Skip to Content
Streetsblog San Francisco home
Streetsblog San Francisco home
Log In
Streetsblog.net

Report: “Cash for Clunkers” Was a Lemon

Here’s the thing about subsidies: They encourage people to do more of something than they would have under normal circumstances.

That’s okay if the activity the government is subsidizing creates an overall benefit for society — like better educated kids, or a cleaner environment.

But if said subsidy encourages behavior detrimental to society, well, that’s just bad policy.

I guess it shouldn’t be surprising then that President Obama’s Cash for Clunkers program — which paid people to buy more fuel efficient cars — is being described as a failure.

According to a recently revised evaluation [PDF] from the environmental group Resources for the Future, the program did little to improve the efficiency of the nation’s private auto fleet.

Erica C. Barnett at Network blog PubliCola explains:

According to the report, “the average fuel economy was only 0.65 miles per gallon better than it would have been among newly purchased cars had the program never existed.” Additionally, 45 percent of the new-car buyers who took advantage of the program would have bought new cars anyway, the study found.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog San Francisco

On the Sausalito City Council and the Bridgeway Safety Project

The Marin County Bicycle Coalition responds to Saturday's fiasco at City Hall... and discusses next steps for Bridgeway

April 3, 2025

Oak Street Protected Bike Lane Approved. Questions Remain About Section in Panhandle Park

Overall project is welcome. But SFMTA has cyclists cutting into the Panhandle Park to make more room for turning cars

April 3, 2025
See all posts