SF Youths Protest Costly Muni Ride to School while Sunday Parking is Free

IMG_1547.jpgSan Francisco high school and college students, most wearing orange shirts protesting Muni cuts, pack the Board of Supervisors chamber on Tuesday. Photo: Michael Rhodes

If the MTA Board approves budget solutions being presented by staff on Friday, the price of a youth monthly Fast Pass will go up to $30, regardless of family income. But members of San Francisco’s Youth Commission say there are better ways to close the MTA’s $16.9 million end-of-year budget gap.

A more equitable option, they argue, would be to extend parking meter enforcement hours.

"The city has a Transit First policy in which it’s supposed to promote public transportation and bicycling and other modes of transportation to counter personal driving use, and this increase goes counter to that," said Nicholas Quesada, chairman of the city’s 17-member Youth Commission and a senior at School of the Arts High School.

Members of the Youth Commission and other young Muni riders made that point in force at yesterday’s Board of Supervisors meeting, calling on the supes and the MTA Board to reject an increase in the youth monthly Fast Pass price.

They’re sympathetic to the MTA’s budget situation: After all, the state has taken $179 million from the agency over the past three years. But Leah LaCroix, an SF State student who chairs the Youth Commission’s Planning, Land Use and City Services Committee, said new revenue options can’t be taken off the table just because they are politically difficult.

"I know this may be really hard, but I would support increasing the time of parking meters," she said. "Things like that would get it off the backs of the youth."

IMG_1541.jpgSupervisor Eric Mar snaps a picture of the Board of Supervisors chamber filled with youth protesting Muni fare increases on Tuesday.

Quesada, who commutes to school by the 44 or 52 from the Excelsior district, notes that while the youth Fast Pass cost would be making a 300 percent increase from its price less than a year ago, not everyone has shared the burden equally to balance Muni’s budget, and he thinks most San Francisco youths would support extending parking meter hours in the evenings or to Sundays instead.

"A lot of us take public transportation to and from school. I think that’s kind of a suburban thing: When you turn 16 you go out and try to get your license. I don’t have my license. I can get by on a bicycle and the bus."

For 70 percent of public school students in San Francisco, getting to school means taking public transportation. A year ago, that meant purchasing a $10 youth-specific monthly pass – still pricier than the free school bus ride many other municipalities offer, but with a lot more freedom to move about town sans parental chauffeur. That price would go up to $30 if the MTA Board approves staff recommendations this Friday. In that case, a family with two adults and
two kids would pay $180 a month for Muni passes, or $120 if their income qualifies the parents for the $30 Lifeline pass.

Extending parking meter enforcement hours could pay for a youth low-income discount pass, which currently doesn’t exist, said Youth Commissioner Hillary Liang, a sophomore at Lowell High School and a Chinatown resident. "I think a lot of other people I know also support this," she said. "Many youths want to focus on their studies instead of taking a part-time job just to pay for the transportation to go to school."

The MTA hopes to raise about $4 million annually by increasing the price of monthly Fast Passes for seniors, youths and people with disabilities by $10. That’s on top of a $5 increase already set to go in effect in May. Extending parking meter hours per an MTA staff study last year could bring in more than twice what the discount Fast Pass increase would net.

Advocates for parking reform have long cited another benefit of increasing parking meter enforcement hours: It might actually be possible to find a parking spot on Sunday afternoon. Quesada made that argument on Tuesday as well.

"People will move their cars and maybe drive less and take more public transportation, increasing the revenue to Muni. So, it seems like it’d be a win-win."

  • Nick

    This is bad in so many ways. It seems the people who make these decisions are divorced from the reality of those who rely on transit to get to school.

    I remember when I went to SF’s public schools in the 90’s that the first 3 days of every month were particularly nerve wracking. The younger kids and those who looked vulnerable would be bullied, intimidated, or beat up for their Fast Passes by groups of punks and gang members.

    Is anybody else concerned that violence will increase to many innocent youths as a result of these fare increases? Back then it was $7 for a monthly pass; I can only imagine that charging $30 will bring back those dangerous times.

    It’s such an irresponsible way to run a city. Charge for Sunday meters and leave the kid’s empty pockets alone already.

  • “This is bad in so many ways. It seems the people who make these decisions are divorced from the reality of those who rely on transit…”

    I’ll just quote you to there because “the powers that be” are divorced from all reasons of using public transit, not just schools. It all starts at the top where Newsom has a private SUV drive him around the city. SFMTA has free parking for their employees (the same charged with running our transit). If they have no personal stake – they don’t ride and their jobs will have a better chance of being there if lines are cut, then why would they care about the effects this will have.

    Sad to hear about that going on in the schools. And I’d assume if with more crack downs on fare evaders then more kids will be beat up for their passes. Easier to take it from a freshman then deal with the police when they come checking.

    Totally an irresponsible way to run a city. But once again, look to the top. Newsom has been on one big publicity tour since day one.


Board of Supes Passes Resolution Urging Free Lifeline Youth Passes

A proposal to give thousands of low-income public school students free Muni passes is on its way to the SFMTA Board for approval after the Board of Supervisors unanimously passed a resolution Tuesday. It followed a passionate show of support from dozens of speakers at Monday’s City Operations and Neighborhood Services Committee hearing. “We need […]