Menlo Park’s Plan to Ruin Downtown With Parking Garages

Menlo Park's popular Parking Plaza 3, one of three sites proposed for a new public parking garage. Photo: Andrew Boone
Menlo Park’s Parking Plaza 3, one of three sites proposed for a new public parking garage. Photo: Andrew Boone

Building new parking garages in downtown Menlo Park will cost tens of millions of dollars while clogging streets with more traffic. But that’s what municipal leaders are seriously considering in an attempt to boost business, apparently oblivious to modern parking policies that have paid off for other Peninsula cities.

Last month, the Menlo Park City Council voiced support for building a new five-level parking garage on top of one of the city’s surface parking lots, called “parking plazas.” The project is estimated to cost between $29,000 and $43,000 per parking space — adding up to several million dollars. The council is also considering extending time limits for downtown parking spaces, having concluded that the current time limits on free parking discourage shoppers from visiting businesses on Santa Cruz Avenue.

Menlo Park maintains 1,595 free parking spaces in its downtown core (the area bounded by El Camino Real, University Drive, Oak Grove Avenue, and Menlo Avenue). The current time limits, set in 2011, are 15 minutes, one hour, or two hours, depending on location. In some spaces, drivers can exceed the two-hour limit by paying $1 per hour after it expires. Also available are $10 daily permits and $592 annual permits.

The council proposed doubling the time limits on the 15-minute and one-hour spaces and extending the two-hour spaces to a three hour limit, with the intention of giving customers arriving by car more time to spend at Santa Cruz Avenue businesses.

“We have the foot traffic, and then we take a stick and chase [customers] away as soon as they finish lunch,” said Mayor Catherine Carlton of the current time limits.

“I just want to make it as easy as possible for families and our seniors to patronize our local business and our restaurants downtown,” said Council Member Ray Mueller, who described the current time limits as outdated, based on parking data collected in 2009 during an economic recession.

But what’s really outdated is the idea that giving away more free parking will be good for downtown. Time limits are a blunt and ineffective means to ration access to parking. For years, UCLA professor Donald Shoup, the nation’s leading expert on parking policy, has counseled cities to instead manage parking by pricing it properly, so that some spaces are always available.

By extending time limits, Menlo Park will only make it harder for driving shoppers to find a parking space during peak hours, causing them to spend more time cruising for spots and clogging downtown streets. Anticipating this problem, the city is now considering building a new parking garage.

“We really ought to try and figure out a way to get one of the parking structures scoped out and built,” said Council Member Peter Ohtaki, “so that it will alleviate some of the stress on the plazas that then can be prioritized for customer parking.”

Menlo Park’s 2012 El Camino Real & Downtown Specific Plan proposed building five five-level parking garages on the city’s parking plazas over the next 20 years. At the time, the estimated construction costs ranged from $11 million for a 250-space garage to $21 million for 650-space garages.

But the same plan also advised a number of lower-cost measures to manage existing parking spaces so that “the number of new parking spaces needed may be reduced and the timing for constructing a parking garage may be postponed.”

Parking garages proposed in 2012 by Menlo Park’s El Camino Real & Downtown Specific Plan. Image: City of Menlo Park

Those recommendations include setting hourly prices for downtown parking spaces to keep a certain number of spaces free, while removing time restrictions entirely. Neighboring Redwood City has used this strategy since 2005 to manage 2,774 on-street and off-street parking spaces in its downtown, with rates currently set at $1 per hour in the city’s downtown core. Menlo Park has not yet studied this option in detail.

New revenues from metered parking in downtown Menlo Park could be used to fund alternatives to driving, such as free or reduced-price transit passes for downtown employees or infrastructure improvements, including wider sidewalks and better bicycle parking. Other programs to reduce demand for car parking could be funded through a Transportation Management Association (TMA) of downtown businesses, similar to those now established in San Mateo and Palo Alto.

The next step of the downtown parking garage project is a $200,000 feasibility study, recommended by the city’s Planning Commission in January to be included in its 2015-2020 Capital Improvement Plan [PDF], scheduled for City Council review in May and June.


Menlo Park Gets One Step Closer to Protected Bike Lanes on El Camino Real

A report released by Menlo Park’s Public Works Department last week [PDF] recommends protected bike lanes and Dutch-style “protected intersections” on El Camino Real. The two-year El Camino Real Corridor Study, led by transportation consulting firm W-Trans, said building bike lanes protected from car traffic by a curb would provide “the most optimum safety conditions for bicycling” and walking while […]

Apartment Blockers

Alan Durning is the executive director and founder of Sightline Institute, a think tank on sustainability issues in the Pacific Northwest. This article, originally posted on Sightline’s blog, is #9 in their series, “Parking? Lots!” Have you ever watched the excavation that precedes a tall building? It seems to take forever. Then, when the digging […]

SF’s Parking Experiment to Test Shoup’s Traffic Theories

SF Park Pilot Areas – Richmond and West Portal control areas not featured The Municipal Transportation Agency’s federally-funded parking experiment, SFPark, is shaping up to be the most powerful tool remaining in the city’s traffic-busting toolbox considering the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce’s criticism of congestion pricing and Mayor Newsom’s recent tempered support for the […]

Menlo Park El Camino Real Bike Lanes Delayed Again

Menlo Park’s plans to fix El Camino Real’s safety hazards were postponed yet again by a city council that is now split on whether to go ahead with the installation of even a bike lane pilot project. Proponents continue to demand that the city take action to prevent injuries suffered by residents in traffic collisions. “The goals of Menlo […]