SPUR Talk: Political Lessons from London and New York

Turns out the Bay Area's special transportation and planning challenges aren't so special after all

The Bay Areas problems, such as  transit overcrowding at rush hour, and complex governance, may not be as unique as we think. All Images from the presentations unless noted.
The Bay Areas problems, such as transit overcrowding at rush hour, and complex governance, may not be as unique as we think. All Images from the presentations unless noted.

Note: GJEL Accident Attorneys regularly sponsors coverage on Streetsblog San Francisco and Streetsblog California. Unless noted in the story, GJEL Accident Attorneys is not consulted for the content or editorial direction of the sponsored content.

They may all share the same roundel, but the divisions within Transport for London can be surprisingly parochial, explained Isabel Dedring, currently a director with ARUP, and formerly London’s Deputy Mayor for Transport.

“You would not know they all work for the same organization; they would walk out of a room if they didn’t like the people or the data you were providing,” she said during Tuesday afternoon’s presentation about city governance at SPUR’s Oakland location. “Every city I go to, everybody goes ‘no you don’t understand, our city is so terrible, it’s really complicated, we have all these different agencies, it’s impossible to do anything.'”

They share one logo, but are often as parochial as agencies in any other large city.
They share one logo but the divisions of Transport for London are often as parochial as agencies in any other large city.

In the Bay Area, urban planners bemoan the region’s 27 different transit agencies. But Dedring said no matter how many agencies there are in a region, it still comes down to individual interests and figuring out how to get those individuals behind your project. “It’s complicated everywhere you go.”

Margaret Newman, also with ARUP, was formerly Chief of Staff to Janette Sadik-Khan at the NYC Department of Transportation (NYDOT). “NYDOT doesn’t actually run any transportation, except for a few ferries,” she explained. And that means dealing with lots of outside agencies.

She said the key to getting things done in New York was to have specific, well-defined goals that the other agencies could buy into–and that meant reaching out to individual department heads within NYDOT and inside other agencies as well. “Inside each agency, there are divisions–so mobility might include people from parking, signalized intersections… lots of different folks,” she said. “So bringing those people together was super important.”

While a bit less complex than London, New York also has to deal with its share of political boundries and different agencies.
New York also has to deal with its share of political boundaries and different agencies.

So what does all this mean in practice?

Newman cites the closing of Broadway to motor traffic through Times Square as their proudest accomplishment. But it meant selling the project to automobile interests, such as cab companies. “We sold it by saying the priority was to increase traffic speeds in midtown.”

That was accomplished, she said, by simplifying intersections. And since Broadway runs at an angle to the street grid, which caused backups at intersections, it worked–with a bit of help from the economic collapse. “The 2008 economic meltdown, it turns out, was really good for traffic movement.”

The other key, she said, was selling it as a pilot. “So we did a nine-month pilot project,” which used epoxy gravel, folding chairs, and other quick-to-install materials. Then, after nine months, NYDOT had data to show about how the project was working–which is how they were able to show naysayers that collisions were down and traffic flow had improved. “There’s that famous Bloomberg quote, ‘in God we trust, all others bring data.’ We focused on measurable outcomes,” said Newman.

There was an added bonus: after doing a long enough pilot, the city could make the case that a full environmental study wasn’t needed to make the changes permanent, since it was now ‘existing conditions.’ “This had implications all over the city,” said Newman.

TimesSquare
A look at Times Square before and after Broadway was closed to motor traffic as part of a “temporary pilot” that is now permanent.

Dedring has similar prescriptions from London. “Have a clear strategy and priorities,” she said, stressing that in getting collaboration transport planners always have to think of individual interests for employees of other agencies as well as the general public. “Don’t say it’s a purple train with great wheels! Transportation people think transportation is really interesting,” she said, adding that for most people, it just isn’t.

Instead, explain why a transit project is going to solve a problem people care about, such as getting to work faster or gaining access to cheaper housing. She said plans for the extension of the Bakerloo Tube line came at a time when Londoners saw the cost of housing as their biggest single problem. “So we said this isn’t about transport, it’s about delivering 15,000 homes in a relatively poor part of the city.” She said the route was based on maximizing access to housing as opposed to the usual business case for extending transit.

