Watch: D10 Supervisor Candidates Weigh in on Muni, Parking, and Bike Lanes

The candidates running for District 10 supervisor this November gave some telling responses to transportation questions last week. The first debate of the D10 race was held at the Potrero Hill Democratic Club and moderated by SF Chronicle reporter Marisa Lagos, who asked some pointed questions on issues around Muni, parking, and bike lanes in SF’s eastern and southeast neighborhoods.

District 10 encompasses neighborhoods like Potrero Hill, Dogpatch, Bayview-Hunters Point, and Visitacion Valley. Image: SFGov

The five candidates, as seen seated from left to right in the video above, included Ed Donaldson, Marlene Tran, incumbent Malia Cohen, Tony Kelly (the close runner-up in the most recent election), and Shawn Richard. The video was provided by Kelly’s campaign.

Here’s a summary of highlights from the transportation section:

  • 38:00: Lagos tested candidates on some transit fundamentals by asking them each to write down all of the Muni lines that serve Potrero Hill, then show their answers to the crowd. The responses, which acted as a score card of sorts, weren’t exactly uniform.
  • 40:30: Lagos also drew some differing responses with her follow-up question: “What would you do to improve Muni service to the hill?” Notably, Donaldson was the only one to mention bringing back Sunday parking metering for Muni funding, and was met with hisses from the audience.
  • 43:00: Lagos asked, “Should private buses be allowed to stop at public bus stops?” The consensus from candidates is a resounding “no.”
  • 44:35: Candidates were asked whether they “agree with the current ratio of residential units to parking spaces in new developments.” All candidates except Kelly said they felt current parking maximums were too low. (On parking, it’s worth noting that Kelly pushed the idea of allowing nearby residents to park at new meters for free.)

  • 47:35: Lagos asked what candidates think of congestion pricing. Kelly and Cohen said it should be pursued, but that the pricing zone boundaries needs to be re-configured from the plan proposed in 2010. Donaldson said that “there are some tough choices we have to make” in reducing emissions, and Tran said it should be studied. Richard didn’t respond.
  • 50:00: Candidates were asked if a parking garage should be built in Potrero Hill, and if so, where. Kelly and Cohen suggested some locations, and Donaldson simply said it should be “left to the people.” Tran revealed her support for the “Restore Transportation Balance” ballot initiative, which calls for more car parking to be built.
  • 52:20: Lagos’ question, “What do you think of the current bike plan?,” was a bit misleading since there isn’t a current bike plan. She may have been referring to the Bicycle Strategy, which the SFMTA is developing as a guide to prioritize bike safety improvements, with its sights set on increasing bike mode share to 10 percent by 2018.In response to the question, Donaldson said that “we have to look at ways to” improve transportation options to “get people out of their cars,” because of state mandates to reduce emissions. Tran said bike lanes confuse drivers sometimes. Cohen said “the bike plan we have now was ill-conceived,” because people shouldn’t bike on certain streets, and said the Hairball needs sharrows. Kelly called for “physical separation” to reduce conflicts. Richard says “we can all share the road.”
  • Johnny Damon

    Watched the whole thing and couldn’t believe how amateur this was. Lagos’ questions were poorly researched and not conducive to thoughtful answers and discussion. Members of the audience were very rude. The rules of not applauding/cheering after each candidate were not enforced. It’s no wonder good people in SF who would make good candidates don’t run for office. What we are left with are people willing to subject themselves to this. Sad.

  • murphstahoe

    Potrero Hill needs a secure parking garage at 22nd Street. For bikes!

  • David

    The Hairball needs sharrows? I think it needs a lot more than that!

  • Amy

    Sharrow? Seriously? I am scare to even walk near there. A sharrow is not going to do anything. And if certain lane shouldn’t be bike in, what do we do? The street that she mentioned are the very few places with usable bike lane in the area! Love Kelly’s immediate response following that. Also, love the bus lane quiz – really shows who knows the area.


Community Meeting on SF General Hospital Parking and Transit

From SF Health Network: City and County of San Francisco (CCSF) is hosting a community meeting to update you on activities and proposed plans for changes at SFGH and in the surrounding vicinity. This meeting will be next Wednesday, September 30th from 6:00 to 7:30 pm in the 2nd floor cafeteria of the San Francisco General Hospital […]

SFMTA Abandons Parking Meter Plans in Dogpatch and Potrero Hill

The SFMTA has given up on its neighborhood-scale plans to install parking meters in the Dogpatch and Portrero Hill, while parking meter approvals in the northeast Mission move forward at a snail’s pace. After two years of tangling with the city, the defenders of dysfunctional free parking have effectively caused a huge setback for progressive […]

Mayor Lee Backs SFPark Dogpatch/Potrero Plan at Supes Meeting

Mayor Ed Lee stood behind the merits of the SFMTA’s SFPark program at a Board of Supervisors meeting today when questioned about the recent backlash against parking meter expansions in the Dogpatch and Potrero Hill neighborhoods. Those proposals have been put on hold while the SFMTA conducts more outreach to neighbors and merchants. During the […]

This Week: Making Bicycling Safer in South/Southeast SF

The SF Bicycle Coalition continues its “Love Your Lanes” bike rides in Districts 10 and 11 this weekend to generate ideas for improving bicycling conditions in the south and southeastern neighborhoods. The District 10 ride will look at ways to create better connections in Bayview and improve connections to the 22nd Street Caltrain station, while the District […]

This Week in Livable Streets Events

This week, speak up for safe bike lanes on 17th Street, become a part of the SF Transit Riders Union, have some pie for a parklet, and take a literature tour of San Francisco. Here are the highlights from the Streetsblog calendar: Monday: 17th Street Bike Lanes Community Meeting. Speak up at this SFMTA meeting […]