Op-ed: Slow Streets & Redefining “Busy”

A street full of cars stuck in traffic isn't necessarily busy--but it is just bad

Good busy, Page Street. Photo: Charles Whitfield
Good busy, Page Street. Photo: Charles Whitfield

I heard a San Francisco fire commissioner say at a public hearing last month  that “not a soul” is using Page Slow Street. This person was clearly wrong; anyone who’s spent even a few minutes on Page this year has seen people passing by on foot or on a bike. The commissioner’s mistake stems from two car-culture biases that we could all benefit from re-examining.

First, why do we expect lots of people on bikes and foot to quickly flood a few new car-lite streets? Let’s try a thought experiment: imagine electric cars had been banned on every street in the city for decades, and the tolls were suddenly lifted on just a few streets. Would we expect to see large numbers of electric cars on those streets shortly thereafter? Of course not. It would take some time and more than just a few EV-friendly streets to see a dramatic change in behavior.

The same is true for Slow Streets. People’s comfort and habits are built over months and years. Time frame aside, any mode of travel requires more than a few disconnected streets. People need a robust network that actually gets them places. It’s no coincidence that Page, one of SF’s most supported Slow Streets, serves just such a purpose, connecting car-free Market Street at its eastern terminus with car-free JFK Drive to its west, in a practical and safe cross-town route for human-scale transit. The more destinations this network connects to, the more people will use it.

Second, it’s wrong to conclude, just because a Slow Street isn’t constantly crammed with people, that “no one is using it” or that it isn’t “busy.” Car-dominated cities have warped our sense of what a “busy” street looks and feels like. We think of “busy” streets as being noisy, smelling of burning gas, and physically filled with large metal boxes.

Bad "busy" on Howard Street. Photo: Sergio Ruiz
Bad “busy” on Howard Street. Photo: Sergio Ruiz

But it doesn’t have to be that way.

Buses, bikes, and walking are far, far more space efficient, quieter, and cleaner than cars. Ten people driving cars fill up a city block; the same 10 people on a bus, biking, or walking barely take up any room at all. Screenshot from 2021-06-10 11-56-19

That’s why Page Street doesn’t seem “busy.”

In a city where over 80 percent of trips are non-car, as San Francisco aspires to be, a busy street should be quiet. It might even, for long minutes at a time, look empty, as if “no one is using it”.

I travel on Page Street nearly every day and I always see other people walking, biking, skating or running. It rarely looks crowded, but that doesn’t mean “no one is using” the street.

It means that car-lite streets are different, in a good way.

We can and should redefine what a “busy” street is in San Francisco. Let’s make our Slow Streets, Car-free JFK, and the Great Walkway permanent, and let’s develop a city-wide network of safe streets for people walking, biking, and taking transit throughout the city.

And let’s not be trapped by the idea that a “busy” street means one that is noxious, overcrowded, dangerous, noisy, and jammed full of traffic.

Charles Whitfield lives and works in San Francisco, where he relies on car-free and car-lite street space for transportation and recreation. He is a member of Streets for People.


SFPD Tickets Bike Commuters Trying to Get By Car Queue on Page Street

Here’s today’s edition of egregious waste of SFPD resources used to harass people on bikes. SFPD officers were posted at the bottom of the hill on Page Street at Octavia Boulevard this morning ticketing bike commuters who squeezed to the left of stopped cars. Freeway-bound drivers routinely queue up to turn right, occupying several blocks of Page’s only eastbound traffic […]

SFPD Park Station Begins Pointless Harassment of Bike Commuters

Cops ticketing a cyclist for rolling a stop on The Wiggle. Subject of last week’s protest: http://t.co/xq1euSM4QQ pic.twitter.com/rTovDhLp5d — Kale Williams (@sfkale) August 5, 2015 SFPD Park Station Captain John Sanford has made good on his promise: Officers were out this morning ticketing bike commuters who failed to comply with a strict application of the […]

Some Residents Urge City to Make Bolder Safety Upgrades on Potrero

The city’s latest proposal to improve safety and transit service on Potrero Avenue is slightly different than earlier versions of the plan. While the redesign would expand pedestrian space, some residents at a public meeting yesterday pointed out that it could do much more to make the street safer for biking and walking. Staff from the Department […]