Four Reasons Pedestrian Injuries Have Plummeted Along Protected Bike Lanes
2:02 PM PST on November 14, 2014
Michael Andersen blogs for The Green Lane Project, a PeopleForBikes program that helps U.S. cities build better bike lanes to create low-stress streets.
Protected bike lanes are good at making it safer to bike. But they are great at making it safer to walk.
As dozens of thought leaders on street safety gather in New York City today for the Vision Zero for Cities Symposium, some of them will be discussing this little-known fact: On New York streets that received protected bike lanes from 2007 to 2011, total traffic injury rates fell by 12 to 52 percent.
"There had been about one pedestrian fatality per mile for years on those streets," said Matthew Roe, the former senior safety planning and research manager at the NYC Department of Transportation. "We saw huge, huge reductions."
Why would bike infrastructure be so good for people walking? It comes down mostly to four factors.
1) Protected bike lanes shorten crossing distances
This is probably the most obvious benefit of protected bike lanes to people walking: You don't have to walk across as many lanes of auto traffic when you cross the street.
"Pretty much the most effective thing we can do for pedestrian safety is get rid of mixed-traffic lanes that shouldn't be there either because the streets are overbuilt or that the way they work is different from the way they were designed," said Roe, who now directs the Designing Cities Initiative for the National Association of City Transportation Officials.
The crossing distance problem is closely related to another safety factor...
2) Protected bike lanes make it easier to know which direction cars are coming from
When you're walking, it's not the traffic you expect that poses a danger -- it's the traffic you don't expect.
By reducing the number of mixed traffic lanes, protected bike lane projects effectively break each pedestrian street crossing into manageable stages, all of which include tightly defined vehicle movements.
"Instead of the pedestrians crossing maybe 70 or 80 feet or 90 feet of unspecified undesignated roadway into which the car could be turning from a side street at any point, instead the pedestrian now crosses the bike lane, in which it's very clear where the bikes are coming from," said Roe. "Then they cross three and only three -- or sometimes two -- lanes of traffic, and they know exactly where that traffic is coming from."
3) Dedicated signal phases prevent turning conflicts with people walking
For decades, people have been told not to bike on sidewalks because people using the same street in cars wouldn't be able to see them and might turn directly into them.
"That story was very well known in the world of biking," Roe said. "But it turns out that the same issues were affecting pedestrians too."
Drivers turning into crosswalks, hitting people who are following walk signals correctly but are somewhat obscured from motorists' view by parked cars, are a major cause of pedestrian deaths. But the same traffic signals that give people biking a head start on traffic or a green light of their very own can also be used by people walking, and the same daylighting and mixing zones that make it easier for motorists to see bikes while turning have exactly the same effect on increasing the visibility of people walking.
4) Protected bike lanes reduce traffic weaving
Another maneuver that endangers people walking is the "zip-around": people swerving their car from one lane to another to get around a stopped car, only to realize the other driver had stopped to yield to someone in the crosswalk.
Protected lanes help solve this problem by creating traffic-calming barriers that drivers slow down to avoid and by narrowing or removing the mixed-traffic lanes that are available to cars.
When a street has more auto capacity than it actually needs, Roe said, people start making bad choices.
"You know there's going to be speeding," he said. "You know there's going to be aggressive maneuvers. People will be speeding around each other and double-parking."
But redesigning a street that has an unnecessary mixed-traffic lane into a street with a protected bike lane can have dramatic effects on street safety, Roe said. Once zip-arounds become impossible, people driving simply queue up to wait their turn -- and people walking are, once again, the biggest winners.
More from Streetsblog San Francisco
CalBike: Tell the Legislature Hands Off Active Transportation Funding
Oakland Rips Out Protected Bike Lane on Embarcadero
The city and the councilmember who represents District 2 complain about lack of resources for safety projects, but somehow they have the resources to rip out protected bike lanes