In other words, “It’s not our job to build something worthy and to tell people they’re bad for not using it,” said Dedring. “It’s to actually create something people are significantly better off using; they don’t use the Tube because it’s pleasant, they use it because it’s faster from A to B.”

As to street design, Dedring agreed with Newman on the importance of pilots. “Just put in some planters and armadillos and say ‘oh, it’s just a trial.’ Not once has any of these schemes been taken out in my experience.”

An example of a 'temporary' protected bike lane in London that became permanent.
An example of a ‘temporary’ protected bike lane in London that became permanent.

Dedring also said it’s important to listen to advocates. She recalled how London’s first attempt to build bike lanes, which were more of the typical, striped lanes without protection, failed. “People in the cycling community were going off to Copenhagen and redrawing our designs and putting them online,” she said. The cycling community demanded truly protected bike lanes. “What we ended up with in the end were things we never did in the UK before,” she said, including bus-boarding islands. “Ultimately we were able to deliver proper segregated lanes.”

London advocates got poorly designed bike lanes upgrades to fully protected bike lanes with bus-boarding islands.
London advocates got poorly designed bike lanes upgraded to fully protected bike lanes with bus-boarding islands, thanks to advocates and protests.

At the end of the day though, both Dedring and Newman agreed it’s hard to make progress without a strong mayor who believes in and fights for better public transit and safer, more livable streets.

Newman recalled how New York’s Mayor Bloomberg was willing to close Broadway to traffic at a time when that seemed untenable. “In 2009, it was a bold thing to do in an election year.”

Ultimately, said Dedring, it’s not about political structures and transit agencies, it’s about individuals and political leaders. “It’s radically different between administrations.” She recalled how London Mayor Boris Johnson took risks after years of inconclusive discussions about extending the Bakerloo line. “Boris was going give a talk, so he just announced that we would build the Bakerloo line by 2030; a great example of where the irrationality of politics can be a good idea.”

IMG_20180130_133046
Isabel Dedring and Margaret Newman at Tuesday’s SPUR talk in Oakland. Photo: Streetsblog/Rudick

For more events like these, visit SPUR’s events page.

  • neroden

    BoJo is the only Tory I’ve ever liked. He really was a good mayor.

  • keenplanner

    Using Googleplex (a major employer) in Mountain View as a destination, click around to suburbs without BART or Caltrain stations. No matter where, it will take 3-4 hours on transit. Places with transit stations can still take 2 hours. In fact, from Milpitas, a suburb 10 miles from Google, it still will take an hour and 15 minutes.
    Transit is good in the Bay Area if you happen to live and work near a transit hub, but most of those small transit operators scattered about the Bay Area aren’t the least bit interested in getting you to work.
    MTC’s solution is “build PDAs” near transit lines, but when will MTC address the failure of 90% of Bay Area transit to serve the needs of riders?
    What if there was a big origin-destination study for Bay Area commuters, and all the transit agencies worked together to serve the most riders possible? Nevermind.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Public works paved the roadway to the left, but left the bike lanes full of cracks, dangerous furrows, potholes, and other defects. All photos Streetsblog/Rudick unless noted.

City Lets Cargo Way Protected Bike Lane Fall Apart

|
As cyclists who use Cargo Way in the Hunters Point/Bayview neighborhood know all too well, the bike lane, once celebrated as San Francisco's first on-street protected bike lane, is in a state of disrepair, with broken pavement, a dangerous, tire-grabbing groove, and a busted fence. And in a stark display of how some city officials regard bicycle safety, the city repaved the adjacent car/truck lanes in August, but skipped the bike lane.
The new Berry Street contraflow bike lane. Photo:  
Leonid Domnitser

Third Street Bridge Detour and the Temporary Berry Bike Lane

|
Note: GJEL Accident Attorneys regularly sponsors coverage on Streetsblog San Francisco and Streetsblog California. Unless noted in the story, GJEL Accident Attorneys is not consulted for the content or editorial direction of the sponsored content. Mission Bay commuters are no doubt aware that the Lefty O’Doul drawbridge on Third Street is currently locked in the upright position and, according […]