlanta’s SMARTRAQ
survey to map the amount of calories burned by various blends of
walking, transit, and car use. That calorie-burning factor was dubbed
the "energy index."

The "energy index" of Atlantans
increased significantly as their neighborhoods grew denser, according
to the study, and the number of calories they used on motorized travel
shrank in denser, more walkable areas.

But interestingly
enough, the study’s density factor only examined residential properties
— and in neighborhoods where mixed-use development grew, bringing
housing closer to commercial property, the energy used for driving and walking decreased, leaving Atlantans’ "energy index" unaffected.

result likely demonstrates that the energy required to travel in a very
mixed land use pattern is lower for both walking and driving — with no
real impact on the relationship between the two modes," the study’s
authors wrote.

The authors also noted the significance of
a documented link between dense residential development and public
health in a city known more for its grinding traffic jams and struggling transit:

Atlanta region is relatively skewed in terms of walkability, with a low
proportion of survey participants actually walking and limited
variation in urban form. While this presented some difficulty, the
large sample size and oversampling of residents of walkable
neighborhoods allowed for reasonable estimates of association. The fact
that these results emerged in the auto-oriented Atlanta region is an
indication that relationships are robust; associations are expected to
be stronger in regions with higher overall variations in walkability
and/or transit access.

  • I have not read the report. But at first clance on the summary above I thougth research can be used to prove whatever you want. Why not admit that massive car use is harming our lives and planet? We have to reduce car use if we want to survive. Let us give priority to commerce end industry, service vehicles and buses during the rush hours; this is TrafikkLogistikk (TrafficLogistics), see my blog: or email me:

    Knut Bøe


Transportation Reform Is Health Reform

During the Washington budget debate earlier this year, a phrase widely attributed to White House budget director Peter Orszag was rolling off many a reporter’s keyboard: "Health reform is entitlement reform." Orszag’s idea, in a nutshell, is that controlling the nation’s skyrocketing health care costs, which are fueled in part by the obesity epidemic, would […]

Complete Streets Could Help America Lose Weight, Says CDC

When non-transportation-geeks ask me why transportation policy is a topic worthy of more attention on the national stage, I often start by talking about the public health implications. Not only are tens of thousands of Americans killed and injured in car crashes every year, not only are countless thousands of others killed and sickened by […]

Bachmann Says Walking and Biking Have Nothing to Do With Public Health

Back when the Senate kicked off its health care debate, Republicans tested out a new line of attack against health committee chairman Edward Kennedy’s (D-MA) draft bill: Its investment in encouraging walking and biking amounts to inexcusable government waste. Never mind that walking and biking have scientifically proven public health benefits. Never mind that the […]

New Study Shows $56 Billion in Hidden Health Damage from Autos

Transportation’s effects on public health are rarely discussed by policy-makers, but they remain very real — and the National Research Council (NRC) put a number on them today, reporting that cars and trucks have about $56 billion in "hidden" health costs that are not reflected in the price of oil or electricity. (Photo: In […]