Gascón’s “Message” Evolves, But Motorists’ Victims Still Await Justice

At the press conference held yesterday for the sentencing of Chris Bucchere, it was clear that District Attorney George Gascón’s rhetoric concerning traffic safety has evolved somewhat, toward a more accurate reflection of the dangers on city streets. In a departure from the “message to cyclists” that was his focus last month, Gascón emphasized that “traffic safety is a shared responsibility,” regardless of one’s mode of transport:

Photo: ## 7##

I know there are people in the community who don’t like to hear this, they like to blame one group or another. Some people will say, well, it’s only the motorists, if they were to behave differently, we would be safer. Other people will say, well if only the pedestrians would pay attention, we wouldn’t have these problems. And certainly, others would say, if only the cyclists were more courteous, we would not have as many accidents.

Regardless of the role you’re playing at that moment, whether you’re walking, you’re driving, or you’re cycling, if you’re violating the rules of the road, fatalities are foreseeable. And if they’re foreseeable, they are preventable.

On the last note, Gascón absolutely hit the mark. But he still didn’t acknowledge the reality that people operating multi-ton motor vehicles have a far greater capacity to inflict injury upon more vulnerable users of the road, and that the vast majority of pedestrians are injured by motorists.

The SFPD reported this week that 423 people were hit by drivers in the first five months of this year. Last year, the total was nearly 1,000. Yet, as we’ve reported, drivers are rarely prosecuted for killing pedestrians and bicycle riders as long as they’re sober and stay on the scene.

Even if Gascón hasn’t mentioned it in his remarks on the Bucchere case, he has shown that he understands the lack of accountability for drivers who kill. When the Center for Investigative Reporting published a Bay Area-wide analysis of fatal motorist-pedestrian crashes in April, Gascón told CIR, “If we had 700 people being shot every year, we would be jumping up and down. Reckless driving is just as bad as people using a firearm recklessly.”

Acknowledgement of that reality from law enforcement officials is necessary if victims of traffic violence are to receive equal justice. But while Gascón has touted his prosecution of Bucchere — the first person in the country to be prosecuted for felony vehicular manslaughter for striking someone with a bicycle — and highlighted the injustice suffered by Hui and his family, the DA and the SFPD continue to fail to devote the same level of attention to pedestrians and bicycle riders killed by motorists.

San Franciscans are still waiting for the DA to call for justice for Amelie Le Moullac, who was killed on her bicycle Wednesday by a big rig driver who appeared to have made an illegal right turn in front of her, as well as Dylan Mitchell and Diana Sullivan, who were killed this year under similar circumstances.

Meanwhile, the deaths of Becky Lee, Tania MadfesEileen Barrett, and Hector Arana — all killed by drivers while walking in San Francisco this year — all seem to be nothing more than “unfortunate accidents” in the eyes of police and the DA.

At the presser yesterday, Gascón said his insistence that all road users have responsibility for safety “may be unpopular in some corners.” But regardless of whatever straw men he’s arguing against, it’s clear that the record of prosecution against deadly driving in San Francisco comes nowhere close to representing the fact that it’s the most prevalent danger on our streets.

Until Gascón and other city officials at least acknowledge that fact, his “message” will carry no weight.

Thanks to Bryan Goebel for providing audio for this report.


DA Gascón to Hire Attorney Dedicated to Vehicular Manslaughter Cases

District Attorney George Gascón has announced that he will hire an attorney devoted to handling vehicular manslaughter cases, in what could be a major step toward bringing accountability to drivers who kill. “We’ve lost children, grandparents, people in the prime of their life,” Gascón said yesterday in his State of Public Safety Address, where he announced the initiative under […]

Outer Sunset Kids Urge Drivers to Slow Down Through DA-Funded Program

“Keep Sunset Slow” — that’s the message from kids in the Outer Sunset urging drivers to slow down and save lives this month. Elementary school students held their first event last week, part of a pedestrian safety campaign coordinated by the Sunset Neighborhood Beacon Center and the Outer Noriega Merchants Association. Though it’s a quiet beachside […]

In SF, Victims of Traffic Violence Don’t Have Equal Protection

SF District Attorney George Gascón is set to bring felony vehicular manslaughter charges against Chris Bucchere later today for biking into 71-year-old Sutchi Hui in a crosswalk at Castro and Market Streets, killing him. Any traffic death on our streets deserves a thorough investigation with appropriate charges filed against the responsible party. But this high-profile case raises […]

A Reality Check for the DA’s New Traffic Safety Campaign

For a district attorney who wants to save lives on the streets, using data to target the most dangerous traffic behaviors should be a no-brainer. But the new traffic safety ad campaign announced today by San Francisco DA George Gascón seems to use little application of crash data collected by his own former police department. The three versions of the ad, which […]